Subscribe to ForumIAS

Doubt Clearance Thread: UPSC 2021

What will be the answer? Please explain the reason behind as well. Thanks!

3.1k views
@MarcusA even I think the same. Last year, RBI through swap agreement purchased excess forex from CBs under swap agreement and as a result, the forex crossed the $500 billion mark. But the answer key states the answer is option A. Now in the question it isn’t specified if the RBI is categorically buying or selling dollars. Because if RBI will sell forex under swap agreement then dollar supply will increase(statement 1). If RBI will buy forex then Ruppee supply will increase as well as RBI’s forex( statement 2). So as the question is not specifying precisely if the dollars are being bought or sold, it mentions sell-buy swap, then wont it be feasible to go with the option 1&2 ie B?  Such a basic question it is but still messing up the mind -.- 


3.1k views

Yes it is a swap agreement but it does involve buying and selling(if buying now then will have to sell at a later date and vice versa). 

The statement 1 is correct in the sense lets say there is a dollar shortage in forex market due to increase in demand. Now there is also high deposits prevailing with the banks in the economy. Now what RBI will do is that it will swap these deposits with the dollar. It can also be said that the RBI is selling the dollars to the CBs. The selling of dollars by the RBI will lead to increase in dollar supply in the economy/ forex market. 

Coming to the second statement, the statement just says Forex will increase. How will the forex increase? Who is or will pump  new forex in the economy? The cumulative forex of India is going to remain same no? Had the statement mentioned that RBI’s forex will increase then toh we could have said for sure that yes it is 100% correct. But the statement says that forex will increase. How will it increase? Think and let me know too.

Someone else forwarded me this question. I have requested for the solution too. I’ll share as soon as I’ll get it. 

3.1k views

is right to health  considered a fr under art21 ?



3k views
@NKS_PSIR You are right but it is not necessary no that under this sell-buy swap, RBI will always sell dollars to buyers. Assume that there is excess dollars prevailing in the forex market/ economy, then RBI will purchase the dollars and will supply domestic currency in return. In March 2020, RBI conducted this deal for a 6 month tenor in which it supplied dollars in the economy. Similar swap agreement was done in March 2019 for 3 year tenor and in that agreement RBI purchased dollars and supplied Indian rupees. I’m sharing a link, have a look.


2.9k views

sbhatisaid

Can anyone explain what a management information system (MIS) is, with some real world examples?

MIS is something which generates information which supports management function and facilitates decision- making process.


Consider government as an Organization and vaccinating the citizens against covid to be the objective of this organisation  to be achieved, COWIN portal can be considered as a MIS which generates various kinds of information like stock availability, numbers of jabs given, wastage of vaccine doses and likewise, all such information helping in management of the vaccination strategy as well as providing inputs to facilitate coordination among various agencies of the organisation ie the government involved in vaccination process, as well as providing inputs for future course of action/s based on real time scenarios and all of these above mentioned things finally contributing to the ultimate objective of the govt(org) that is to vaccinate the citizens.

2.7k views

D503said

What explains the aversion of shanta kumar committee and niti aayog towards NFSA. Shanta kumar recommended curtailing coverage from present 66.6% to 40% and niti also made a similar call recently. And is DBT a real substitute for food grains? Given the patriarchal nature wouldnt the money be controlled by male of the family and I know it's a cynical view but how would you ensure that the money actually goes towards nutrition and not towards alcohol, and other vices or priorities. Further , when govt provides food theoretically there's some minimum standard , regardless of how much the inflation is people get food. If DBT isn't inflation adjusted people won't be able to purchase food.m when tomatoes go 100 and onions 80.

And This is being recommended when GHI ranking shows india as one of the hungriest country of the world. Further, CoVid ke time par when the even the much vaunted middle class has shrunk by 3 crore and lining up for ration, niti aisa kyu suggest krega.

Give me counter arguments.

https://m.timesofindia.com/business/india-business/hunger-crisis-forces-even-middle-class-indians-to-line-up-for-rations/amp_articleshow/84399671.cms

The DBT will be given on the basis of ration cards, as it is related to food provisioning. The ration cards are issued in the name of the female head of the household. The ration card has linked to it the bank account of the female head under whose name the ration card is issued. The DBT will be made to this bank account only and most of these bank accounts would be under the PM Jan Dhan Yojana regime and hence I think the DBT funds would be under the direct disposal of these female heads only in most of the cases barring some exceptions and they will decide on how to spend the amount received via this DBT.

