BRICS Bank & AIIB Bank: Benefits & Concerns – Pointwise, Demystified

Two things have happened recently:

  • BRICS Bank has been formed – with subscription by Brazil, India, Russia, China & South Africa
  • AIIB: The Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank formed by India, China and 19 Asian economies.

Aim of the Regional Banks:

  1. Multilateral Financial Institutions – viz. World Bank & IMF – are West dominated. reforms in governance structure has been so far stalled by Western nations
  2. The Lending Agenda of these MFIs are different from that of the development Agenda of the developing economies.
  3. Lending from MFIs are conditional – acceptance of which may be difficult as has been seen historically (Read Why India Gandhi was forced to devalue currency)
  4. So the quick solution is – Form your own banks to meet your development agenda – primarily infrastructure development

Pros of Regional Banks

This can be derived from the above points itself.

  1. Easy borrowing by developing nations
  2. More democratic control by participants
  3. Borrowing by regional banks from other larger institutions will depend on the sovereign rating of the largest participant – China (both a positive and a negative), hence borrowing will be cheaper for the less developed economies.
  4. Can be used to finance the development of trans continental infrastructure – Like North South Corridor, BMIC Corridor, India-Myanmar- Thailand Trilateral Corridor etc.
  5. Countries need not go for ideological changes for getting aid – No need to open markets , as demanded by WB, IMF etc.

Cons / Negatives of Regional Banks

  1. Banks will be dominated by a single country – say China
  2. Lending may be controlled on the basis of strategic interests – Possible clash between India – China, for instance.
  3. At least the IMF and WB are not dominated by a single interest.
  4. Will the consortium be able to create a huge pool size for funds?

You may add more points , but this article pretty much takes 280 words, excluding this line.