Subscribe to ForumIAS

Civil Services Mains 2020 Results: In or Out ? Way ahead, gratitude and Pain

The Civils Mains result has been declared. This thread is for sharing your grief , joy , mixed feelings - absolutely anything and everything.



jack_Sparrow,musaand60 otherslike this
2.2m views

5.3k comments

Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.
AzadHindFauz,Inselberg
6.1k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

Have heard good reviews about this one. (Can't certify personally. Have not read it. But isspey bohot din se nazar hai meri)


https://www.amazon.in/dp/9353333091/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_glt_fabc_3FNN37T6M9S87KBS4M6N

Just_relentless,whatonlyand1 otherslike this
4.5k views
» show previous quotes

Have heard good reviews about this one. (Can't certify personally. Have not read it. But isspey bohot din se nazar hai meri)


https://www.amazon.in/dp/9353333091/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_glt_fabc_3FNN37T6M9S87KBS4M6N

Wow! Very interesting. Didn’t know Varun Gandhi wrote too! Will check out.

6k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

Have heard good reviews about this one. (Can't certify personally. Have not read it. But isspey bohot din se nazar hai meri)


https://www.amazon.in/dp/9353333091/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_glt_fabc_3FNN37T6M9S87KBS4M6N

Wow! Very interesting. Didn’t know Varun Gandhi wrote too! Will check out.

 in that case you must listen to the first half of this speech. He is a good orator as well. 




AzadHindFauz,whatonlyand3 otherslike this
4.4k views
https://swarajyamag.com/politics/long-read-why-upscs-archaic-selection-process-needs-a-complete-overhaul

Talk about Shallow Articles. Proper Uncle level post-dinner walk arguments. 

The problem with the general attitude is that to sound intellectual, everybody says reforms needed. But only a  few have the intellectual depth to suggest how. This article is devoid of that. No data, no comparative analysis anything.

One of the "key reforms" mentioned is to make 2-year work experience compulsory for applying. A country where 90% work is in the informal sector and rampant unemployment prevails. Plus, how hard is it to forge a work XP. certificate In the informal sector.

This is why journalism is losing badly. Too many average minds entering, who measure their intellectual depth not by hours of research, but by retweets.

sonder,KatnissEverdeenand20 otherslike this
4.4k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

I will strongly suggest "Everybody loves a good drought " by P. Sainath. I have read that book once  and it's awesome. Tells you the ground realities of India. P. Sainath is one of the best minds in India when it comes to agriculture. You can also see some of his YouTube lectures .

Short summary of evolution can be found anywhere but for proper understanding history of agriculture, I don't think any mainstream book will do justice to this topic. If you are interested you can read some proper academic books on History of Indian economy. 

Aurora,Rambo93and3 otherslike this
4.4k views
@Usain_bolt its a good read. 


Usain_bolt,
3.9k views
@whatonly you can read essays from getting india back on track. they have some good opinions, although background and history is not covered thoroughly 


Just_relentless,whatonlyand2 otherslike this
3.9k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

Have heard good reviews about this one. (Can't certify personally. Have not read it. But isspey bohot din se nazar hai meri)


https://www.amazon.in/dp/9353333091/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_glt_fabc_3FNN37T6M9S87KBS4M6N

@12432TrivendrumRajdhani thanks for  A Rural Manifesto, it has been lying there unread for a year by now.

@whatonly 

Try,

  1. Everyone loves a good drought
  2. Poor Economics

Recommending these as Agriculture in general - being associated with Rural India & Poverty, and others.


12432TrivendrumRajdhani,whatonly
3.6k views

Thanks@Usain_bolt @Rambo93 @Just_restless 

Have read ELAGD and Poor Economics recently. Agreed entirely on ELAGD :) Poor Economics too was a very good study of poverty.

Neyawn,Integerand1 otherslike this
5.6k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

Have heard good reviews about this one. (Can't certify personally. Have not read it. But isspey bohot din se nazar hai meri)


https://www.amazon.in/dp/9353333091/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_glt_fabc_3FNN37T6M9S87KBS4M6N

Wow! Very interesting. Didn’t know Varun Gandhi wrote too! Will check out.

