@al_biruni
I think paper 1 first instance looks Easy but comments are not so easy to recall the term .Hindi medium students also got confused in AMENSALISM question and the negative impact will spill over other question . I am hoping 130+...
2nd paper was scorable 5 maps .... Expecting 150+...
..........amensalism question also hurting me I am a hindi medium student and I read this word amensalism (हिन्दी म सहजीविता था जो कि mutualism होता ह , amensalism की हिंदी असहभोजीता होती ह ) prelims ke bad pde nhi the so amensalim and comensalism m confuse ho gye and messed up ......अब फील होता ह की हिंदी के सब्द के अनुसार answer दे दिया होता तो भी शायद अच्छे नम्बर मिल जाते ।।
@Rags240 marks in 1st paper and 2nd 250 ( only 5 maps
@Hartshornephretic eruption
@Hartshornerulayega kya yar ab ....Isme fenka h tikka idea se ..........nrr m maine likha tha a women in her reproductive age m net reproductive birth kitne deti h ..........And linked with tfr ......Answer was not exact but near the answer .....आपने क्या लिखा ह ?
@Hartshorneआप कितना एक्सपेक्ट कर रहे हो मार्क्स ?
@Hartshorneactually my marks expections are based on last year marking not 2017 based ....
2016 --106,129
2017---86,131
2018---123,148...
......On the basis of 2017 marking 1st paper m 123 nhi aane chaiye the 2018 m .....But esa lgta h jin question m quality achi hoti h wha really m ache number milte h ....2nd paper m 2016,2017 m maine pura paper attempt kia and mapping bhi 7-8 se km nhi thi but number itne nhi the ....Last year time ki kmi se 1 question 20 marks wale m answer kafi km likha and one 15 marks m only flow chart .....While nipah viras wala question was below the average .......
1st paper m as compare to last year bde questions sbhi ache hue h ...Comments m loss hua (phretic ,nrr ,amensalism ) ...But last year bhi davis wale question m maine critique nhi kia jo core demand thi , eurocentricity wala question I left , cobar and triwartha m some fundamental mistakes , ek question m only flow chart bnaya tha (lack of time ),exopolis wala question
Is like this year's NRR wala , and I was not so satisfied.......
BAKI AAPKO PTA UPSC KA KUCH NHI KH SKTE ,KYA PTA ACHA LGNE PR BHI NUMBER KM AAYE ...M TO BS NEGATIVE EXPECTION NHI KRNA CHAHTA SO MARKS THORE JYADA BTA RHA HU .........
@Hartshorne3,6,7
@Hartshornesome ways ....amensalism question is example of that ....Last year bhi environment education ke 3rd part m loss hua muje
@Hartshorneyeah ....It's same 2maps (rainfall pattern +regional distribution) + maps of vegetation with mountain and non -mountain vegetation...
@Ragsyeah ...i am hoping for 130+ ,150+ or minimum 271 that was my score of last year....
@Scorpion888noor ...eurocentricity wala question i left .....And megalopolis and exopolis wale question m gadbad .....davis wale m criticise nHi kia, triwartaha and kober wale m basic point m blundr ,envir edu wale m 3rd part m main demand nhi likha (due to hindi word sarokar),population wale question m only flow chart due to lack of time ,8(a ..Likh dia pura welfare geography but esa lga main question demand puri nhi ...
AND ACCORDING TO 2017 MARKING (86 MARKS I got ..Hope was about 110 )...i was. Hopping for 100-110 marks for 2018 paper ...But surprisingly i got 123
...So on that basis ....This year ...phretic left, nrr not good,amensalism hindi ki karan kharab (i wrote on सहजीविता),PET avg. , Rest were good.........But ...Feeling ye h ki bde question last year se better hue h ...Comments m kuch loss h ...Overall last year se better ki ummid h baki kuch kh nhi skte
@Ragsbhai gs m itne marks aa jaye to dikkat kya hogi .....Hindi medium m to it will be rarest of rare ...According to last year gs marking .
@Ragsit's possible bro and toppers ke aate bhi h ....And without selection walo ke bhi aate h I know 2-3 person who got good marks in 16,17 gs paper ........Bs mere nhi aaye kbhi so esa tough lgta h baki ...Kuch kh nahi skte kya pta gs m acha score ho ya ho skta h interview call bhi na ho (GS 1..Ne le rkhi h meri to with geography optional
@Bubba_gumpnope bcuz wha thore time m hi question smjhna and krna hota h ....Inki tarah answer pe 2-5 din ka time nhi hota work krne ka .......Like vision ias ke gs ke answer ..They work hard to make good answer along with a team ........Exam ka scenario different hota h ......As it is to likh pana sambhav nhi h ...
