Subscribe to ForumIAS

Interview Transcripts: CSE/IFoS 2020

An attempt to crowd-source transcripts for future reference and use

Neyawn,DMand6 otherslike this
58.5k views

204 comments

Chairman : BB Vyas sir (08/09/21) : 30min, afternoon session 3rd to go.
B/g - comp sci engineering
Optional : Anthropology
Other mentions: badminton, drawing, jogging
From:- UP


Ch : sir very nicely explained the whole process - Asked me not to be worried about anything.. Just want to have a good conversation.
Ch:-
1. Wat is sec 66A of IT act
2. 2. SC stand on it
3. Related to newspaper- india russia NSA meet
4. Threat to India due to devpt in afg
5. As a student of anthropology tell me:- Wat is modernisation;
6. Wat is tradition;
7. how backwardness and tradition are linked
M1:-
1. Wat is e- rupi
1. Wat are types of cryptocurrency
2. How are they regulated in India
3. Wat govt is doing for digital currency
4. How CBDC difft from other cryptocurrency
5. Wat is Jan dhan adhar mobile trinity
6. Wat is SC observation on freedom of expression
M2:-
1. RCEP full form
2. Members in it and give 3 economic reasons why India left RCEP
3. MSME sectors and what govt did for it ( I mentioned few schemes den he asked me it’s funding pattern)
4. Question on custom union n its example
Ch:-
1. diff between judicial activism and judicial outreach
2. Examples based on them
3. Wat is bilateralism
4. Diff between finance bill and appropriation bill

M3:-
1. question related to hobby- 2 female player who play doubles in badminton apart from PV Sindhu and Saina Nehwal
2. Ok.. then tell me 2 female retired players from badminton played doubles
3. Wat is data autonomy
4. Wat is pink economy

M4:-
1. what is statelessness
2. Explain in brief social, cultural, biological and political anthropology.

Chairman:- gave some insight on tradition and modernity and gave me 60 sec to speak on it..

Thank u; ur interview is over

The board was very welcoming and cordial; helped me in between wen I got stuck.. chairman Sir kept motivating me throughout..

Few more questions were asked Wich I am not able to recall..
balwintejas,
6.2k views
Interview transcript
Manoj Soni sir Board
Last (6th) to go
Optional- Anthropology

Chairman-
1. Tell me about your Upsc journey (told about my attempts and preparation phase)
2. This seems a very simple journey, no struggle story? (Told him that journeys are not defined by the struggles you face but the lessons they teach)
3. Meaning of you name
4. Your name and your medical background- any story behind it?
5. Situational question about being SP
6. One question on Afghanistan

M1-
1. Can India ever coordinate with Russia and China over Afghanistan issue?
2. Coming from an Army background, you have seen the Defence closely. Tell me positive points and negative points

M2- very analytical questions
1. Relation between culture and religion
2. Society is moving from status to contract to status
3. Linguistic pluralism should lead to pluralistic laws. Do you agree?

M3-
1. Reforms needed in bureaucracy
2. Why Babu culture?
3. Why stagnation in bureaucracy?
4. We are already having community engagement, what more needs to be done to change public perception towards bureaucracy
5. Why doctors praised but bureaucrats criticised during Covid

M4-
1. Questions about right to protest
2. Questions about Odisha Government giving reservations in medical and engineering colleges
3. Questions on education sector in general

Chairman-
Questions on saree.
Asked to recite a poem

Thank you. All the best. Stay healthy and stay safe.
balwintejas,
6.2k views

Background
Ashish
Graduation : - NIT Nagpur
Optional :Sociology
Place : Buldhana
Work ex : Currently working in jPmorgan chase

Was waiting outside the cabin of tc anant till called from inside .
Went and sat on the chair forgot it was a moving chair and there i was sliding after sitting:


Chairman ( T C Anant)
We are old people speak as loud as you could . YOu can remove your faceshield and put it on the table

1. You are from akola
2 . Tell me something about buldhana ?
3. Strengths and weakness of buldhana?
4 . You are doing good in life . Here your salary will be less than half and then why you want to join?
5. What you do in JPMorgan ?
6. What kind of flows are in it ?
7. From where are you based out of ?
8. So you are working from home ?


1 st member

1 . Do you write algortihm?
2 . So while working you stole some time from job is this so and prepared for civils?
3. You have been topper all through why didn't you think of doing mba?
4 . What is the measure for you by that ou will say you brought change in lives of people ?
5. How did you study for this interview. What was your approcah ?
6 . What drives ashish ? Is it money power fame ?

2 nd member

1. Which newspaper you read ?
2. tell me 3 news ?
3. Did you read indian express or economic times ? As 2 of 3 were financial news :)
misc: Did you read about gautam buddhnagar news ? (This hint was not given : Some distrct name where mahapanchayat happened ) Not able to recall.
4. You are to be advising PMO on Afghanistan what will you say ?
5 .what is blockchain?
6. Few uses of blockchain ?
7. What will be you reaction if tomorrow govt accepts bitcoin as legal tender?
8 . What is the current price of 1 bitcoin ?

