Subscribe to ForumIAS

Official: SFG / RLG All Tests Discussions in one place

Wrt Q.7 of Test 8, the 3rd statement - the CM of Puducherry and Delhi are appointed by the President, though sworn in by Lt. Gov. Won't that be the case in J&K also?


According to Section 54 of the JAMMU AND KASHMIR REORGANISATION ACT, The Chief Minister shall be appointed by the Lieutenant Governor and the other Ministers shall be appointed by the Lieutenant Governor on the advice of the Chief Minister.

Please refer to the link given below.

http://egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2019/210407.pdf

2.3k views




Hi@Thinker 

Q35 Test 9

There is misalignment of options as answer should be B and explanation is also correct but answer option is given wrong as A

Also the 3rd statement clearly says that president appoints SAT members yet, the option is termed as correct. 

Please clear this out. Thank you




It seems there may have been a typing error. In any case, Both statements 1 and 2 will be correct and 3rd will be incorrect. 


2.3k views

@Thinker Q32 in today's paper-

Both Anugraha Narayan Sinha and J B Kripalani were teachers, not just the latter.Marks should be awarded for both options or the question should be cancelled.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J._B._Kripalani

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anugrah_Narayan_Sinha

All the mentioned options acted as a teacher sometimes down their life but the question is asking for the profession as a teacher and most appropriate option is J B Kriplani. Always tick the most appropriate answers that the thumb rule of UPSC.   

2.3k views

@Thinker 

Mahadayi river flows through 3 states Goa, Maharashtra and Karnataka but in explanation sheet of test 7 question no 41 it is written only 2 Goa and Karnataka . Tribunal also shared water between these 3 states not 2. 

Theonlyin the explanation sheet must have been written by mistake. In the class, it was discussed that it flows through 3 states Goa, Maharashtra and Karnataka. 

2.3k views

@Thinker 

Test 11 Q37 

Dadabhai Naoroji

Statement 1 :-

He propounded the theory of Drain of wealth for the first time in his book Poverty and Un British rule in India .

( Why this statement is wrong???)

He propounded this theory for the first time in 1867. The book was published later I guess around 1901. So the statements stands incorrect. Because He did not propound the theory in his book for the first time.  

2.3k views

Test no. 14 SFG 2 

Answe given for question number 29 and 42 are wrong 

Q.no. 29 3rd sentence is wrong 

Gandhi described the Cripps mission as a post-dated cheque not nehru 

Q.no. 42 again 3rd sentense is wrong 

Faizpur session of INC is chaired by Jawaharlal Nehru not Subhash Chandra Bose

Forumias ,please make the changes in answer key

Please read the questions correctly. Both the questions asked that ''Which of the statements given above is/arenot correct?''

For Ques 29:  Gandhiji (not Jawaharlal Nehru) described the Cripps offer as a Post-Dated cheque. 

For Ques 42: Faizpur session of INC is chaired by Jawaharlal Nehru, not Subhash Chandra Bose.



2.6k views

Test 14 Q no. 49 first session was held in bombay or calcutta? 

Yes, it is Bombay and not Calcutta. I hope they will update the answer.

2.6k views

The answer provided in Test 14 Answer Key (SFG 2, 2020) for question number 49 is wrong. As first session of an All India StatesPeople's Conference was held in ''Bombay'' in December 1927 and not in Calcutta. So answer should be ''B (2 & 3 only)''.                                                 Thanking You.   https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/All_India_States_Peoples%27_Conference.        

The answer will be B only.  The first session of All India State’s People’s Conference was held in Bombay and not Calcutta. Let's wait for them to update it. 

2.6k views

Q19 Test 13

Muslim League did participate in 3rd RTC with leaders like Agha Khan, Muhammad Ali, Fazlul Haq, Jinnah.

Therefore according to it answer should be B rather than A.

@root @Thinker 

The Muslim League did not participate in the 3rd RTC. 

