Subscribe to ForumIAS

What is Mandatory Whip?

Can mandatory whip be issued for cases other than no confidence and confidence motion?

Gochi,upsc2020
6.6k views

4 comments

A whip is a directive from the party that binds party members of a House to obey the line of the party. There are three kinds of whip.

  • A one line whip is issued to inform the members about the vote
  • Two line whip is issued to inform the members to be present inside the House at the time of the vote
  • Three line whip is issued directing members to vote according to the party line. 

Supreme Court inKihoto Holohan vs Zachillhu case, 1992 held that the application of the Tenth Schedule, which subsumes the mandatory whip, is limited to avote on “no-confidence” or  “motion of confidence”in the government or where the motion under consideration relates to a matter which was an integral program or policy of the political party.

If an MP violates the whip of his party, he or she is evicted from the House under the Anti-Defection Law. A three-line whip can be violated only if 1/3rd of the party members of the House decide to vote against the party line.

GaryVee,extinctinwildand1 otherslike this
4.5k views

But in the Kihoto holohan case the directions given by SC were not binding but orbiter dictum ..so what is the present situation? 

4.3k views

But in the Kihoto holohan case the directions given by SC were not binding but orbiter dictum ..so what is the present situation? 

Mandatory whips - No confidence & Any bill that can that requires majority to be proven by the ruling party. 

3k views

مرحبًا بالجميع، أتمنى أن تكونوا بخير وصحة. أود أن أشارك تجربتي الرائعة في لعب روليت اون لاين في United Arab casino. كانت اللعبة مثيرة للغاية والأمور تسير بسلاسة. كما أن الكازينو يوفر تجربة عالية الجودة في جميع الألعاب الأخرى. إذا كنت تبحث عن مكان للعب الكازينو عبر الإنترنت، فإن United Arab casino هو الخيار الأفضل. شكرًا للجميع!

1.4k views
Write your comment…