3 rd member

1 . What type of work you do under CSR ?
2 . How govt ensures 2 companies doesn't work for same ngo ? (Not aware)
3 . Are you aware about national audit framework something (Indas)? (Vague idea but not sure )This was asked to everybody irrespective of their background?
4. Is climate change the truth ?
5 . There have been similar changes in the past ?
6. Two govt initiatives which you think are step in write direction?

4 th member

1 . Continuing on climate change more carbon more plants will consume why the hoax?
2 . Are we only serious about it ? USA doesn't seems to bother? (Some discussion and counter questions)
3 . About csr activities should be centralised or local responsibility should be maintained?

Chairman : thank you much . ur interiew is over.


balwintejas,
6.2k views
AHF

Board- Manoj Soni sir
Academic qualifications- B.Tech (Mechanical)
Work ex- 2 years in IT Industry
Optional- PSIR
Home state- Bihar
Achievements- Published writer in a national daily
Hobbies- Writing on Quora, European Football

Chairperson
Q1. You have a nice name. I have also heard about Satyam Shivam Sundaram. Do you know its essence?
Q2. Why did you take psir as optional?
Q3. Do you know about the constitution?
What are DPSPs?
Q4. Can you name some?
Q5. Are they justiciable?
Q6. Give me some examples of DPSP that you would have justiciable?

M1.
Q1. What is post truth? Are we living in a post truth era?
Q2. You write on Quora,but there's no authenticity of information on Quora. Your views?
Q3. You are a published writer in a national daily. Do you write regularly?
Q4. What was your last article about?
Q5. What is the reason behind so many custodial deaths?
Q6. You studied in DAV school. Tell me about its founder.
Q7. Name some social reformers from 18th century.

M2(lady member)
Q1. Picking up from what you mentioned- grievance redressal. Do you know about citizen charter?
Q2. Is it statutory or voluntary?
Q3. It's great that Bihar has brought RTPS Act. Tell me more?
Q4. What goes in the back end while making something like citizen charter, RTPS as statutory?
Q5. About custodial deaths, what do you think is the fountainhead of the problem why police has a negative image?
Q6. Are you aware about some police reforms?

M3(lady member)
Q1. Did you follow Paralympics? Tell me about it.
Q2. Do you think our efforts are decent or there's scope for improvement?
Q3. What has the government been doing for persons with disability?
Q4. What more could be done?


M4
Q1. You did NCC. You were in which wing?
Q2. Tell me something about the Indian Army.
Q3. What new has been done with respect to Indian army?
Q4. Should we increase our military expenditure given we spend 62 billion dollars?
Q5. Even with this much amount we are constantly facing border issues. Shouldn't we just accept LAC and LOC as international border and resolve the issue for the good?
Caesar,Auroraand7 otherslike this
5.2k views
Guys completely unrelated to the topic but any idea when the results are coming out?
3k views
Ajit bhonsle board
9/9/2021
Afternoon session
3rd to go
Optional - geography
Graduation - mechanical engineering
Hobbies - swimming, watching space tech videos, following women's cricket, fitness enthusiast....
State - Tamilnadu

Chairman made me comfortable as he explained the process and read my daf aloud starting from school, college and all the hobbies....

Q.1. He asked me to tell about any other hobby which I haven't mentioned in the daf...I said I like riding bikes for longer distance....
Q.2. What's the purpose of brakes?
We had long discussion...I said that the brakes is for safety and comfort and he gave his own perspective about brakes as he said that it's not about safety, brakes make you to ride faster and it's a marketing strategy...

member 1 (lady) (mostly factual questions from geography)
Q.1. geopolitical importance of Indian Ocean
Q.2. name some warm ocean currents
Q.3. name some hot local winds
Q.4. highest peak in Himalayan region, Indian region
Q.5. reason behind the name of trade winds

Member 2
Q.1. What is Chidambara ragasiyam?
Q.2. Features of Brihadeeshwara temple.

Member 3 (mostly factual)
Q.1. why do you follow women's cricket?
Q.2. name the women cricketer who took 200+ odi wickets and her native state.
Q.4. Captain of present Indian women's team
Q.5. Asked about some places and their importance - Ain Sefra, Petra
Q.6. Name the External intelligence agencies of India, UK, USA
Q.7. Name the Government of India ministers of Law, IT, Health
Q.8. Which swimmer is the most successful Olympian and the number of medals won by him.

Member 4 (opinion based questions)
Q.1. How IPL has changed the cricketing culture of India?
Q.2. IPL impact on world cricket
Q.3. Role of coaching centres in school education and what needs to be done in government schools
Q.4. Issues in higher education and remedies

Chairman - good, your interview is over....
4k views
T C A Anant sir board..
Karnataka, Reflective writing, cricket, Table tennis, Civil engg graduation, Psir optional..

