Anthro 2019 mains discussion

Thanks. .@sat_009please discuss all questions of paper 2 here

Please start from 1st question n go on

Yess. . As questions repeat in anthro. . Will be better for future adventure as well

Heckel u explain ur approach inpaper 2 as well

@Anthromanyes

What u have written in contribution of tribals in freedom struggel??

Attempted 3,7,8 in P2
After going through questions i chose the ones which will certainly ensure average marks.. so questions where broad knowledge can b used were chosen..

I don’t know how it’ll be awarded

@sat_009

@Haeckelcontribution of tribes?

@Haeckelattempted 3, 6,8

paper 2 was slightly odd paper 1 was good as compared to that,
paper 2 10 markers were fine.
20 markers were good harappa, tribe nation state and village studies sohanian all fetch good marks
15 markers were too generic very less scope for case studies and indepth analysis in 40 percent questions (impact of media, impact of industrialisation on social life no direct case study yes i have written displacement and impact on villages singur nano etc still not direct linkage with social aspect, tribes in indian stuggle tough to find specific good pointers execpt revolts or rani gadinliu etc

@sat_009kk. We want more detail insight from u

Question by question outline

In media i quoted S c dubey study of impact of media, yv laxman rao study, Reddy studies. .and then explain the detail of impact of media in generic manner. . Only speciality was thinkers and case study of Band darwaja campaign and its impact on socuety

What did you guys write for ethnoarchaeological analysis of hunting activities of contemporary tribal communities?

In tribal revolt also I thought that generic answer can be specialised only by thinkers so Started with BD sharma and his analysis of how forest policies was responsible for the tribal revolt, later on quoted Nk singh and various revolts reasons for it and impact. . Quoted Sachodanand for Tanabhagat oraon and its transformation to socioreligious. . Later on added impact of rise of leadership like rani gaidnlou,gopinath bardoli based on general history knowledge

Attempted 3 6 8 in paper 2. Could have attempted 2 and 7 too but felt comfortable with these.@Haeckel

Feeling like i miss the trick by not attempting 8 . . Must be the loss of 3 to 4 marks atleast

@princessconsuela488inteo ethno archaeology importance
Example lewis bindford study of butchering practices among nanamuit eskimo
Some explanation
Conclusion

@Anthromanat least 7-8 marks it’ll fetch at any cost