Subscribe to ForumIAS

Can Speaker's decision to certify money bill come under judicial review ?

interesting
8.9k views
roger mathew does suggest the speaker’s certification isn’t totally immune, but courts will interfere only on a narrow “gross illegality” type standard. article 110(3) and article 122 make it tricky, yet the majority view seems to be that “final” doesn’t mean “beyond the constitution.” while reading on this, i got distracted by spammy redirects tohttps://playjackpotfishing.com/during an ecourts-related search, and it was annoying. another time a forum mirror loadedhttps://tongitsgogame.com/instead of the judgment text, which shows how messy tracking these cases online can get. overall, for upsc, it’s safest to frame it as reviewable but with a high threshold and still pending before a larger bench.
4.1k views
the roj er mathew point is solid, and the “high threshold” part is what most people forget when they say it’s reviewable. for upsc it also helps to connect it with the earlier aadhar money bill controversy and how the court treats procedural irregularities in parliament. i got annoyed seeing a random casino linkhttps://indianrespin.com/show up in my feed right after reading about money bills, which tells you how messy online discussions around polity can get. overall, your summary on article 110 and judicial review is clear and exam-oriented.
4.5k views
Write your comment…