Chairman..
1. What have you been doing since your gradutaion??
2. Not yet all working ??
3. Why civil services even though civil engg is a good field?
4. Tell any instance where you served society recently and what exactly what was your role
5. What is this Reflective writing ?
6. Recent writing, summary of it and what have I learned from it.

Member 1
1. What is Mankading ?
2. Name any 2 Indian tt players - Olympics and paralympics included
3. Afghanistan issue and Indian role ..follow up question on that
4. Present status of doklam standoff
5. 4 Civil engg questions - all I don't know

Member 2
1. Diff between fiscal deficit and revenue deficit
2. Primary deficit menaing ( I asked if I could take a guess as I wasn't sure about the answer and mam obliged)
3. What do you mean by Economic reforms and tell any recent economic reforms
3. About reflective writing - who inspired you, how does it help you, do you write it for self or others, do you follow anyone's writing, when did you start writing
4. Banglore metro issues - when I said some issues, mam asked for one specific issue and I told I don't know

Member 3
1. Waht Is the fiscal deficit allowed in india? ( picked from 2nd member )
2. Have we crossed it ? And what is the present deficit ?
3. About frbm act and how fiscal deficit should be reduced
4. My role as a cricketer and what is chinaman bowler?
5. Neighbourhod issues - how to solve it
6. What is Stagflation and Present inflation rate..is it good for economy ?

Member 4.
1. IR - mechanisms through which infra projects carried out in neigbourhood ? ( picked from 3rd member )
2. Bimstec and its current status ( picked from 3rd member )
3. Scheme under aatmanirbhar Bharat for manufacturing ?
4. About pli scheme and asked to mention any one specific component ( picked from previous question )
5. Why Women labour force participation rate less in india
6. How to generate jobs - agri or services should be preferred?? When I told we need to go for manufacturing, asked me to specify certain areas.. when i told about engineering goods, chairman intervened and asked me if it was labour intensive..i replied its not but it can create forward and backward linkages and this could create employemnet
7. Views on caste census
8. Scheme for Muslims to avail educational loan in India

P.s : asked to remove face shield, m1 and m4 were sitting very close to me, asked Me to also pull my chair towards the table, asked me to correct my mask as it was coming down while answering, overall very cordial board, no grilling at all, 25 - 30 minutes.
4k views
Board- Manoj Soni sir
Btech Mechanical
PSIR
Bihar
Achievements- published writer in a national daily
Hobbies- Quora, European Football

Q1. You have a nice name. I have also heard about Satyam Shivam Sundaram. Do you know its essence?
Q2. Why did you take psir as optional?
Q3. Do you know about the constitution?
What are DPSPs?
Q4. Can you name some?
Q5. Are they justiciable?
Q6. Give me some examples of DPSP that you would have justiciable in nature?

M1.
Q1. What is post truth? Are we living in a post truth era?
Q2. You write on Quora,but there's no authenticity of information on Quora. Your views?
Q3. You are a published writer in a national daily. Do you write regularly?
Q4. What was your last article about?
Q5. What is the reason behind so many custodial deaths?
Q6. You studied in DAV school. Tell me about its founder.
Q7. Name some social reformers from 18th century.

M2 (lady member)
Q1. Picking up from what you mentioned- grievance redressal. Do you know about citizen charter?
Q2. Is it statutory or voluntary?
Q3. It's great that Bihar has brought RTPS Act. Tell me more?
Q4. What goes in the back end while making something like citizen charter, RTPS as statutory?
Q5. About custodial deaths, what do you think is the fountainhead of the problem why police has a negative image?
Q6. Are you aware about some police reforms?

M3 (lady member)
Q1. Did you follow Paralympics? Tell me about it.
Q2. Do you think our efforts are decent or there's scope for improvement?
Q3. What has the government been doing for persons with disability?
Q4. What more could be done?


M4
Q1. You did NCC. You were in which wing?
Q2. Tell me something about the Indian Army.
Q3. What new has been done with respect to Indian army?
Q4. Should we increase our military expenditure given we spend 62 billion dollars?
Q5. Even with this much amount we are constantly facing border issues. Shouldn't we just accept LAC and LOC as international border and resolve the issue for the good?
4k views
Board - BB Vyas Sir

Interview date - 9 Sept, Forenoon (2nd to go)


Background

Computer science engg, work ex - Samsung

Optional - PSIR

Hobbies - cooking, diary writing

Places mentioned in DAF - Bihar, Jharkhand, Dhanbad, Bokaro, BITS Pilani


Chairman

What is data protection.

Mechanism in India for data protection

What is cyber security

Laws in India for cyber security

GCC - members

Importance of middle east for India

What is your idea of aspirational India

Explain the statement - Respect diversity unity will follow


Member 1

Digital formats for expressing yourself (diary writing hobby)

What is cloud kitchen

What is India doing to promote kabaddi

Long statements about Aksai Chin. He mentioned about water scarcity and asked how can u relate water and computer science engg.