You can refer to this link. https://api.parliament.uk/historic-hansard/commons/1932/oct/31/round-table-conference-delegates and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Round_Table_Conferences_(India).

Also, Mr. Jinnah did not attend the 3rd session of RTC as Congress was once again boycotted the third session of RTC. Link- http://www.ajssh.leena-luna.co.jp/AJSSHPDFs/Vol.5(1)/AJSSH2016(5.1-12).pdf

I hope it helps. 


2.6k views

@Thinker 


W.r.t Q26 Test 13 

Was the poona pact signed between Mahatma Gandhi and Dr. Ambedkar where Madan Malviya signed it on behalf of Gandhiji or Was it directly between Madan Mohan Malviya and Dr. B R Ambedkar?

The Poona Pact was in fact signed by Madan Mohan Malviya and B.R Ambedkar.Madan Mohan Malviyarepresented upper-caste Hindus and Ambedkar represented the Depressed classes. They both signed the Poona Pact. Gandhiji more or less acted as an intermediary between them.

2.6k views

@Thinker 

Q4 test 13

How is Jinnah associated with khilafat?

Even according to Wikipedia the answer should be  A and not C.

The question asks about ''associated''. Jinnah reluctantly agreed to the program and even attended a few Khilafat meetings. Hence I guess this counts as being associated with it.

2.6k views
@Disciple but then 2nd option is directed associated with khilafat movement.. then the answer should have been 1234.. which in not an option.

And as per your explanation, I have found no particular source of Jinnah being associated with khilafat.


But the options were changed in the classroom itself before the beginning of the test. and Option C was changed to ''1,2, 3 AND 4''. 

2.5k views
@ForumIAS-Academy  In the updated schedule of SFG-2 few topics are repeated. Is that intentional?


They have updated it again. I just got an email. Recheck it. 

2.5k views

Test 15, Question 5:

-Calcutta Madarsa was established by Warren Hastings

-Fort William college was also set up by Wellesley in 1800.

But the options provided didn't have both 2 & 3. Please tell me where am i going wrong?

This is a previous year's UPSC Question.  Fort William College was founded by Richard Wellesly and not by Arthur Wellesly. 

2.5k views

SFG 2--Test-16- Q.39

Statement-2  should be correct.

•The Govt.passed the Sikh Gurudwara Act,1922 to pacify the Akalis.

Ans.must be (C)-Both 1& 2

Even I had read this. But when I researched, the Gurdwara Act of 1922 was officially called The Gurdwara and Shrines Act, 1922. This Act was later repealed by theGurdwara Act of 1925.  So the statement stands wrong. Had the statement said, only an act( without mentioning the name) was passed in 1922 to pacify the Akalis, then the statement would have been correct. 

2.5k views

@Thinker 

Test 16 Q39

Akali Movement

Statement 2 

The Government passed the SikhGurudwara Act 1922 to pacify the Akalis.

( This statement should be correct , Attaching pg from spectrum )

Answer should be C


Even I had read this. But when I researched, the Gurdwara Act of 1922 was officially called The Gurdwara and Shrines Act, 1922. This Act was later repealed by the Gurdwara Act of 1925.  So the statement stands wrong. Had the statement said, only an act( without mentioning the name) was passed in 1922 to pacify the Akalis, then the statement would have been correct. 

2.5k views

sirQ 31Answer should be option A

@root @Jack__Sparrow @curious_kid 

What is wrong with the second statement? Karnataka has the highest overall rank and is the most innovativeMajorstate. I think it is correct. Correct me if I am wrong.

3k views

yraj38said

SFG-2, Test 17

Question 6 and 22 have been incorrectly explained. Please Correct them.

Q6-  Lepakshi Paintings DO NOT follow  a religious theme.

Q22- Indus script is Right to Left ( Boustrophedonic )

Q.6) Lepakshi paintings do follow a religious theme. The statement you are quoting is probably from the OLD edition of Nitin Singhania. But it has been updated in the subsequent version which says that Lepakshi paintings do follow a religious theme. Also, you can go through the images in the temple. they do follow a religious theme. 


