Mains 2019 Preparation and Discussion Thread

Disqualification ka matlab disqualified for being chosen as bhi ho sakta hai na?

@harsh12345S R Bommai case

@ManchesterUnitedThat's it right? I've been wrecking my brains trying to think of a case dealing with distribution of legislative powers!

@harsh12345Thats I could recall though!

@harsh12345Delhi gov vs centre recent one

@harsh12345i thought it was a philosophical ques on federalism, left after defining both the terms(esp after seeing legislative powers in ques)

@ManchesterUnited
we can add basic structure as well kesaavananda bharti case - seventh schedule and federalism are part of basic structure

@LostDo UTs share federal relation with centre?

@ManchesterUnitedwhat is the power of centre vs what is the power of ut was divided..not federal though

@ManchesterUnitedLol kyo hata diya bhai..sahi tha..

That's what I was thinking! Is there a similar case like the Delhi one where it's state vs centre?

@ManchesterUnitedwhat did you write in basic structure ?

@harsh12345harmonious construction bhi tha...maina socha relevant hai to likh diya

@dancingminionAmendment power-Limitations to absolute power by Art 13 and Judicial review methods
For Can basic structure be destroyed, I wrote it can be by quoting example of 24th amendment and judiciary can only give guidelines and law making is function of parliamnet
Concluded by writing why it should not be destroyed!

@LostBilkul relevant hai! Couldn't think of it then.

@dancingminion
Basic structure.

Evolution S. Swami case
Legislation abolished Judicial review.
Minerva Mill case.

SC didn't define Basic structure.
Ever evolving.
Constitutional Supremacy.

Conclusion: Can amend anything but within basic structure. So laws can be reviewed by judiciary to see whether they fall within basic structure...

@harsh12345@ManchesterUnitedne lol bol diya to maine socha galat hi hoga.

@LostNullius in verba!

@LostIt didnt bol bro
I just pooched

@ManchesterUnitedThis entire paper was nullius in verba personified! xD