I remember when this book was published, Sriram Sir of Sriram IAS Institute said he will read it and update his notes from this book.

After two weeks, he came and said book is amazingly wonderful but he is not sure if Feroze Varun Gandhi has written it :D

12432TrivendrumRajdhani,whatonly
3.6k views
.
EiChan,Monkey D. Luffyand4 otherslike this
4k views

@whatonly I have troubled you so many times with my stupid questions that now you telling me thanks feels a bit weird 😃

EiChan,whatonly
3.9k views
@nerdfighter thank you! And yeah! Listening to him is really such a privilege. I got to hear a CEA speak live once but unfortunately it was not him :(


12432TrivendrumRajdhani,nerdfighter
5.2k views
.
sonder,EiChanand1 otherslike this
3.6k views
Deleted


I used ratta last time in 9th and 10th like around 10 years ago and whatever I have done later on in my life, never required rote learning. 

My optional already has lot of things which I need to rattafy and I am not able to do that satisfactorily. And now I am realising need to rattafy in GS too ? What all I need to rattafy ? data? committee ? what else ? as already it is huge size. And if i am not seeing it month later, definitely I am going to forget.


On a lighter note 

might be useful for essay

"Never memorize something that you can look up." ~ Albert Einstein

peterparker,
3.2k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

I will strongly suggest "Everybody loves a good drought " by P. Sainath. I have read that book once  and it's awesome. Tells you the ground realities of India. P. Sainath is one of the best minds in India when it comes to agriculture. You can also see some of his YouTube lectures .

Short summary of evolution can be found anywhere but for proper understanding history of agriculture, I don't think any mainstream book will do justice to this topic. If you are interested you can read some proper academic books on History of Indian economy. 

This is a brilliant read!

However, it’s quite dated since it came out nearly 25 years ago if I’m not mistaken. Also, it’s not limited to agriculture. If you want to really delve deep into the topic and have a more holistic picture, I would recommend the Dalwai panel report. It’s daunting in size, but there is a lot that you can skip. :)


ssver2,EiChanand6 otherslike this
6.8k views

https://www.newindianexpress.com/nation/2021/may/23/chhattisgarh-cm-bhupesh-baghel-orders-removal-of-surajpur-collector-for-slapping-youth-2306442.html

This news made me sad. Unfortunately, civil services are still seen as legacy of colonial era with elitist mindset and lack of respect for common citizen. More incidents are alsocoming

I hope aspirants among us who clear this exam won't indulge in this kind of behavior.

While nothing can justify the collector's behavior, I felt that the humongous pressure and frustration of handling Covid had a huge role in making him behave like that.



Dionysus,Villanelleand2 otherslike this
5.9k views
And like this the thread completed 150 pages :)
Mariposa27,whatonly
6k views
Hello gentle friends of forum, can anyone recommend a good book on Indian agriculture? Its history, economy, problems etc. Looking for helpful analysis and suggestions related to the sector.

I will strongly suggest "Everybody loves a good drought " by P. Sainath. I have read that book once  and it's awesome. Tells you the ground realities of India. P. Sainath is one of the best minds in India when it comes to agriculture. You can also see some of his YouTube lectures .

Short summary of evolution can be found anywhere but for proper understanding history of agriculture, I don't think any mainstream book will do justice to this topic. If you are interested you can read some proper academic books on History of Indian economy. 

This is a brilliant read!

However, it’s quite dated since it came out nearly 25 years ago if I’m not mistaken. Also, it’s not limited to agriculture. If you want to really delve deep into the topic and have a more holistic picture, I would recommend the Dalwai panel report. It’s daunting in size, but there is a lot that you can skip. :)


I have heard about this report only in mock MCQs and paper columns. Never bothered to go in much detail. However, now given the postponement I will try to skim through its contents.

Thanks for the suggestion bhai😊

EiChan,Patootieand1 otherslike this
6.7k views
Write your comment…