Q.22) As you said, the Indus Script is a  Boustrophedonic script. Right to left in one line and left to right in another. So what is the confusion? The second statement is obviously wrong. 

3k views

sirQ 31Answer should be option A

@root @Jack__Sparrow @curious_kid 

I think they picked the question from this link. Just check if you wish. 

https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=193852



Yes, I checked it. and it clearly says that Karnataka is the most innovative major state in India. What is wrong with it?

3k views

Test 23-Question: 47

Avangard is a Hypersonic missile but isnt hypersonic as subset of supersonic.

Supersonic range: >1 mach

Hypersonic range: >5 machs

Please elaborate.

I don't think UPSC will accept this logic. Hypersonic and Supersonic have clear distinct definitions. 

2.7k views

Few bloopers in today's discussion. See these corrections and point out if I'm wrong.

04:28-"Yellow and red light will scatter more and the sun will appear reddish".Wrong. During sunrise and sunset, it is the shorter wavelength that is scattered away as solar radiation being oblique traverses greater distance and what reaches us are the longer wavelength i.e Yellow, Orange, and Red.

10:03-"Without an ITCZ, strong wind shear will not be possible".Gives a sense that wind shear is necessary for cyclone formation which is clearly wrong.

23:10-"Nigeria is in Northern Africa".Wrong. Nigeria is in Western Africa.The same mistake was in the test 21 discussion video too!



No doubt Nigeria is in the west, but if you divide Africa into 2 rough halves, it is in the northern part. Maybe by that, he meant that Nigeria is north of the Equator. 

2.7k views

Q no 49 test no.25 please change the answer as per given explanation

It must have been a typing error! I hope they change it.

2.8k views

Q 42. Pliz have a look.... I find Duars formation is common in foothills of both sikkim,darjeeling himalayas and of arunachal himalayas..... Correct me if m wrong... How preference is given to sikkim darjeeling himalayas?

The NCERT mentions about arunachal himalayas due to roughed topography the inter-valley transportation linkages are notional so, most interactions are through duar region along arunachal assam border. Pg no 14


We are supposed to find the best suitable option. If such a question comes in UPSC, we cannot fight with them. The answer will be Sikkim and Darjeeling Himalayas in this ase.

2.8k views

Anonsaid

TEST 25  Q 13

Answer is A as per the explanation and otherwise but the correct answer given is C

The boundary line separating one drainage basin from the other is known as Water divide 

There is nothing wrong with the second statement, The boundary line separating one drainage basin from the other is known as the watershed. A drainage divide, water divide, divide, ridgeline, watershed, water parting or height of land is elevated terrain that separates neighboring drainage basins. The answer will be c only. They must have been trying to elaborate on the second statement's explanation.

2.8k views

Bishwasaid

@Thinker test 26- question number 49, tropical moist deciduous consist of 37% area, while dry deciduous covers 28% area. Please clarify as it contradicts the given answer

Please update your information regularly. The recent ISFR has clearly mentioned otherwise. Do check. Someone has updated a picture of the same.

2.8k views

WRT question no 32, test 26  the shadow zone is between 102 to 143 degree . SO the answer and explanation needs to be rechecked.

Shadow Zone - Earthquake Glossary

The NCERT mentions 105 and 145 degrees. You can refer this link 

http://www.ncert.nic.in/ncerts/l/kegy203.pdf



2.8k views

WRT question no 30, test 26 sandal wood is found in himalayas.

If you travel through the Himalayas, you are likely ... - GKToday

Govt removes curbs on growing sandalwood | Bengaluru ...