Member 2

Anti trust law

How to promote tourism in jharkhand

Name few potential places for tourism in jharkhand


Member 3

One state has passed a new law. Can u name the state and the law ( She told about TN and right to sit)

Name the country which is banning apple and google payments.

Who is new Sherpa for G20

Role of Sherpa

Cooking at personal or commercial level

From where have u learnt cooking


Member 4

Give 2 more points on importance of GCC (himself gave hints on diaspora and remittance)

What are some unique features of mineral policy of Jharkhand

What new is Bokaro steel plant doing (he said about some new technology adoption)

How many tribes are there in Jharkhand ( I said 32 then he said speak for at least 2 minutes )


Chairman: Thank you so much


Overall coordial board
3.9k views
BB Vyas board
10.09.2021
Forenoon last one to go
Aerospace , Anthropology , Painting (hobby)
These parts of DAF are covered.
Chairman
1. Drone technology development activities?
2. In which region extensively used ? ( Armenia, Azerbaijan) ? What is the exact issue?
3. Why is the drone seen as a future warfare ? What are its effect in the hand of non state actors?
4. Why Drone rules liberalized in India if there is a potential security threat?
5. How can we address the threat of drones?DRDO efforts?
6. Can we get the technology from USA in future? What are other friendly nations that can provide us the technology?
7. Define tribe?
8. Safeguards for tribals constitutional, legal and institutional?
9. Different programs for tribal welfare?with examples and evaluate?

Member 1
1. Long question regarding a tribe in Gujarat which are African based tribe and has huge potential in running?
2. One more tribe in West Bengal at Siliguri corridor and potential threat around the same?
3. What is Anti satellite technology ? Does India have the same? Explain the technology and threats?Is it due to threat from China?
Does China have the same?
4. What is far east economic forum ? India's stake in region? China Russia axis?
5. ISRO vs PSU Efficiency ?
6. Specialist vs generalist?

Member 2
1. Say something regarding van Gough?
2. Did he enjoy the amount of popularity when he was alive?
3. Can painting be a full time job( discussion around the same)
4. What is US " war on terror" ( tomorrow is 20 yrs of 9/11 attack , expected question)
5. Questions around Taliban , Al Qaeda ( Did US completely eliminate the terrorism)
6. Place of Saddam Hussein death ( don't know sir) , pushed a lot to answer ( said some place and asked which country don't know)

Member 3
1. Are you aware of the recent airstrip? Location? Why near an airbase , a new airstrip ? Why a lot of news surrounding the same?
2. Do you know regarding a new deal with TATA airbus c 239 aircraft? Why now ? Why change ? Which we are using now ?
3. What is anthropocene?
4. Discuss around Chandrayan 2 success?
5. DRDO and covid?

Member 4
1. Why aerospace?
2. Future scope in sector?
3. Why civil service now? Why no job ?
4. Is autonomy of ISRO the only reason for their success? Because they do have a lot of red tapism?
5. Peaceful use of outer space treaty ? 5 guidelines and institutions for the same?
6. What is interferometery? ( Project)

Thank you your interview is over.
4k views
Board - Dr. Manoj Soni
Date - 10/9/21
Education- BBA/MBA-HR/Pursuing PhD
Job experience- Executive HR + Teaching
Optional- Literature in English Language
Afternoon shift
2nd to go

Chairman-
1-So you have studied at St Joseph. Who was St. Joseph?
2- What has literature in English taught you ?
3- Which books do you feel have added such values to you ?
4- Is Christ University a UGC recognised University (due to educational background)

Member 1-
1- As an HR what all technologies can you use to make work more efficient?
2- How will you manage conflict if your superior doesn't use data based analysis ?
3- Who is Ann Rand ?
4- Books authored by her ?

Member 2-
1- How are Christian missionaries different from Other schools?
2- Do you feel they are indulged in Conversion?
3- Where all are Chirstian Missionaries more active geographically?
4- What is difference between Debate, Speech , Elocution?

Member 3-
1-You have done NCC , how many years did you do it?
2- What are drawbacks in NCC
3- How can India solve it's issues with its neighbours?
4-Do you think Indian writers in English language who are settled abroad get given prizes like Pulitzer because of the influence they can exert ?

Member 4-
1- What is the Title of your Thesis ?
2- CAG recently flagged that the Universities in Odisha aren't having good quality because low percentage of students clear civil services and other govt service exams, do you think that should be the only crieteria ?
3- Why Indian students go abroad to study ?
4- Do you think choice based systems also have a role to play ?
5- How does Choice based system help in innovation?
6- Do you think Indian graduate have low employability?

