@doodlebean@IWRAplz have a look
@doodlebeanthank you mam. What shld come in second part .
@doodlebeanok mam.
@IWRA@doodlebeanMam i face prblm in breaking the ques in parts. In all 3 mains i hv faced this prblm and so i havent clrd mains once. Even for those ques which i have good content i dnt how to approach it, how to break it in parts.
Also i hv one doubt while writing in points do we need to just mention the point or shld we also explain tht point. . Example- Rti will increase transparency.
Is this enough or do i need to also write how rti will increase transparency. Likewise for every point in the ans.
@doodlebeanthank you mam for suggestions and assurance. Will be regular on this thread.
@IWRAthanks sir . Thats very helpful.
@doodlebeanMam what is the difference between NPG and GG
@mahi2501uploading pura hone dijiye fir submit kijiye.
@mahi2501image size badi hogi. Cam scanner mein se scan krke upload kijiyega size choti ho jayegi.
@mahi2501Thanks sirji. I am having prblm with word limit in all my answers. I am working on it.
I did not write conclusion in tht ans . Can we write following as conclusion- Rationality and efficiency not always intertwined . Besides rationality efficency is dependent on other factors like motivation,communication,decision making,ecology etc.
@doodlebeanthank u mam for ur kind words. Learning a lot from you and others on this platform.
Mam wat is diffrence between NPG and good governance
@doodlebeanyes mam
@doodlebeanthanks mam. Actually i was confused between both as they both looked similar
@mahi2501i am also not sure of digital era gov. May be i shld have avoided it. Thanks for reviewing
@IWRAthanks for sharing this sir. Much clr now
@IWRAthanks sir . But its taking around 15 mins to write it. During exam only 7-8 mins available for 10 marker.
@mahi2501sir. U hv covered all pnts. I liked ur conclusion . Few suggestions. Underline ur imp pts. Its a 10 marker so dnt explain in detail each pt like u did for expertise pt. (I hv asked this query to iwra sir. Chk his response in previous pgs). With a diag ur ans would have been catchy.(pardon me its my first review)
@mahi2501thanks. I run out of ideas in 2nd part.
I hv one doubt@IWRA@doodlebeanin this ques do we need to first shw the comparison of classical and behavioural and then shw how it is linked by Simons model or we shld directly write on the linkage part and also same doubt for previous ques on NPS as improvement over NPM, do we need to first explain the concept. Of NPM NPS and then shw how NPS is an improvemnt over NPM or directly start with second part?
@IWRAThank u very much sir.
@mahi2501bhai maine pre ka preparation chalu kr diya hai. Pre ke baad hi abi vapas aaunga. Sgining out bye.
Lets strt . Shld we strt doing chapter wise or solve ques papers.@doodlebean@IWRA@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singh
@Hakunah_Matatai think we shld take chapter wise questions from previous years and of classes on daily basis. Finish paper 1 in 25 to 30 days and paper 2 in 15 to 20 days. Also we can do thinkers simultaneously one thinker in 2 to 3 days. What are ur views on it.
@prowess@Thoroughly_Screwed@ravimeena@iceblock93
I have prepared following time table . All of u r free to amend it.
Paper -1
Ch 1 - 5 days
Ch 3 - 3 days
Ch4 + ch3 of paper 2- 4 days
Ch 5 - 2days
Ch6 - 2days
Ch7 - 2 days
Ch8 - 2 days
Ch 9 + ch 8 of paper 2- 4days
Ch12 + ch9 of paper 2- 4 days
Ch 10- 3days
Ch11 - 2 days
Paper 2
Ch1- 2days
Ch2 - 1 day
Ch4- 2 days
Ch5 -1 day
Ch6- 1 day
Ch7- 2days
Ch 10 - 2 day
Ch11- 2 days
Ch12 -2 day
Ch13- 2days
Ch14 - 2 day
Thinkers for next 10 days
Wilson
Fayol
Taylor
Gulick and urwic
Follet
Weber
Mayo
Waldo
Once it is final then we can prepare detail timetable for the coming week .
@Hakunah_Matataexactly.
If everyone is fine with the given time table. Then we can start today or tomorrow .
Ch1- 5 days
Day 1 - meaning, scope, significance and evolution Thinker - Wilson
Day 2- NPA , blacksburg manifesto, critical choice theory, Thinker - Waldo
Day 3- Public Choice approach, challenges of LPG, Thinker- Taylor
Day 4 - Good governance and its related concepts like governmentality, digital era governance etc
Thinker -Fayol
Day 5- NPM , NPS etc. Thinker - Gulick and urwick
Should we take previous year questions only or both previous years + test series
@Thoroughly_Screwedas u suggest sir. Waldo i took earlier coz of NPA . If u think we shld do it later then its ok . We could do taylor then
@IWRAand@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singhwe will need ur guidance here.