Please do not refer to GK today for previous year questions. You can check and verify the answer from UPSC Ques paper and answer key. This is a 2014 question paper, I am attaching the links for the question paper and answer key. And to make it easier for you, This is Q.23. The answer is A only.

https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/General%20studies-I.pdf

https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/CSP_14_Gen_Study_I0001.pdf



2.8k views

You can check and verify the answer from UPSC Ques paper and answer key. This is a 2014 question paper, I am attaching the links for the question paper and answer key. And to make it easier for you, This is Q.23. The answer is A only.

https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/General%20studies-I.pdf

https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/CSP_14_Gen_Study_I0001.pdf

2.6k views

SFG test 25 Q:49 answer is wrong

How can the answer of question no 49 (SFG test 25) be ‘b’. The answer should be ‘d’

A Corrigendum was given the same day when the paper was published. The answer will be D. 


2.6k views

SFG batch 2. TEST 26

Question number 30


Sandalwood is found in deciduous forest. Deciduous forest are found in foothills of himalayas, so shouldn't the answer be 1,2&3.

You can check and verify the answer from UPSC Ques paper and answer key. This is a 2014 question paper, I am attaching the links for the question paper and answer key. And to make it easier for you, This is Q.23. The answer is A only.

https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/General%20studies-I.pdf

https://www.upsc.gov.in/sites/default/files/CSP_14_Gen_Study_I0001.pdf

2.6k views

SFG 2 TEST 28


Q 4   As per arrow is given.it has created an unnecessary confusion, Answer should be B 

Road >Railway >Waterway >Air

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Q 21 With reference to the Uranium, consider the following statements:

1. The Bureau of Indian Standard has no specific guidelines for maximum permissible limit of radioactive elements including Uranium in drinking water.

 This statements must be correct as per "THE HINDU". Answer should be "A" instead of "D".

https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/science/severe-uranium-contamination-in-indias-groundwater-study/article24122258.ece




Hi,

For Ques no 21, Why are you sending and pasting a link from 2018? It is 2 years old. Update your information and Please cross-verify your information from authentic sources. 

The Indian Standard IS 10500: 2012 for Drinking Water specification has specified the maximum acceptable limits for radioactive residues as alpha and beta emitters, values in excess of which render the water not suitable. These requirements take into account all radioactive elements including uranium. No individual radioactive elements have been specifically identified.

https://pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=1606572

and for Q.4- The question clearly mentions that arrange the following in the increasing order.This isnot a CSAT paperthat you will consider the ''greater than and less than sign''. They must have used that to show a transition from one form of transport to others. 


2.8k views

The Brahmaputra, Irrawaddy and Mekong rivers originate in Tibet and flow through narrow and parallel mountain ranges in their upper reaches. Of these rivers, Brahmaputra makes a 'U' turn in its course to flow into India. This 'U' turn is due to

a Uplift of folded Himalayan series
b Syntaxial bending of geologically young Himalayas
c Geo-tectonic disturbance in the tertiary folded mountain chains
d Both (a) and (b) above

question 25 answer should be D

https://www.jagranjosh.com/articles/ias-prelims-2014-importance-of-indian-geography-1393482065-1

Please and Please referring to Jagranjosh as a source for your UPSC preparation. This is a previous year question from 2011, answer is B only. Search for the official paper online if you want.

2.8k views

PJsaid

Given answer of Question no 4 of Test 28 is wrong.

Answer should be Road>Railway>Waterway>Air

Greater than sign has been used instead of using arrows. It is misleading.

The question clearly mentions that arrange the following in the increasing order. This is not a CSAT paper that you will consider the ''greater than and less than sign''.

2.8k views

Bishwasaid

@Thinker today's test, question 26_- UP is largest producer of sugarcane as per recent data and not Maharashtra

I hope they change the answer accordingly.

2.8k views

Wind energy causes noise pollution Q 18

UP is the largest producer of sugarcane.

Q.18) Isn't wind energy pollution-free? How does wind energy cause noise pollution? The turbines may cause it. Just asking for my clarification. Also, this is a verbatim statement from the NCERT. You can check that when you read it.


And for UP, I hope they change the answer. 