Chairman-
Your interview is over
Have a great day
3.9k views
Board - BB Vyas Sir
Date - 07/09/21
Education - Born and completed schooling in UAE, B.Tech EEE, NIT Tiruchirappalli
Hobby - Food photography, Weightlifting, Audiobooks
Football (DAF)
Optional - Sociology
IFS service preference
Morning session, last to go

I was quite unwell in the preceding days but two separate Covid tests turned negative. UPSC gave go ahead for attending.

Chairperson - asked me to remove the mask, but I insisted on wearing it and intimated him regarding my condition.

- You sure you want to give now, you can give interview later as well when you're better
- Why do we get cold?
- Tell me about our relations with UAE
- You are a sociology student, why do we mention 'children on the wrong side of the law'? Tell me about the Juvenile Justice Act
- Kerala is known as God's own country, tell me another tagline that can be catchy, you can tell later at the end of the interview as well

Lady Member -

- You sure you don't have fever? (looking concerned)
- Are you a citizen of UAE? (...)
- Okay so, your school is named Our Own English High school, is it your family's own or?
- You have mentioned food photography but that does not involve cooking. How do you choose the images to capture?
- Are you present on social media, do you have your own website?
- How do you popularize your product?
- Why sociology as optional? How has it changed you?

2nd Member -

- It is said that Kerala is undergoing 3rd wave. Why is it that Kerala is performing so poorly presently despite the high education and health infrastructure metrics?
- Is there GCC - India trade agreement?
- Should India sign FTA with UAE?
- UAE's sovereign fund is being used pumping billions of dollars into an entity that only brings few hundred million or so in revenue and rarely turns profits, what is it? (Manchester City, ez)
- Mention UAE visa scheme criteria, why is it not available to Pakistan?

3rd Member (Kept interrupting in between)
- Tell me why UAE and Saudi are experiencing few tensions currently
- Name 2 exceptional players of Indian football team
- Who are the two well known Indian female weightlifers and which states are they from?
- Qatar, how is it playing such a prominent role in negotiations?
- Our Electricity grid faces security issues because we import so much from which country?

4th Member
- Tell me about 6th schedule
- Why is there so much concern about Taliban coming to power?
- Do you watch Mammootty movies? Mention 5 films done by Mammootty (xD)

Chairperson
Points toward the painting on the wall (kalaripayattu warriors)
- Do you know what this is, speak about it.(Originated from my district)
- What lessons have Kerala learnt for its tourism model since covid has occurred?

Your interview is over. Wish you a speedy recovery, get well soon!

Interview was weirdly factual at places, and one member in particular kept interrupting in between.
Overall experience was very cordial and accomodating. Best of luck to all!
4k views
Interview Transcript 

Board- TC Anant 
Date- 09/09/2021, forenoon
B.Tech (Civil), IIT Bombay
IDAS, Table Tennis, Anthropology
Katihar (Bihar)

Chairperson

Read my DAF. Where are tou from in Katihar.  Have your childhood spent in village, are you still staying in village?

 1. Tell me about Katihar
 2. As DM of Katihar, tell me what you will do for next 2 years

Member 1

 1. Tell me height of TT net
 2. Difficulty in construction activity in black soil
 3. Why black soil swells? Is it due to any compound/chemical?
 4. Asked me about some principle related to CE (haven’t heard of)

Member 2 (lady member)
 1. From where govt collects revenue- tell me the percentage wise bifurcation 
 2. Counter questions 

Member 3
 1. Tell me some govt schemes being implemented in your village and their success, failures
 2. Purdue Univ vs IIT Bombay (Daf)
 3. Do you play sports? TT- name some players and olympians. 
 4. In recent para olympics, a civil servant participated. Tell me the sport and name
 5. OFB corporatisation 
 6. Afghan issue- what is happening there and India’s interest

Member 4
 1. DAP2020 vs DPP 2016 (daf)
 2. earlier offset clause in defence procurement was an issue for MSME. Tell me the reasons
 3. Why separate accounts department for defence?
 4. Why Civil services after IIT
3.8k views
Chairman - Dr. Manoj Soni

Date of Interview- 10 September 2021
Afternoon slot

Doctor, Mbbs, Safdarjung Hospital 
Hobbies - Bhangra, Badminton
State - Chandigarh, Punjab, Haryana


Chairman
 ⁃ Can you remove your facemask and shield to match your picture?
 ⁃ You can wear mask again. Can you tell what is the importance of masks even when there is social distancing? 
 ⁃ So After doing internship in 2020, what all you did? 
 ⁃ What was your experience in COVID duty and during 2nd covid wave?
 ⁃ We need funds for health, for education. Seeing limited resources what do u think is the least important ministry from which funds could be cut? (I said every ministry is important and we should cut on corruption, leakages and rationalise subsidies)
 ⁃ How will you prevent leakages? ( i told DBT, digitisation)
 ⁃ How to prevent misuse of funds in DBT?( talked about E-RUPI - voucher based system)

 Member 1
 ⁃ Seeing such a shortage of doctors, didn’t u rethink your decision to stay a doctor ?
 ⁃ Regarding Pegasus, how can state do snooping on public? 
 ⁃ Earlier it was paperwork but no issues like this, why? 
 ⁃ How to balance Rt to privacy n Rt to public security? 

