Friends, I need some help.
This articlefrom August 2022 says:
>>> The personal law do not fall within the definition of ‘laws’ under Article 13 of the Constitution. The validity of a personal law cannot be challenged on the basis of fundamental rights enshrined in the Constitution.
The above position was based on a Judgement of Bombay High Court, in Narasu Appa Mali Case (1951).
HOWEVER, in Sabarimala Case (2018),Justice Chandrachud, who was part of Majority opinion, had said:
>>> Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, in his separate opinion, held that the reasoning given in the Narasu Appa Mali judgment of the Bombay High Court in 1951 was based on flawed premises. Immunising customs and usages, like the prohibition of women in Sabarimala, takes away the primacy of the Constitution.
>>> “Custom or usage cannot be excluded from ‘laws in force’. The decision in Narasu also opined that personal law is immune from constitutional scrutiny. This detracts from the notion that no body of practices can claim supremacy over the Constitution and its vision of ensuring the sanctity of dignity, liberty and equality,” Justice Chandrachud wrote.
Toh, my Question is: Does Justice Chandrachud's Opinion Invalidate the 1951 Judgment?
Does definition of 'Law', with respect to Article 13, include 'Personal Law' or not?
Narasu Appa Mali is still valid. Personal laws were discussed in both Triple Talqa & Sabarimala judgment but they were not in question.
Judges trying to become netas of wokes cause unnecessary confusion! Either you test the validity of law or not, yh bhashanbazi kyo karni h.
@Naadan_Parinda I can totally relate bro, because this shaadi wala conversation happens every alternate day at my home, and it ends with a conflict.But, at the end as you said Zidd hai ab paper nikalnaa. Ab paper chahiye toh chahiye. This reminds me of a song. The line goes "zidd hai ab toh hai khud ko mitaana, hona hai tujh mein fannaa.." ab bas yahi Krna hai.!Btw, i appreciate your decision of being bold and selfish for a moment and making huge difference in your life. All the best Man.. !
And Thanks bro...🤝
I like Amir Khan‘s Sarfarosh more than Fana. 😄
Not working for me eitherIs the My Courses Tab functioning properly or only I am facing a problem going inside a course?
Hey, everyone! I made this account using a Temporary Phone No, from some site I don't remember, to safeguard my Privacy. I believe in Free Access to Resources. So, if you see any posts from this account Selling anything or trying to scam, they wouldn't be from me. Someone would have gained unauthorized access to this account. Best recourse to prevent such a thing would be to delete the account, but Forum doesn't provide that option.
Saturday sham aur Sunday padh kaise lete ho yaar. My brain stops working after 7 pm on a Saturday and on Sunday toh refuses to register it's existence. Please give some tips, I REALLY need to change this.
Schedule a test on Sunday? Mains/prelims ya both?
Saturday sham ko start revising for the test, Sunday morning dedo, Sunday evening model answers dekhlo/ evaluate karo.
Sending love and light ('(:'(:
15/10
- Newspaper
- optional
- Answer writing
- Revision
Achieved all targets.
Talked to friend over phone. It always go on for 2-3 hours, the reason why I call them after 3-4 months (It was less today, however).
@dravidpujara my iPad keeps hanging while playing video. It’s okay on laptop.
@RiRi I didn’t realise that it is Saturday today, until I read your comment. Apne liye to sare din same hain.
Saturday sham aur Sunday padh kaise lete ho yaar. My brain stops working after 7 pm on a Saturday and on Sunday toh refuses to register it's existence. Please give some tips, I REALLY need to change this.
My Brain stops working after 4 PM EVERY DAY 😆
Hey, everyone! I made this account using a Temporary Phone No, from some site I don't remember, to safeguard my Privacy. I believe in Free Access to Resources. So, if you see any posts from this account Selling anything or trying to scam, they wouldn't be from me. Someone would have gained unauthorized access to this account. Best recourse to prevent such a thing would be to delete the account, but Forum doesn't provide that option.
Made a start. First half was okay but slow and second half was non existent.
Repeating the targets.
Good day people!
Finished the forestry targets for the day but not a lot else. Still, I hope that I pick up the rhythm tomorrow.
Targets:
- Finish ODE
- Forestry - 9, 10, 11
- Newspaper
Edit: Couldn't study in the morning due to external reasons, won't be able to do maths but will work on the other two targets.
Back on forumias after a while, Aka Juggernaut here. Hope you guys are doing well.
Apologies for breaking the flow of this thread,
Needed some help with recommendations onGS mainsprep. Any good content building and feedback programs in the market you guys know about? Also, have a limit to spend around 20K. Need to cover topics one by one. (any hacks would also do. )
Thanks for your time.