2.8k views

@Thinker  Test 28 Question 18

Statement 2 : 2. Wind Energy is a pollution free energy resource.

Isn't windmills cause noise pollution?

Windmills may cause noise pollution, but how does your explanation help negating the statement that wind energy is pollution-free. Also, this is a statement from the NCERT. 

2.8k views

Test 30, Ques 36, Statement 1: It refers to the physical position and functional role of a species within the community.

Instead of 'community', it should be 'ecological system' as a niche includes food habits, habitats, etc. 

Hi, 

This statement is verbatim from the NCERT. An ecological niche is a physical position and functional role of a species within the community. Also, he focus area of the term "Ecological  Niche" is  - the physical position and functional role of a species within the community of organisms it is a part of. The mere use of the word "community" in place of "ecosystem" (as is used in the standard definition) does not make the statement 1 incorrect.


3.1k views

T30 q24 transfer of energy is always unidirectional from one trophic level to another . 

You are right in saying that in a food chain, energy flows from lower trophic levels to the higher trophic levels.

Thus, in a food chain, there is only one direction of energy flow. However, since a Food Chain is a simplistic model of reality.

In reality, an organism can be a part of multiple food chains. Hence in nature, energy flow is occurring not just along "one"

food chain,but along many different food chains. It is in this context, is the word "unidirectional" is used for explaining

energy flow in afood chain and the phrase "all directions" is used for explaining energy flow in a food web.


In Question 24, Statement 1 is -

"In the food web, energy transfer is possible in all directions whereasin the food chain it is unidirectional."

We need to read the whole statement together to understand that the words "all directions" does notimply " energy flow in a single food chain".

It isnotimplying that energy flow can occur from higher trophic levels to lower trophic levels.

Rather, it is used to imply the existence of energy flow along different food chains a single organism is a part of.


3.1k views

SFG batch 2 test 30

Question number 17

Ephernerals are free from any xerophilous adaptations. Also, the species which survive dry season are called rain perennials ajd not Ephernerals. 

That is what is written in the explanation. The ephemerals are delicate species without any special (xerophilous) adaptations.Xerophile or xerophilous meansdry-loving or drought-loving organisms,such as plants being characterized by various ecologic adaptations to desert life, such as excessively long roots, fleshy stems (cacti) or thin leaves (acacia). But ephemeralsappear soon after the rains, grow and bloom with flowers and fruits for a very short period. They die out as soon as the soil moisture dries up.

In general, also,An ephemeral plant is one marked by short life cycles. Desert ephemerals are plants that are adapted to take advantage of the short wet periods in arid climates. What is wrong with the statement according to you? I think the statement is correct. 
3.1k views

 In this quen ans given at various online platform is d.. I have confusion in gypsum statement.. I think this is correct but ans given is c....@Disciple @Thinker  


Which of the following practices can help in water conservation in agriculture? 

1. Reduced or zero tillage of the land 

2. Applying gypsum before irrigating the field 

3. Allowing crop residue to remain in the field 

Select the correct answer using the code given below.

a 1 and 2 only‎
b 3 only
c 1 and 3 only ‎
d 1, 2 and 3

Rather than searching previous year questions in various platforms, please follow the official website. This is a 2017 question, for a person preparing UPSC, all the previous year papers should be downloaded or printed. Also the answer provided in the official key is C. 

3.1k views
see this.It incorporates both grazing as well as detritus food chains as its sub-components. Doesn't it seem to be multidirectional?
Moreover it was to be referenced w.r.t comparative unidirectional aspects of food chain as a concept.



Sir in this article , no where it is mentioned that foodweb has multidirection energy flow. 

