December 24, 2024   Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
Subscribe to ForumIAS
Dec 24, 2024  Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
1
Create
Create
Share GyanWrite an Article and share your knowledge or something you have learned recently.
Ask QuestionStart a discussion, ask a question, or ask for an opinion
Sign in

History Optional Students 2021- 2022

There was a thread in forum regarding history which was of great use let's make one again! 

OctagonalArcher,musaand20 otherslike this
86.6k views

295 comments

Commenting here while reading Upinder Singh! :P
BD,
14k views
+1. Lets prepare well for 2021, esp. the map portion.
14.1k views

Amit Chaturvedisaid

+1. Lets prepare well for 2021, esp. the map portion.

Have you been able to get some insights in what is working and what is not working for History optional people ?

From history optional people ?

I am no knight. Do not call me Sir|Philosophy behind ForumIAS

BD,
14k views
@SergioRamos never knew you had history optional!! 


SergioRamos,
15.2k views
@Neyawn Relevance of IgNou is going high day by day! 


15k views
What can be written under khalsa Evolution? 
14.9k views
@Freakhoto I believe IGNOU are important for every optional. Most of the coaching notes and mains test series are verbatim from IGNOU. Coachings are literally doing copy paste and taking 50k! :P


BD,No 1
14k views
@AmitChaturvedi  So many temple sites messed up my mapping portion! :(
Focusing on mapping in Feb!


13.7k views
@Freakhoto We can start from the transformation of the nature of gurudom. Then link it with ongoing hostility of Mughals to Sikhs and then trace to as regionalism in its infancy maybe?


13.7k views
@SergioRamos I was thinking of like this
Can we divide the khalsa panth evolution into three part? 
1. As a group to fight against the soxio religious group
2. As a Confederacy
3. As a sikh Monarch
14.9k views
@Freakhoto What all points you have for monarch?


13.6k views
@SergioRamos rise of ranjit singh!! 


14.9k views
@Freakhoto Yes! That is correct! 

Khalsa->Misls->Ranjit Singh. 
So we may start the answer with changing nature of gurudom, ie from hereditary to Gurdom perpetually vested in the book. Then bring the socio-political angle of Mughals and then lead to misls and regionalism.
Do you know any socio-economic angle to the evolution? Can it be said to be an assertion of the castes hitherto devoid of any political power as Sikhism attracted "lower castes"?

BD,
13.8k views

@AllMight  a place to discuss history optional. Tag more if you know!

13.6k views
@SergioRamos Obviously See Punjab as a region was always agriculturally rich with a lot of traders residing there.. Infact their breakup from Mughal empire was a due to their economic superiority. But due to the Overtone of linking and rise of Punjab as an independent state that angle is never explored... And we don't find if ever lower caste asserted their power! 

Another reason is that sikhism the ethos of equality were dominant .So there is no mention of class. so if they did also it doesn't find mention in literature! 

P. s Personal opinion ->IgNou me toh Sikhism ache se nahi diya! 


14.9k views
@Freakhoto Hmm okay!!! Will see if I find anything worthy on this and post it here!


13.6k views

Neyawnsaid

Amit Chaturvedisaid

+1. Lets prepare well for 2021, esp. the map portion.

Have you been able to get some insights in what is working and what is not working for History optional people ?

From history optional people ?

@Neyawn - Given my marks (120+165) + talks with a few others (with good marks), I was able to make some deductions but not sure if they are completely correct. 

Paper 1 - Sources are of paramount importance. (Since no conclusive evidence available for any inference).

Paper 2 - Analysis >>Facts.

BD,
14k views

SergioRamossaid

@AmitChaturvedi  So many temple sites messed up my mapping portion! :(
Focusing on mapping in Feb!


@SergioRamos - Map looked tough this time (Though I had not appeared this year).

13.9k views

What strategy do you guys use for maps?
I found this book pretty helpful.

https://www.amazon.in/Map-Entries-History-Optional-2ed-ebook/dp/B087BCQ8CN

BD,
13.5k views

Not a history optional guy but just stumbled upon this thread. Since you guys are discussing maps, I had this Chitra Mishra's map strategy pdf in my evernote as it seemed nice in terms of mapping historical locations for prelims. See if it helps, else ignore. Best wishes. MAP-SECTION-HISTORY-PAPER-1.pdf

SergioRamos,
14.5k views
Write your comment…