Member 2
 ⁃ What is the need of UT? Shouldn’t this idea be scrapped? 
 ⁃ What about Chandigarh? What has centre done in it? 
 ⁃ What are the issues regarding Organ transplant and donation? 
 ⁃ What is this Euthanasia, Active, Passive, what are the provisions in India? 
 ⁃ Shouldn’t Rt to die with dignity involve anyone whoever wants to die, why only vegetative state? 
 ⁃ Who was really Safdarjung? 

Member 3
 ⁃ If you are given power to allocate budget, u think that is sufficient?
 ⁃ What other things are required?
 ⁃ Have you heard about Ajmer? 
 ⁃ It has always remained outside of federal powers. What is analogous nowadays? (Can’t remember exact question)(Answered UT directly administered by Center, they wanted to hear this) 
 ⁃ What are the recent Singapore developments? 

Member 4
 ⁃ You have been a head girl of your school. What were your takeaways? 
 ⁃ How you dealt with crisis with a positive attitude? example?
 ⁃ What are India’s relations with pakistan
 ⁃ How to improve them?
 ⁃ Tell me anything about Indian ocean region
 ⁃ You also do Bhangra. Do women also perform it? Or is it a male dance? 

Chairman
 ⁃ So how was your overall experience in UPSC bhavan?
 ⁃ Any suggestions as a doctor?
 ⁃ 
 ⁃ Your interview is over. Stay safe and healthy!

Cordial and comfortable board.
3.8k views
09.09.2021
Forenoon
2nd to Go
Hobbies : Vipassana, Poetry Writing, Calligraphy
Optional: Anthropology
Background : Computer Science Engineer.
Job Experience : 1 Year at TESCO
State : Karnataka
Board : TCA Ananth

ChairPerson(CP): 
What was your role at TESCO.
Why did you leave your Job
You worked with NGO, what Projects ? ( I mentioned Bank account for women from Slum area)
Follow up Question: What is you assessment of Jan Dhan Yojana?
Have you helped anyone in creating account in Jan Dhan Yojana?
You are also pursuing Masters in anthropology ? When did you start? when will it finish?

M1:
Asked 3 Questions.. Which I was not aware. I said I don't know. 
You do vipassana? Where did you attend ? 
What do you do in Vipassana?Explain.
Why is there tussle between Executive and Juduciary.
What is your take on Recently formed Taliban Government.
You are Computer Science Engineer,Tell me what is AI and ML.
Tell me one Good thing and One bad thing about AI.
How far do you Agree with this statement -"Corona will make us zombies and AI will take over humans".

M2(Lady Member): You missed on main point regarding tussle between judiciary and Executive ( I did not know what she was referring to I said, I ll read about it Mam)
Tell me What is Greenfield and Brownfield Project.
Disadvantages of Brownfield Project.
From where are you Pursuing Masters?
Looks like you are pursuing masters in Anthropology as that will help you in Civil Services.
Which other University Offers Masters in Anthropology?
You are Anthropology Student, Have you read Sapiens?
Tell me few Important Points from the Book.
Do you really agree with author's views.
Don't you think Sapiens will kill all the other animals like they killed other Homo. ( I was saying, we are evolving as humans, We are signing Convention)
If you are saying so, Then why are many animals under threat and are endangered.
Tell me names of few endangered species.


M4: 
So you had mentioned financial Inclusion in your answer, Explain this quote to me -"India will realise its Full potential only when we achieve Inclusive development"
What is Govt's Slogan Regarding this
What is Calligraphy?
What do People really achieve by beautifying the Letters?
Tell me Important Qualities of Leadres?
Are the Qualities of Civil Servant the Same or they are Different?


M5:
So you write Poetry, Can you please recite one for us. ( I started reciting and after few lines , Lady member Started Clapping)
Was your Poem Viral?
Do you think Social Media has bridged gap between Govt and people?
What is your view on Civil servants being nameless and facecess or they should be viral? What did Sardar Patel say about Civil servants?
Tell me only one reason that drives you so much to this Service( I said sense of satisfaction)
What is the difference between Sense of Satisfaction and Power.