Energy (as a concept ) flows in the direction from lower trophic level to higher trophic level ( in both detritus and grazing food chain) 

food web is to depict interconnection of different food chainsand  not “multidirection” energy flow . Even in food web energy flow from lower to higher trophic level only

The multi-directional used in the question statement was not pertaining to trophic levels according to me. It was in the other context. "In the food web, energy transfer is possible in all directions whereas in the food chain it is unidirectional." We need to read the whole statement together to understand that the words "all directions" does not imply " energy flow in a single food chain". It is not implying that energy flow can occur from higher trophic levels to lower trophic levels. Rather, it is used to imply the existence of energy flow along different food chains a single organism is a part of. 




 

2.9k views

Mosquitoes sucking human blood is an example of parasitism.

How this is wrong.  In explanation it talks about female mosquito but here its not clear. 

Pls explain@Disciple 

Mosquitoes are not a parasite. They belong to phylum Arthropoda hence they are insects. Parasites are living creatures that need a host for its life cycle. Parasites solely depend upon the host for their survival and live in the body or on the body of the host. Mosquitoes do not drink blood because of their nutritional requirements. If they did so, then male mosquitoes cannot. But only the female ones drinks the blood. Nutritional requirements of mosquito are fulfilled by plant sources. They are not actually parasites because female mosquitoes only need blood to lay eggs. Both the males and females feed on nectar and plant juices and do not rely on blood as a food source.

2.9k views

@Disciple Sir, how should we go about chapter 11 of Shankar on various animals in different schedules of WPA,1972 ... What would we the efficient way to go through this list or should we try to go in it.s entirety ? 

Anyone else who has any suggestion regarding this..

For the schedules, you should know what is the exact purpose of the schedule. For example, animals in Schedule I are the most protected animals, so by that logic you can eliminate the options. Plus Schedule VI only contains a list of 6 plants, you need to remember that. I personally do not think it is possible for me to learn all the animals in the schedules, it will be a waste of time.

2.9k views

@Thinker Test 32 Q33. Snow Leopards are not endemic to India. 

Yes, you are right. They will probably change the answer because  Snow leopards are found in 12 countries—including China, Bhutan, Nepal, India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Russia, and Mongolia.  

2.9k views

Test 32, Ques 33: Statement 1 says endemic to those places. Doesn't it mean that it is not found anywhere else which is not the case as it is found in central Asia as well.

Or is the statement talking only about regions in India where its population is found. Can you please clarify? 

They will probably change the answer. Even I marked it B. Because they are found in other countries as well.

2.9k views

Test 33, Ques 4:  as per upsc answer key, statement 3 is wrong

I just checked that the question was from 2012 UPSC Prelims. But the recent studies and journals, particularly from 2013, support the statement. You can check these links https://www.nature.com/news/rising-ocean-acidity-will-exacerbate-global-warming-1.13602 and https://www.the-scientist.com/the-nutshell/ocean-acidity-affects-climate-38812

2.8k views

What is iucn status of leatherback turtle.  In explanation of test it was given critically endangered but iucn site shows vulnerable.@Disciple kindly guide

Are you referring to the explanation given in sfg 32?

2.8k views

Test 34 Q1

Statement 2 isincorrect.Answer must be"A"

Consider the following statements regarding the National Supercomputing Mission (NSM):

2. It is implemented and steered jointly by the Department of Science and Technology (DST) and Department of Electronics and Information Technology (DeitY).

Refer this PIB Release :

https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=200608

 National Super Computing Mission is steered jointly by the Ministry of Electronics and IT (MeitY) and Department of Science and Technology (DST) and implemented by the Centre for Development of Advanced Computing (C-DAC), Pune and the Indian Institute of Science (IISc), Bengaluru.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Q3: Correct answer is left "blank".Not counted in Scorecard. Please update it in answer key as per Explanation givenas"A" 




For Q.1) The information mentioned in the second statement is from the NSM website, but I guess it is old. You have pasted a recent link. I hope they take a note and change the answer. 

Q.3) They probably will consider it while making the rank list. 

2.8k views

Test 34 Question 21:

Consider the following statements regarding the Money Bill:

1. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha is authorised to decide whether the Bill is a Money Bill or not.