@Bubba_gumpexact chaye na ho but drastically wrong na ho .......Like maine 2016 m guhawati ko assam ke most eastern part m mark kr dia tha
@Bubba_gumpno issue at all ...I hope
@Bubba_gumpyrr don't konw about this scalling process ........
@SUMANSAURABH201296904polavaram must be interbasin ...But ken and betwa both are tributaries of yamuna ..May be an example but I am not sure
@vvvikas0078212actually I read in hindi just linking of rivers and started answer without reading INTRABASIN ...In the end luckily mera dhyan ispe pda so last ke page m answer ko demand ke anusar bnane ki kosis ki but I was late ......3 case studies polavaram, ken -betwa ,narmada link maine likhe but answer ki structuring demand ke anusar nhi bni ......Like inter basin ki kmi btata and polavaram ki case study ...After that intrabasin ke advantages...
@vvvikas0078212hmm but question was ..More feasible ...Means
more advantages in comparison...........### so mine answer is not according to demand ### bs kuch number de wo baba bs
@Arrah_Jilaaap marks kaise calculate kr rhe ho.....# below average,average ,good ,very good ......Is type anser ka categories banaye to marking kisme kitne % ,ki hogi
@Hartshornesame ..But durga word suggesting WB but Creek ke hindi anuwad ne kafi confuse kr dia gujrat vs WB ....So finally ise mark hi nhi kia .....Likha h kuch kuch same in sanctuary
@Hartshorne5 +1(tehnmala as yours tn/kerala border
@Hartshorne2018 CREEK=संकरी खाड़ी
2019 Creek= ज्वारीय नदी .....##UPSC KI JAI
@Arrah_Jilaany idea how to calculate gs marking ...
@Arrah_Jilaokay ....I have attempted many regional disparity questions so there are 3 theories (growth pole , cumulative causation ,3rd yad nhi rha kuch sam vikash jaisa tha ), ground water depletion and wildlife conservation linked with concept of mental map ,space programme linked with PIVOT AREA concept (heartland theory),.....## ha shi kha bahut jyada dimag us time lga nhi ### muje to scope bhi km lga
@Bubba_gumpbarry commner ke 4 rules of nature m ek .... Everything connected to everything se start kia than ...Man -envir relation ke ke sath 2-3 examples like ...Global warming, urban pollution....Used flow chart .....used rules of ecosystem and 4 rule of nature ..... Something like that
@SUMANSAURABH2012969047(c ..m kon konse incentive like h
@SUMANSAURABH201296904I used
...REGIONAL DEV PROGRAMME (dpp,tribal area ,hill ,desert ), aspirational district ,VGF , special status ...Etc
@Hartshornehmm.same ..I also wrote +ive and lacuna and way forward...
@132_SIDBAISED MEDIA WALE ESSAY .........Mine .
Maine democracy ke basics and importance of each puller se start kia .....1.)media ka importance(kitabi gyan + real
2.) Media is not impartial
3.)impact
3(when media is baised in favour of govt . (Satta paksh), than when media in favour of vipaksha, I expand dimension to hindi vs non hindi language ,north vs south vs north east , development vs environment,tribal vs industry , etc ..
4)why media become biased ... Advertisement, trp, competition , influence
5 ) positive side not all based some are good... 6 ) what to do for make them impartial...
7) conclusion.....
Kitne ki ummid kru ....( 2016,17,18 ......Marks were 124,135,139
@Hartshorneyeah ...Example were there .....Arab spring , some good examples of medias role in democracy (nirbhya kand , .....24×7 ram mandir , ati-rastrvad, ,1975 emergency, recent economic slowdown , sri devi incident , odisha m niamgiri matter , .......Etc not fully remember.....## I was tried to be impartial while taking examples ....
@Hartshorneexample to bahut the but risk tha and aalochna ke time pe use different trike se likha gya ...Like विद्वानो का एक वर्ग मानता ह की मीडिया जम्मू कश्मीर की ग्राउंड रियलिटी को छुपा रहा ह ।।।like
@vvvikas0078212bad examples h not good
@hirockyrocks7101what's your score in your previous attemts
@vvvikas0078212no one knows ...Hmare case m ulta hua 131 (2017) to 148(2018) with less mapping