Note:

Largely Questions were from DAF .
Questions were built upon what I had mentioned in my answers.
3.8k views
TRANSCRIPT 

Date: 10/09/2021
Board: B B Vyas 
Forenoon session; First person to go 
Optional: PSIR 
Graduation: BA Economics 
State: Maharashtra 
Hobbies: Alt Rock music, Running, Karate, Reading, Debating  

Chair
 1. You’ve studied economics and pol sci. Tell me what are the internal tensions within China 
 2. What lessons can india learn from China’s situation today? 
 3. Which newspapers do you read? Have you heard about VPN? Please explain 
 4. India has been promoting exports. Do you think it is going to do us any good? 
 5. What are the measures taken to promote exports?
 6. Have you heard of the concept called helicopter money 
 7. What is the importance of Siachen glacier

Member 1
 1. Why is China facing economic problems in recent years? 
 2. Why have Chinese wage rates gone up? 
 3. We have been talking about make in India so much. What has the govt done in that direction? 
 4. What is Alternative Rock Music? (hobby) 
 5. How is it different from Heavy metal? 
 6. Do you know about Sanjay Gandhi National Park? What is it famous for? 
 7. How are forest areas located within city limits protected 

Member 2 
 1. Tell me names of some martial arts from India (based on hobby) 
 2. Have you heard about RDF? Mandi tax?
 3. What is your opinion on the way the APMC system works 
 4. Is Pakistan a failed state?
 5. What are the conflicts within Pakistan? 


Member 3
 1. What do you understand by Global political economic order?
 2. Is the current order conducive for India’s rise?
 3. What are we doing about it?
 4. What are institutions of global governance? 
 5. Give me names of some political scientists who advocated institutional approach
 6. Which is India’s National Waterway 1
 7. What is the use of waterways? 
 8. 90% of our economy consists of unorganised workers. What has the govt done to provide social security to unorganised workers?

Member 4
 1. Recently a cruise was inaugurated in our prime minister’s constituency. Have you heard about it? 
 2. The govt has launched a portal for unorganised workers. Have you heard about it? What is it used for? 
 3. Which ministry does e-shram portal fall under? 
 4. What is the meaning of your name? 

Member 1 
 1. Which service have you chosen? 

Chair 
 1. Imagine that you have to give a speech to a group of young girls at a college/ university ceremony. Tell us 5 points that you’ll mention in your speech
 2. Name 2 female leaders whom you admire 
 3. Name 2 male leaders whom you admire 

Thank you very much.
3.7k views
Date - 08/09/2021.
Academic- Masters Applied Geology , 
Work ex @ Coal India (resigned) , 
Home State & residence- MP , Jabalpur & Narsinghpur.
Optional - Geology
Hobby - Wildlife observation , Teaching. 
BB VYAS Sir Board

Forenoon session - 2nd last ( 12:05pm). 
Wished everyone.
Chairman sir - Welcome. 
Please take your seat.
Made me comfortable. Asked to remove mask and keep the shield on. Already had gone through DAF.
Let’s get to Geology directly. 
1.What are the challenges in mineral prospecting in India?
2. What are the challenges in Coal mining?
3. Let’s discuss the ground water situation of our country. Also tell me about ground water contamination.
4. Recent changes in Mining laws.
5. National Coal index ( I didn’t know. Said sorry. He said need not to worry that’s alright)
6. Which countries India must cooperate with wrt Geological resources? ( I named three regions)
7. What about Africa? How can Africa be significant for India?

M1- ( question answer mode)
First told me - you could have said two more points wrt Africa.let’s discuss more on Geopolitics.
1. What can we do about Pakistan- tell me 5 points
2. A complex question about China and Pakistan which I couldn’t understand. 
3. How can we go China plus in terms of textiles?
Some questions on geopolitics.

M-2 ( Sir Seemed  to be from Armed Forces background) (Conversation mode)
1. Name One disaster that Army faces in high altitudes. Why increasing instances?
2. How can Army mitigate the same?
3. An institute has been established for this in Manali. Do you know?( I politely said sorry)- he told the name of the institute 
3. Which energy source Army can utilise in Himalayas- related to geology?
4. A neighbouring country of Afghanistan where we were supposed to mine a strategic ore but it has been cancelled-
He told the answer as well when I couldn’t tell the name of ore.
I told   about Farzad - B gas field and whole cancellation issue.
Chairman sir said yes that’s also a strategic one which is having issues.
5. China has established some thermal power plants under CPEC 
in Pakistan. Do you know what special feed they use ? 
M3- asked what teaching do you do?
1. Tell me difference b/w teaching and mentoring.
2. Can an economist be a mentor to a geology student?
3. What is net neutrality?
4. What is 9th Schedule of the constitution?
M4 ( Lady member)
Let’s talk something on your comfort zone- Any movies you watched related to Coal mining ?
I replied - Two movies I know of - Gangs of Wasseypur and Kalapathhar.
She said I will recommend you watch Kalapatthar.
Had a small discussion on Gangs of Wasseypur and Chasnala mine disaster.
1. Buxwaha forest diamond mining issue- gave context- what should we do?
2. Probing question on how to do that?
3. Should we go ahead with the project even if locals do not benefit at all?
4. Narsinghpur- 3 things that are special about it?
Discussion about Arhar dal.
5. Is anyone from your family involved in agriculture?