2. It has to be introduced in the Lok Sabha as per Article 110 of the Constitution.   

What does the second statement mean in this context?
A-110 does not contain the procedure to introduce the money bill but what constitutes a money bill. It does create a doubt whether it talks aboutArticle 109 i.e: special procedures to introduce a money bill

It probably means that it has to be introduced in the Lok Sabha as per the provisions of Article 110. I understand what you are saying, but the statement indicates otherwise. As in, A Money Bill can be introduced in the Lok Sabha if it contains the provisions of the imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax;( this second part is as per article 110).

2.8k views

FCsaid

sfg test 34, Q34.

statements wrt National Bamboo Mission.

Krishonnati Yojana has 12 missions/sub-schemes including National Mission on Sustainable Agri....& also MIDH (Mission on Integrated Development of Horticulture).

https://pib.gov.in/Pressreleaseshare.aspx?PRID=1580432

While the correct statement in Q34 says that Nat Bamboo Mission is sub scheme of National Mission on Sustainable Agri....I couldn't find it under this. However, as per what i know its a sub-scheme of MIDH instead.

https://vikaspedia.in/agriculture/policies-and-schemes/crops-related/krishi-unnati-yojana/mission-for-integrated-development-of-horticulture/national-horticulture-mission


Please let me know whether I am wrong ?

Please refer to the operating guidelines of 2019,

https://www.nbm.nic.in/Documents/pdf/NBM_Revised_Guidelines.pdf




2.8k views

SFG batch 2, Test 35

Question number 26. Statement 2.

Private remittance (which is calculated as net ie. Total incoming minus outgoing remittance) is part of GNP calculation. Hence income generated by foreigners in india is part of GNP calculation. This makes the 2nd statement wrong and correspondingly correct option should be D instead of B. 

GNP is commonly calculated by taking the sum of personal consumption expenditures, private domestic investment, government expenditure, net exports and any income earned by residents from overseas investments, minus income earned within the domestic economy by foreign residents.
Private Remittance = Incoming Remittance (which would have been sent by Indians living abroad) - Outgoing Remittance (Which is sent by Foreigners living in India) is part of Gross National Product (GNP).
Since the outgoing remittance is getting subtracted from it, it can not be a part of GNP.
2.8k views
@ARS21 core iip by commerce ministry... iip by by mospi.... 


@Jhaljit_forum can you quote a source on this? i have tried searching and it is given that initially Ministry of Commerce calculated it but later it was transferred to MoSPI

http://mospi.nic.in/iip

A simple google search would have helped you. 

The monthly Index of Eight Core Industries (ICI) is a production volume index. ICI

measures the collective and individual performance of production in selected eight core industries

viz. Coal, Crude Oil, Natural Gas, Refinery Products, Fertilizers, Steel, Cement, and Electricity.

It is compiled and released by Office of the Economic Adviser (OEA), Department of Industrial

Policy & Promotion (DIPP), and Ministry of Commerce & Industry. The inter-se weights of

these eight industries are largely in alignment with the respective weight of these industries in

the Index of Industrial Production (IIP). 

https://eaindustry.nic.in/eight_core_infra/ICI_Compilation_Methodology.pdf

2.8k views
@ARS21 core iip by commerce ministry... iip by by mospi.... 


@Jhaljit_forum can you quote a source on this? i have tried searching and it is given that initially Ministry of Commerce calculated it but later it was transferred to MoSPI

http://mospi.nic.in/iip

 The monthly Index of Eight Core Industries (ICI) is a production volume index. ICI

measures collective and individual performance of production in selected eight core industries

viz. Coal, Crude Oil, Natural Gas, Refinery Products, Fertilizers, Steel, Cement and Electricity.

