Anthro 2019 mains discussion

Thanks. .@sat_009please discuss all questions of paper 2 here

Yess. . As questions repeat in anthro. . Will be better for future adventure as well

Heckel u explain ur approach inpaper 2 as well

What u have written in contribution of tribals in freedom struggel??

@sat_009

@Haeckelcontribution of tribes?

@sat_009kk. We want more detail insight from u

Question by question outline

In media i quoted S c dubey study of impact of media, yv laxman rao study, Reddy studies. .and then explain the detail of impact of media in generic manner. . Only speciality was thinkers and case study of Band darwaja campaign and its impact on socuety

In tribal revolt also I thought that generic answer can be specialised only by thinkers so Started with BD sharma and his analysis of how forest policies was responsible for the tribal revolt, later on quoted Nk singh and various revolts reasons for it and impact. . Quoted Sachodanand for Tanabhagat oraon and its transformation to socioreligious. . Later on added impact of rise of leadership like rani gaidnlou,gopinath bardoli based on general history knowledge

Feeling like i miss the trick by not attempting 8 . . Must be the loss of 3 to 4 marks atleast

Ngo wala question plz explain

Ngo question was critical analysis. . So started with few welare works. . Quoted dhebar. . Few examples. . Later on made criticism of it which form bulk of my answer. . Given the case study. .IB report, CAPART study , other criticism of xaxa, dhebar etc

Impact of buddhism i wrote name of tribes. , study of shardukpen tribe by heimendorf and impact. . Explained the impact of buddhist stuapa tradition. . Mahayan sect hinyan sect. . Mahayan predominance i n arunachal region. . How religious centres act as centre of education in form of monastries in spiti valley, quoted yogender singh. . Neo buddhist scholar neera borra. . No impact of neo buddhist caste movement on tribe

Kk. . I was not sure about 8th question. . Nationstate and all that stuff

I made mess of ethnicity and regionalism. . I explained 2 terms diffrently. . Wrote one page on ethnicity with case studies and then regionalism with case studies. . Surely going to get big zero in that

There are enough number of tools, advancement of it but no fossil of man which produces it due to acidic nature of soil. . Also H.Narmadensis which is erectus as per dr.Arun sonakia has cranial capacity exceeds erectus standards(1440cc) so it is often called as primitive h.sapien

Also lack of clear cut demarcation and intermixing of variety of tools. !lack of venus figures lack of substantial no. Of bone tools etc are problems

@Valar_morghulis-i have written only this much of problems. Somebody can throw more light on it

Village studies main kon konse concepts likhe sabne..

@sat_009yess. . Bohot likha. . Pura topic pucha tha. .

I wrote great n little tradition and its use was done by singer n marriot. . Not write parochi n universali in words. . Also i wrote cosmopolitisation of village

Internet n braintree, muniratnam se kiya. . Ask sat009 for his source too

1st timer with anthro. . So dont know much about scoring pattern n all

Attempted all 250 marks in both papers but 100 marks of it like polymorphism,impact of buddhism,regionalism ,classification of languages,ethnoarcharlogy,levis strauss model of kinship etc is poorly adressed i felt

@Tetsukoi wrote about fossils that are found viz australopithecus by leaky, homo habbilus and homo erectus. . Then about oldovian culture tool tradition of hand axes, cleavers about climate of paleolithic era, brief about migration from oldovia gorge to other regions due to climate change, concluded by saying olduvai gorge is craddle of human evolution. . Drawn diagram of oldovian tools thats it

@sat_009bhai. . 250 bhi mile to khush hu mai. . Itna to bohot hota hai

@sat_009UPSC is all about surprises. . So fingures crossed . . Cant be so sure about marks

Facial reconstruction a method used in forensic anthropology. . Methods of facial reconstruction, can be used to get idea about earler hominid faces,identification of mutilated bodies,3D facial reconstruction. . Early inspiration from facial mask studies of franz boas

I wrote about wrong thinker but wrote the theory right . . Both concept. !

Question was surprising

What u people have written in schemes of tribal welfare. . Critical analysis

Impact of industrialisation on village social and economic

@sat_009i have started from 5 th schedule 6th scheduel, sches related to education, health, tribal subplan, trifed etc. . And xaxa commitee reccomendation. , space was lacking here

@sat_009wrote on simailar line. Economic impact on agri ,traders ,women,schedule caste,jajmani etc and case studies of few which i know. . Social impact on similar line family,kinship,women,social systems like jajmani,caste structure etc and case studies of few. . Lack of space was the issue

@Yes_I_am_in- kyun maje le rahe ho bhai

Bhai average marks mill jai basss. . Baki jyada khwaish nahi hai

Bhai i dont know how upsc award marks. . So dont encourage false hope in me . .

@sat_009Bhai aapne jitne marks bataye usme to mera rank aa jayega. . Hahahahaha

@Haeckel- bhai ab tum pakka maja le rahe ho

Kuch nahi bhai.. . Sab thik hoga. .

@Haeckel-good stratergy

@sat_009good attitude by u bro. . U r less critical but more a oprimistic man for me. . Started preparing my DAf questions just because of the confidence by you. . Shame on all the critics of u