And though DBT has several flaws in it but still it is a potential way forward keeping in mind the corruption, ill practices and the discretions the food grain allotters/distributors enjoy under the existing food grain provisioning system.

2.6k views
@D503 Agreed on the earning part.


The quest for independent decision-making of women gender reminds me of a recent data point coverage of the Hindu wherein it was stated that as per NFHS 5 survey, health outcomes were better for those women who took independent health decisions as compared to those women whose health decisions were taken by their husbands.


But such independence of decision-making is not the sole panacea to all the problems out there. It has to be coupled up with the ability of women to make rational decisions with the resources they have, though limited they may be. For example, if they are getting some amount as DBT for buying food grains but instead they are buying cosmetics like lipstick and makeup instead with that money to flaunt among the neighbouring aunties of the gully, I guess they are at fault for doing so.


Coming to the UBI part, again this has to be viewed wrt rational decision making. Cash transfers are indeed a positive move, condition being the amount is utilised for genuine purposes. For eg, if we go as per NFSA act, majorly, 3 items are provisioned, vis, wheat, rice and pulses. But if rather than providing these commodities to the households directly, if we provide them with an equivalent or a higher amount as a cash transfer, the receiving household would have greater options to spend this money upon. They can either buy these basic food grains, or they can go for other healthy and nutritious stuffs like fruits, vegetables, eggs, diary and likewise. But again, inflation has to be indexed no matter what as we all know how the prices of even the necessities are sky rocketing these days. So, conclusively, UBI, or any cash transfer per say, isn’t that bad an option. It does, to a major extent, depend upon the rationality of the person at the receiving end who is to spend the money, and independence wrt this decision making, plays a vital role. 


I would also like to say that food grain provisioning by the government, to an extent, seems to be a kind of monopoly to me, and an antidote to this monopoly is the practice of Public Choice approach wherein citizens are provided with different alternatives/choices, with the inclusion of private domain. And cash transfers seem to be a medium for such kind of approach as cash at hand gives people scope to exercise choices, expecting the choices being made are logical and rational.


P.S. Thanks for the compliment bhai. I too have come to a realisation that many of the knowledge we assume that might be content enriching for the answers/exam, actually do not provide to be of much use when it comes to ground reality and to be honest, this feeling sucks :/

3.3k views

D503said

What explains the aversion of shanta kumar committee and niti aayog towards NFSA. Shanta kumar recommended curtailing coverage from present 66.6% to 40% and niti also made a similar call recently. And is DBT a real substitute for food grains? Given the patriarchal nature wouldnt the money be controlled by male of the family and I know it's a cynical view but how would you ensure that the money actually goes towards nutrition and not towards alcohol, and other vices or priorities. Further , when govt provides food theoretically there's some minimum standard , regardless of how much the inflation is people get food. If DBT isn't inflation adjusted people won't be able to purchase food.m when tomatoes go 100 and onions 80.

And This is being recommended when GHI ranking shows india as one of the hungriest country of the world. Further, CoVid ke time par when the even the much vaunted middle class has shrunk by 3 crore and lining up for ration, niti aisa kyu suggest krega.

Give me counter arguments.

https://m.timesofindia.com/business/india-business/hunger-crisis-forces-even-middle-class-indians-to-line-up-for-rations/amp_articleshow/84399671.cms

The DBT will be given on the basis of ration cards, as it is related to food provisioning. The ration cards are issued in the name of the female head of the household. The ration card has linked to it the bank account of the female head under whose name the ration card is issued. The DBT will be made to this bank account only and most of these bank accounts would be under the PM Jan Dhan Yojana regime and hence I think the DBT funds would be under the direct disposal of these female heads only in most of the cases barring some exceptions and they will decide on how to spend the amount received via this DBT.

And though DBT has several flaws in it but still it is a potential way forward keeping in mind the corruption, ill practices and the discretions the food grain allotters/distributors enjoy under the existing food grain provisioning system.

Having in her account won't ensure she spends it. Authority of males in the family has to be taken into consideration.

Agreed. That’s why I typed there will be few exceptions.

Also, in the pursuit of finding some numerical backing in order to make sure that what all I was conveying was even making sense or not, I came across this 👇🏼


Source:- https://www.moneycontrol.com/news/trends/current-affairs-trends/national-family-health-survey-2019-20-number-of-bank-accounts-owned-operated-by-women-grows-6231791.html

@D503  same here as well bhai! 🍻

2.8k views

District judge qualifications in Laxmikant:-



If I go as per the first qualification(in the red box), then why the answer of the below question is D, all correct?




