Official Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers

@mahi2501I thought question has to link rationality and efficiency with Weber’s bureaucracy...it is what I wrote in Mains2018 paper.....@doodlebean mam please help....

@Hakunah_Matatasaid inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

@doodlebean

Justice done in second part. Job well done. Conclusion is impressive. However not able to understand relevance of first part of your answer. Looks like you were short of words so scribbled something from Weber for the sake of it. When you have so much to write for this answer then why to waste words on something irrelevant to thr question asked.

@Redsaid inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

This is how I like my answers to be... TO THE POINT- no deviations. As it was a ‘Comment’ question so you’ve aptly not attempted any analysis. However more explanation is required. Mujhe do baar padhna padha to understand whether you’ve covered the demands of the question- examiner nahi padhega.. katai!!

@Bhagat-singhsaid inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

@doodlebean@IWRA

You can be the next pub adm topper. Do I need to say more

P.s work on handwriting n presentation.

@prowesssaid inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

Could have explained your diagram more. Your diagram is just a diagram. No explanations given in answer. It can turn out to be a blunder.

@ADIsaid inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

Some good content in answer but where’s the explanation for your diagram. Believe me it’s not self understood and more pain you’ll give to examiner to understand your answer more ‘majdoori’ he’ll deduct from your marks.

@doodlebeanmam please review mine too... Link daal hai

@mahi2501said inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

@doodlebean

https://ibb.co/Vm3RhpC
https://ibb.co/NK4h8cQ

Here is my answer..

Sorry I was unable to directly add photos

Okkk... so first things first. In a 150 words answer you’ve mentioned other thinkers and Weber got sidelined. Examiner har baar poora answer nhi padhta . I’v read 6 answers and now I’m searching for keywords, explanations n diagrams (explanation for diagrams) ... you attempted the graphic presentation Very Well but invested the time for explanation in Simon despite it being a ‘comment’ question only .@Bhagat-singhto pls take note.
PSU example was a smart move. Kudos to that!!

@doodlebeanmam directives me confusion hot.... Analyse aur comment me kya difference hai..
If the directive was analyse what difference it would have made to the answer?

@doodlebeanbeautifully explained... Thank you...

But do we have time in exam to draw such crafted diagrams?

@doodlebeanthanks mam for taking time to review the answer... thoda out of practice ho gya hai answer writing ..will try to be more examiner friendly with explanations.

@mahi2501said inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

@doodlebeanmam directives me confusion hot.... Analyse aur comment me kya difference hai..
If the directive was analyse what difference it would have made to the answer?

@doodlebeantheoretically to maine bhi padha hai ye differences.. But jab likhta hoon.. It becomes difficult to align my answer as per directive... Could you please explain the difference with the given question as example.??

@mahi2501said inOfficial Thread for Public Administration Optional - Questions & Answers:

@doodlebeanbeautifully explained... Thank you...

But do we have time in exam to draw such crafted diagrams?

And I was wondering abhi tak ye kyu ni poocha kisine

After practising around 350 diagrams... it takes not more than 1 minute to draw a diagram for me . One nicely explained diagram channelise your thought process and cuts down time to attempt the explanation as well. You just have to see the diagram and explain. So little effort in practice and you getting good marks....not a bad deal I guess.

@doodlebeanyou make things so simple mam.. Never thought it was so easy.. Overcoming the inertia is the key..

I will try for myself.. And buckle up my preparation.. Shuruaat me back was sa banega but dheere dheere improve karoonga

@mahi2501

@doodlebeanthanks man..

@doodlebeanthank u mam for ur kind words. Learning a lot from you and others on this platform.

Mam wat is diffrence between NPG and good governance

reference for third answer i.e NPS vs NPM