Subscribe to ForumIAS

[ Official ] How was the Prelims 2021 paper?

How was the paper guys ? 

jack_Sparrow,curious_kidand28 otherslike this
1.7m views

4.8k comments

Negansaid

Pam123said

@sushil_21 B is not right, I marked B too out of hurry. But it’s wrong. It nowhere mentions bicameralism. It says elected representatives from constituent units. Even Lok Sabha members are elected representatives are these units. So no B is definitely wrong. 


A is also definitely wrong. Palestine is also a state, but it is not independent of external Control (Israel).


aap mix up kar rhe ho iska B hoga , A federalism wale ka hoga XD.
Pam123,
3.3k views
@Aurang_mirasudar badi duvidha me hain.. pakka na 29th free rakhe dimaag?


3.2k views
@Negan oh if that’s for state, then yeah it’s definitely A. I was talking about federalism one


3.1k views
@Pam123 Yeah, state is A. Federalism I have marked wrong i.e. B


Pam123,
3.8k views
Kaise pata yaar? Koi source? Or Telegram thing? 


3.8k views
More twists and turns in answers of forumites than daily soap operas 
keephustling,Ferbiumoxide
3.9k views
@monisha27 same here :(


2.9k views
@parle ji_ his first comment on forum.fake .


3.8k views
From past two years some random person comes and tells such an info. and generally result aa jaata hai. 
I hope it's you this time.


3.6k views
He has been a member since 8 months. He may be talking with some info. hopefully. Fake ones can't hold themselves for that much, I believe. :P


3.5k views

Pam123said

@Negan oh if that’s for state, then yeah it’s definitely A. I was talking about federalism one


State wala is definitely not A.

And regarding "essential feature that indicates India is federal in character" is definitely A

Hernan cortez,
5.1k views

DD Basu says Federalism has 4 characteristics - 1. Dual government 2. Distribution of powers 3. Supremacy of constitution 4. Authority of courts

There is no mention at all of bicameralism.

plmokn25688524,keephustling
4.2k views
@parle ji_ lets see.


5.1k views
@parle ji_ no. deriving sadistic pleasure by creating anxiety.


Joey27,parle ji_
4k views
Deleted
@Negan yes both are A. That’s the debate I was giving too. :D for federalism B is wrong is what I was saying.


4.1k views
@Negan why not A for state?


4.1k views
@Aurang_mirasudar badi duvidha me hain.. pakka na 29th free rakhe dimaag?


Han

5.4k views
@Negan The"best" definition of State is B. It is the most comprehensive amongst all options. Also, it does include sovereignty in it, ergo holding true to the overly-emphasised Montevideo Convention's criteria of a State in almost all coaching institutes' key, which I think is in particular context of international law. I 'd mark it B even I were to attempt the paper today. 


keephustling,Hernan cortezand2 otherslike this
4.6k views
@Pam123 State should have Citizens, Government, Sovereignty and Territory! Rest depends on UPSC. 


Pam123,plmokn25688524
4.7k views

Pam123said

@Negan why not A for state?


Because Palestine is also a state, but it is not independent of external Control (Israel).


4.8k views
Write your comment…