2.8k views

Who all are included in the Antyodaya Anna Yojana (AAY) scheme?

A table in class 9th economic ncert says poorest of the poor.
Department of Food and public distribution website lists several categories.
An institute’s explanation says, in 2006, all BPL households plus HIV positive people are now included in AAY category.( the DFPD website has information till budget of 2005-06).


2.8k views

Are subsidies part of transfer payment?





2.8k views

Are subsidies part of transfer payment?





A transfer payment is a one-way payment to a person or organization which has given or exchanged no goods or services for it. 

Generally, the phrase "transfer payment" is used to describe government payments to individuals through social programs such as welfare, student grants, and even Social Security. However, government payments to corporations—including unconditional bailouts and subsidies—are not commonly described as transfer payments.

Source: Investopedia


Still confused :/


Source- Wikipedia


Source- Encyclopedia.com

3.6k views
@Caffeinity By devaluation, you essentially reducing the purchasing power of the currency. Imagine a pie that equally divided into four parts. Now each part is 1/4th of the pie. Now if you slice it twice in such a manner that each part is 1/8th, obviously the piece remains one, but its 'value' decreases. If you had promised someone to give '02 'slices of your pie, you would obviously prefer to divide it into 8 slices than 4 to give them a lesser share. 
Similarly, if a govt has borrowed let's say 100000 INR, they can devalue the currency to their advantage. If each USD was worth 50 rupees earlier (assume), now if rupee is devalued such that 1 USD = 100 rupees. Then, when the govt repays the fixed debt, what was effectively worth 2000 USD now is worth 1000 only. Hence, burden reduced. 


Devalued currency leads to increase in exports.

Higher exports bring in more forex.

Higher forex will increase the repayment ability wrt foreign loan.

Higher ability to repay eventually leads to reduction in  sovereign debt burden.

Is  this a right way to think as well?

3.5k views
@TheNotorious I am not very sure of this relationship. China is notorious for manipulating currency to promote exports, but as@sstarrr and@balwintejas have explained, that won't help in case of non-yuan denominated debt. 


As per RBI report on India’s external debt, Debt in terms of USD has the maximum share(more than 50%).

Im not sure what is the major currency which India uses for global trade but worldwide, USD is the most transacted currency globally. Plus, wrt India’s forex, though there are many currencies under Foreign Currency Assets, but ultimately they are converted to USD. So due to the above two reasons, I’m assuming India mostly deals in USD(I may be totally wrong here).

So, if currency is devaluated, it will boost exports. Exports will bring in more forex( assuming USD due to the above mentioned reason that ultimately all foreign currencies are converted into USD under foreign currency asset section of rbi’s forex reserve)and since as per RBI’s report the USD dominates India’s external debt, so more influx of  forex (more USD) due to higher exports, will enable India to make more payments wrt it’s external debt, hence reducing debt burden.

3.3k views
WHAT IS MEANT BY PROVISIONING OF LOANS?

Hypothetically assume a bank received 100₹ by a single person as deposit and decided to lend these 100₹ to 10 different people(₹10 each). 


Now the bank again receives 100₹ as deposits and  decides to lend this ₹100 amount to same 10 people as well.


But this time, 2 out of 10 people defaulted while repayment of loans which were sanctioned out of initial ₹100 deposited amount. So this time, the bank will lend only ₹80 out of the new 100₹ to 8 people and not complete ₹100 because bank was not able to recover ₹20 from the earlier lent amount, so it is keeping aside ₹20 from the new ₹100 deposit and lending ₹80 only.


The bank has to return the initial ₹100 deposited by the person as well at some point in time. If the bank lends entire 100₹ amount this time too, there will be a deficit of ₹20 ( one which weren’t repaid by 2 borrowers). 


So to balance the loss of  non recovery of ₹20, the bank is lending 80₹ this time. This reduction of 20₹ in lending amount from the new deposit of ₹100 is called provisioning.

3.2k views
Can anyone provide a document which has details of all the international organisations like asean, eu and stuff. 

La Ex - RRP 2021 International Groupings.pdf

2.7k views
Out of union, state and concurrent list, which list has more items for taxation? 

State(18) >Union(13) >Concurrent (1)

Source- Laxmikant 6th edition Centre-State Relations chapter.

2.7k views
@TheNotorious any clue from where to get all rrp pdfs ?


https://www.instamojo.com/Laexcellence/?ref=offer_page 😸

2.8k views

Class 11th ncert “constitution at work”, chapter 4, page 86.

why is it written “other than money bill” ?

It should be constitutional amendment bill in place of money bill right? 