@mahi2501@Hakunah_Matata@LalSalaam@Thoroughly_Screwed@iceblock93and all others.
1 A theory of public administration means in our time a theory of politics also. Comment (1994)
2 Do you think that contemporary Administrative Theory supports the 'art' of public administration and generally tends to place less emphasis on the 'science' of public administration? (1988)
3 "Public administration is the translation of politics into reality that citizens see everyday"(Donald F. Kettl and James W. Fesler) Explain.(2016)
4 "Even after 130 years of its publication, Woodrow Wilsons essay The Study of Administration continues to have great relevance even today." Comment. (2017).
5 " With every major transformation in the applied world of Public Administration, the study of Public Administration has grown in scope and intensity." Discuss the relationship between the evolution of the discipline and profession of Public Administration. (2017)
I will post other ans by night.
@IWRA@Thoroughly_Screwed@iceblock93@mahi2501plz review. This and of others also.
@iceblock93use of NpM , NpS , Npa was nice . Learnt how to interlink from this ans . I would suggest if possible to write on paper.
@Thoroughly_Screwed. I think its just an outline of ur ans . U have covered it nicely. For uploading images@GeorgeReddyhas answered . If u still face the prblm uploading the ans plz do ask sir.
Also@iceblock93and@Thoroughly_Screwedwhen u upload ur ans tag@iwra@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singhand others to review ur ans. Bcoz most of them will not know and review the ans if its not tagged.@mahi2501@LalSalaam@Hakunah_Matata@prowessand others plz start writing. Write atleast one ans today.
@Thoroughly_Screwedi dnt have test papers of other institutes. If u have then u can add questions here.
@iwra@Yo_Yo_Choti_Singhif u could plz explain phenomenological approach and deductive-nomological, inductive- probabilistic concepts.
1 " The Phenomenological approach advocated by the New Public Administration has obstructed the path of theory building in Public Administration." Comment. (2018)
2 "NPA is........ a revolution or radicalism in words , and (at best) status quoist in skills or technologies." (2009)
3 ' Deductive - nomological and inductive - probabilistic approaches dominate NPA' (Marini). Discuss (1987)
4 In what respects is Taylors Scientific Management or Classical motivational theory different from the Classical organizational theory expounded by Gullick, Urwick etc ? (2012)
5 Taylors Scientific Management already offered a humanistic theory of motivation, wih its democratic and participatory emphasis, that was hardly improved on by Elton Mayo and others. Comment (1994)
@IWRA@Thoroughly_Screwed@LalSalaam@Redplz review
@iceblock93@LalSalaami will also participate.
@LalSalaam@Burningdesire@Hakunah_Matata@iceblock93bhai plz chk kr dena . Aur kya add kr sakte iss ans mein.
@LalSalaamthanks for reviewing. I shld have written examples,facts. Will implement ur suggestions in next ans .
Thanks@iceblock93@Burningdesire@Hakunah_Matata. I hv note down all ur points. We had healthy discussion , many ideas,suggestions came out. I think we shld discuss everyday few questions,concepts.
@iceblock93almond and verba talks abt 3 types of pol culture -
parochial- ppl r not aware of govt. Here ppl will follow whatever the govt does. Will have stable govt. No opposition frm ppls side. But not effective democratic govt as lacks ppls support. Top down. Few of the african countries or fused societies.
Subject- ppl are aware of govt, but do not participate. Therefore policies will be top down. Will have stable govt but not effective democratic govt.. most developing countries or prismatic societies
Participative- citizens not only aware of govt but participates in governance. It will have eefective democratic govt but because of over involvement of ppl in governance there will be constant opposition to governments decisions which are against one section of population. Therefore stability will not be their.
Almond and gabriel says to have a civic culture i.e, stable and effective democratic govt a combination of all the above three pol culture is needed , so that people will participate in governance but will also follow decisions which are against one section of population but is in public interest.
I wld have written this . Would have try to add more examples in it.
Speaker om birla has modified few rules and the efficiency of ls has increasedin this budget session 9 legislation passed from 21 which were introduced . This is highest for NDA govt. He removed limit of one hr time for zero hour .many minor changes introduced.
https://rightlog.in/2019/06/speaker-om-birla-parliament-01/
