Mains 2019 Preparation and Discussion Thread

@Phagocyteyaar it was difficult. I explained the two terms and gave example of concurrent list in harmonious construction and interstate water dispute in federal supremacy. In conclusion wrote rather than judiciary adjudicationg on legislative matter centre state can use the forum of niti or inter state Council in spirit of cooperative federalism. Also wrote recommendation of punchii commission.

@Aktgreat

@Akthow much marks are u people predicting ??

Sabke answers dekh kar Aisa lag rha hai....maine hi Sabse kharab likha hai️

@Lonewolfcutoff 750

@Yes_I_am_insaid inMains 2019 Preparation and Discussion Thread:

@Lonewolfcutoff 750

Same here... Expecting cut off to be around. Bhai there would be few answer which everyone would have written well. Overall gs2 was quite difficult.

@Lonewolfsaid inMains 2019 Preparation and Discussion Thread:

@Akthow much marks are u people predicting ??

Cut off around 750.whats ur take

bas disqualify na ho jaye gs 2 ke paper me

@Phagocytei wrote federal supremacy as that bommai case...harmonious construction as harmonisation between fundamental rights and directive principles along with case...1 number milega maximum

@Yes_I_am_indon't worry! This question was vague with no pre-defined answer. It's open for multiple interpretations.

cooperate collaborate wale me what have u all written?

@STwhich

@ranyo_asokabhai maine to niti aayog ka bhi point likh diya hai, keeping harmonious construction in mind

@madeyecooperative federalism aspect?aur kya likhe ho

@corrigible_87Bhai 63 to aa hi jayenge. Don't get tensed.

@VikaLol. haan umeed to hai : )

@PhagocyteThey had put within ' ' which means it might have had some very specific context. Probably used by SC in some case, the Law or PSIR guys may throw some light.

@ranyo_asokayes, co operative federalism. GST as a concept of pooled sovereignty but apprehension of central supremacy. Yahi sab kuch kuch bakwass kiya hai maine. Koi solid point hi nai tha. Thora centre state relation pe bhi light throw kiya, finance comission. Need to fill vacuum after dismantling of planning commission.
Kaam ki koi baat nai likhi, bas maan ki baat

Ye upsc ki site pe representation ka kya mtlb hai mains k liye ??

@ranyo_asokaitbwas about distribution of legislative power and not about FR and DPSP