2.4k views

Alexrsaid

@Neyawn Sorry Sir , I didn't raise my question in a meaningful way. Kindly let me know , will the attempt be counted by UPSC if a candidate appear in none of the papers(GS + CSAT) (absent for both sittings )??


No.

Understand it this way.

The counting of attempt has got to do with the signing of attendance sheet/s.

If attendance sheet is  signed in both the papers, attempt will be counted.

If attendance sheet is signed in any of the two papers, attempt will be counted.

If attendance sheet is signed in none of the two papers (the case that you are talking about), attempt will not be counted.

2.7k views

Cannot find any reliable/updated compilation of  mineral resources and their largest producer/s(in India as well as worldwide). Created my own list for quick revision from various sites but not sure of how accurate my drafted information is. Please have a look and point out if there is/are any incorrect info in this; would be of great help.

The red star indicates largest producer.


Mineral Resources.pdf


P.S. If anyone has made a summary of Indian Minerals Yearbook 2019, kindly share please.



4k views

IN MID LATITUDES, SALINITY INCREASES UPTO 35 METRE DEPTH AND THEN DECREASES. 

Is there any good soul who could care to explain this statement to me?? 
Thanks in advance :)


Not sure if the doubt is clear now or not but as I did this topic recently, I’ll try to explain it.


Some pointers:-


  • Withincreasein temperature, there isincreasein salinity due to increase in evaporation.
  • Withincreasein fresh water/precipitation, there isdecreasein salinity.


Explanation:-


Mid latitude regions(both north and south) receivemostsunlight during solstice(summer and winter likewise),as compared to other latitudes. Also, because there isno cloud formationin these regions(because these are zones ofhigh pressure(convergence in upper atmosphere))where winds sink), the ocean water here receivedirectsunlight, henceraisingthe sea surface temperature(due to these reasons, ocean water at mid latitudes areHOTTEST).


Keep in mind here that equator too receive direct sunlight but salinity here islowerwhen compared to mid latitude because equatorial regions are4 o clock showerregions due to formation ofcumulonimbus cloudsabove them, so precipitation heredecreasessalinity.


It is also that withincrease in depth of ocean, there isdecrease in temperature, so if temp is decreasing, so will the salinity. Hence at mid latitudes, salinity increases up to a depth and after that, itstarts to decline with increase in depth. However at poles, this(increase in depth->decrease in salinity), do notoccur. The surface ocean water at poles areLEASTsaline because ofinflux of freshwaterviamelting of glaciers. But after a depth(calledHALOCLINE), there is anincreasein salinity because there isno addition of fresh waterat that level. Post the HALOCLINE, from where the Dark region starts, salinity is atuniformlevel, both at poles and equator.

p.s sorry for such Chipka chipka sentences. I tried boldening the important keywords but it ended up this way. Editing it will consume more time so please excuse me.

2.6k views

86 answer ??

Legal/Statutory right under RPA, 1951.

hence D.

4k views
@TheNotorious Official UPSC answer is C-constitutional right


Han ji dekha Mai Abhi net pey

3.9k views

Please have a look and point out if there is any wrong info in the list. Thank you.

Leading producers of agri products.pdf

2.9k views

Egrets and Buffaloes share Commensalism.

Oxpeckers and Zebras share Mutualism.

why? What is the difference?

2.8k views
@MaeveWiley I searched but it is showing that egrets also eat bugs from water buffalo?


Then this will be Mutualism.


https://socratic.org/questions/if-cattle-egrets-removed-ticks-from-cape-buffalo-would-their-relationship-still-#400711


3.5k views

Will it be right to say :-

if Egret is using Buffalo to scout insects  on ground then it will be commensalism.

if Egret is eating the insects lying on the Buffalo, then it will be mutualism because  it is helping the Buffalo in grooming?

3.4k views
agree 
I was talking about externalities which make this exam more complex for aspirants, the FOMO 

there wasn't need of such long post, mains k time chal jata :P



Long toh long, bhai ne Chinese CSE ke questions upar sey aur daal diye.

Meri CSAT ko leke phati padi hai, Mujhe cube and dice ke questions practice  karne thay par Abhi Mai Gaokao ka sample test de raha hu  😹😹😹


3.5k views
@TheNotorious yeh kaisa procrastination hai bhai lmao


Mujhe khud nahi pata 😹

3k views

One source says Greater One Horned Rhino is the largest species of rhino.

Another source says White Rhino is second largest land mammal after African elephant.

Which species is the largest then? Greater One Horned or white?

3.6k views
Write your comment…