Chairman sir said - thank you . That is all from our side. I thanked everyone.
Overall - Cordial environment- Chairman sir always nodding smiling and encouraging.Gave hints when I got stuck. All members nodding and sometimes smiling.
3.7k views
Kerala.
Anthropology
Fertilizer sector experience
Smita Nagraj Board

Chairperson
1. Thing you enjoyed most in your job. 
2. How do you deal with mistakes of your subordinates. 
3. What is the current subsidy policy?
4. What changes will you suggest. 

Member 1. 

1. Advantages of moving into DBT to farmers. 
2. Long term solution to reduce subsidy?
3. Why covid cases increasing in Kerala 
4. What can be done. ?

Member 2

1. What are biofertilizers 
2. Why can't chemical fertilizers be replaced with bio fertilizer. 
3. What is nipah? Why are ppl more afraid of it than covid ?
4. Difference b/w appam n idiyappam 

Member 3
1. When n  why was kendriya vidyalaya established?
2. What is NEP ? 2 Provisions I like most ?
3. Any anthropologist I like and his concepts? 
(I said Boaz and Cultural Relativism)
4. He asked me about LP Vidyarti Sacred Complex.
5. Asked link between sacred complex and sanskritisation ? 

Member 4. 

1. If you're JS fertilizer department will you abolish fertilizer department? 
2. Will you privatise fertilizer PSUs
3. Will you stop fertilizer subsidy 

Chairperson 
Your interview is over.
3.8k views

Board: BB vyas sir

Mbbs, chandigarh, Haryana

 

Chairman: cheerful, smiling, encouraging

-What is medical ethics? Give 3 main characteristic ethics?

-Difference In confidentiality and privacy

-what is Haryana sex ratio at present?

-What haryana did to improve it?

-Latest Q1 economy analysis

-what is v shaped and k shaped

-reason for k shaped economy

-Is world economy recovering? Do you have any data?

-Laqshay program

-Imr high in a district. As an officer What will do for hospital to prevent mortality

 

M1: (meh faced but laughed in end)

-so how is chandigarh?

-Sukhna lake, there was shramdaan recently, why?

-what is the reason of siltation in lake? (Gave one reason, he explained another one which he wanted to hear)

-What is pre medical counseling (daf)

-Will you continue after coming in C.S.

 

M2: constantly smiling

- Meaning of name

-Are you like this?

-Why ias

- will you go for further studies and PG?

-what you did after 2019

-What we did in second wave

-What could have been better

 

M3: very soft voice. Many times said to repeat.

-ever visited police station? Said No, it's okay would have heard about it

-What can be done to improve police station? How to make it women friendly?

-How will you inspire girls to take policing

-Use of med sci knowledge in IPS ?

 

M4:

-what is special about jagadhri( said don't know)

-Why haryana doing well in sports

-Can other states do it

-Why chd people are ruining Himalayas? Solutions?

-What policy can be done by HP in tourism to avoid it

-Can we limit No. Of tourist per day

 

Chairman: All the best for your future. Thank you.

 

Very cordial board. Mostly daf based.

3.5k views

Name : MMB

Background : BTech (ECE) -Nit Warangal- working in Micron - Anthropology-AP - travelling- Badminton

 

Board : Sujata Mehta Ma'am

 

Chairman

1. What can India do in short term(next 3 years) to become manufacturing hub in semi-conductors

 

2. What was your best travelling experience. (Told about a trek)

 

3. What is your least enjoyed traveling experience ( told visiting temples)

 

4. Do you think trekking and other activities are confines to only  rich, while piligrimage is a mass based tourism?

 

Member 1:

 

1. Tell me about different existing inter state border disputes . What can he done about it.

 

2. Tell me about reason why inter state water disputes are persisting.

 

3. Tell about recent Karnataka - TamilNadu water dispute.

 

4. Tell me about Andhra Telangana water disputes.

 

Member 2:

 

1. Why did you take anthropology?

2. How anthropology can be used in administration.

3. What is your take on Socio economic caste census ( chairman asked member to skip this question very firmly and go for next question )

4. What is sanskritisation.

 

Member 3

1. What is the role of USA in current Afghanistan crisis.

 

1. Do you think education system has failed as suicides are increasing in higher education institutions

 

2. What is smart city mission.

 

3. What are works taken up in Hyderabad under smart city mission.

 

4. Tell me about aspects of recent IPCC report related to India in 5-6 points.

 

Member 4

1. you know national health mission (and he explained that center shares money to states to improve health system)

 

Why people blame center for covid when health is clearly state subject.

 

2. Do you think center should interfere in state subject like health

 

3. If center manages covid by itself, why some states performed well and some couldn't do well.

 

Chairman

1. Do you want us to ask from anything, it's okay even if you say no

 

(I said badminton or Andhra Pradesh)

 

2. Do you think bifurcation was necessary or beneficial.

 

3. That demand existed from 30 years back. Center could have let the demand continue as it is. Why did it yield now.

 

 

Thank you, you may leave now

 

Board is very cordial.

They let me express my views and didn't interrupt unnecessarily.

 

All the best to all.

3.5k views
Write your comment…