[Results] Prelims 2020 Over - Gearing for 2021
Because of the corona virus issue? If it does not happen then worst affected will be people whose interview is stuck, around 600-700 such people I think are yet to appear for their interview.
@neyawn sir and others, what is your take?
This is the official Thread for discussion of Prelims Postponement, Please do not create new threads for the same.
What can be the answer of the CSAT passage about Education and Economic Freedom?3 only I have marked.
I have also marked option c ( 3 only)... passage has talked about eduaction, not higher education.... dont why coaching keys r not able to comprehend this...passage no where is talking about higer eduaction....whats ur take ?
Subramanyam,
@Tokyo Inclusive agri growth jismein option hai u mean 2 qs ka second qs wala? I have marked d - inc growth is key to reduce poverty in near future.
Bhai es par controversy hai ..c k saath
I have also marked D ....but is this also controversial ..as C bhi rajias video says c ....your take??
I have also marked D and most of the coachings are giving it as D. Honestly, the more you check different answer keys, the more variations you will find in passages.
What can be the answer of the CSAT passage about Education and Economic Freedom?I have marked 3only ...but answer some have given d (123) and one gave 1 only. ..
how can be only 1 as option...passage is no where saying about higher education...but coaching r giving 1 only as answer....god know what they smoke...
@Tokyo Inclusive agri growth jismein option hai u mean 2 qs ka second qs wala? I have marked d - inc growth is key to reduce poverty in near future.
Bhai es par controversy hai ..c k saath
I have also marked D ....but is this also controversial ..as C bhi rajias video says c ....your take??
i have also maked D
What can be the answer of the CSAT passage about Education and Economic Freedom?I have marked 3only ...but answer some have given d (123) and one gave 1 only. ..
how can be only 1 as option...passage is no where saying about higher education...but coaching r giving 1 only as answer....god know what they smoke...
Whatever they smoke --- they have given a sleepless night yesterday inspite of scoring way above average in gs1
gauravbrly409,I took it as *legal bearing* in interpretation of constitutional provisions and marked its as C.(I did it)
But, If some body read. .. Legal effect = Justifiability ... Then A is answer..
🧐: i do not know what *legal effect* means actually.
I think it does not mean Justiciable ness in strictest terms. or .. I am wrong perhaps.
Depends .. How upsc interpretation goes for it.
NOLEisGOAT,@gauravbrly409 I am not saying that my answer is correct but I can give you reason for why I feel D is more suited than A. C is not possible because SC has categorically said that Preamble is not justifiable. So no law can by struck down because it violates any of the provision of the Preamble 'only'. It is due to this 'only' that I feel D is better than A because D says that although it does not have an independent legal effect, it can be used to interpret other provisions of the constitution. You can watch Nextias faculty's polity discussion of Pre 2020. He has explained this decently.
Legal effect, ka kya matlab nikale, it could be about taking inference (judicial) from it. Since supreme court declared it as part of the constitution. It is as good any other part of constitution.
Supreme Court can declare any law void if it violates that part of basic structure of preamble. So it has legal affect. But question is what is meaning of legal effect.
I took it as *legal bearing* in interpretation of constitutional provisions and marked its as C.(I did it)
But, If some body read. .. Legal effect = Justifiability ... Then A is answer..
🧐: i do not know what *legal effect* means actually.
I think it does not mean Justiciable ness in strictest terms. or .. I am wrong perhaps.
Depends .. How upsc interpretation goes for it.
appyfizz,What can be the answer of the CSAT passage about Education and Economic Freedom?3 only I have marked.
I have also marked option c ( 3 only)... passage has talked about eduaction, not higher education.... dont why coaching keys r not able to comprehend this...passage no where is talking about higer eduaction....whats ur take ?
If you look at the passage then there is this line "When people, thanks to lower tax rates are allowed to retain most of higher income that they gain from eachincremental level of education"
I think that probably talks of higher education. At least that is what I believe. I may be wrong
What can be the answer of the CSAT passage about Education and Economic Freedom?3 only I have marked.
I have also marked option c ( 3 only)... passage has talked about eduaction, not higher education.... dont why coaching keys r not able to comprehend this...passage no where is talking about higer eduaction....whats ur take ?
If you look at the passage then there is this line "When people, thanks to lower tax rates are allowed to retain most of higher income that they gain from eachincremental level of education"
I think that probably talks of higher education. At least that is what I believe. I may be wrong
incremental is very subjective word... also i would like to tell bhai....option also says that " tax cut invaribly leads to higher education" .. dont u think " Invariably " here is key word in relation to higher education..
I agree. It may be interpreted as such if it was just a general statement. Lower tax rates do not always mean investment in education. However, the question was asked in the specific context of the passage where author clearly has highlighted that it makes eminent sense to invest in education due to lower tax rates as people can retain higher income from each incremental level of education. So there is assumption here that Lower tax rates will invariably translate into greater investment in education since people get benefits from it. Rest UPSC is the judge.What can be the answer of the CSAT passage about Education and Economic Freedom?3 only I have marked.
I have also marked option c ( 3 only)... passage has talked about eduaction, not higher education.... dont why coaching keys r not able to comprehend this...passage no where is talking about higer eduaction....whats ur take ?
If you look at the passage then there is this line "When people, thanks to lower tax rates are allowed to retain most of higher income that they gain from eachincremental level of education"
I think that probably talks of higher education. At least that is what I believe. I may be wrong
incremental is very subjective word... also i would like to tell bhai....option also says that " tax cut invaribly leads to higher education" .. dont u think " Invariably " here is key word in relation to higher education..
gauravbrly409,
Write your comment…