It is compiled and released by Office of the Economic Adviser (OEA), Department of Industrial

Policy & Promotion (DIPP), and Ministry of Commerce & Industry. The inter-se weights of

these eight industries are largely in alignment with the respective weight of these industries in

the Index of Industrial Production (IIP). 

https://eaindustry.nic.in/eight_core_infra/ICI_Compilation_Methodology.pdf


Also if you look at the PIB links you can see that for the core industries the data is provided by Commerce Ministry and For the IIP in general by the MoSPI. For your reference,

https://pib.gov.in/newsite/PrintRelease.aspx?relid=199633

https://pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetail.aspx?PRID=1599044



2.8k views

Test 37, Q40


Doesn't pendency of cases affect Resolving insolvency and Enforcing contracts as a measure of EoDB?  IIRC, Eco Survey - 18 also talks about need to reduce pendency of cases to improve  EODB.

The question specifically asks for the components of the Ease of Doing Business Report.  And according to world bank reduction injudicial pendencyis not one of the components. The component is Resolving insolvency.Sometimes you do not have you choose the best option that is available. 

2.8k views

PJsaid

w.r.t Test 37 Q 37 

RBI issues and exchanges or destroys currency and coins not fit for circulation

Does RBI have the power to issue coins?

Same doubt

As perthe Coinage Act, 1906,the Government of India has the sole right to mint coins and the responsibilityfor coinage vests with the Government. But, The coins areissued for circulation only through the Reserve Bankin terms of the RBI Act.

Functions of RBI

The issuer of the currency:

Issues and exchanges or destroys currency and coins not fit for circulation.

Objective: to give the public an adequate quantity of supplies of currency notes and coins and in good quality.

These statements are taken verbatim from the RBI Website.

https://www.rbi.org.in/Scripts/AboutusDisplay.aspx

https://www.rbi.org.in/scripts/ic_coins.aspx

2.8k views

Test 37, Ques 49: Statement 1 says RBI but wasn't BPSS created for the purpose of regulation and supervision of payment systems.


Can someone confirm this?

 The PSS Act, 2007 provides for the regulation and supervision of payment systems in India and designates the Reserve Bank of India (Reserve Bank) as the authority for that purpose and all related matters.The Reserve Bank is authorized under the Act to constitute a Committee of its Central Board known as the Board for Regulation and Supervision of Payment and Settlement Systems (BPSS), to exercise its powers and perform its functions and discharge its duties under this statute. The Act also provides the legal basis for “netting” and “settlement finality”. This is of great importance, as in India, other than the Real Time Gross Settlement (RTGS) system all other payment systems function on a net settlement basis.

https://m.rbi.org.in/Scripts/FAQView.aspx?Id=73


2.8k views

Q.28 Many sources are saying icsid as a part of world bank... Pliz clarify...  Even dere official sites

The Question asks 'India is not a member of which of the organizations given above?'.  The others given in the options are also part of World Bank Group. India is not a member of ICSID.

https://icsid.worldbank.org/en/Pages/icsiddocs/List-of-Member-States.aspx


2.8k views

Test 37, Q40


Doesn't pendency of cases affect Resolving insolvency and Enforcing contracts as a measure of EoDB?  IIRC, Eco Survey - 18 also talks about need to reduce pendency of cases to improve  EODB.

The question specifically asks for the components of the Ease of Doing Business Report.  And according to world bank reduction injudicial pendencyis not one of the components. The component is Resolving insolvency.Sometimes you do not have you choose the best option that is available. 

By that logic,labour market regulationis not a component in EoDB report. There are only 10 components, I don't know from where did Forum come up with 11 factors. They are giving same explanation since past 2 tests, which is wrong.  I am attaching official ranking screen-shot. 


Also, question is askingwhat factors are taken into accountnot what aresub-indices (which are components of EoDB)

Bhai Read the question! It asks about the Ease of Doing Business Report not index. They are different. 

Regulations affecting11 areas of the life of a business are covered:

starting a business, dealing with construction permits, getting electricity, registering property, getting credit, protecting minority investors, paying taxes, trading across borders, enforcing contracts, resolving insolvency andlabor market regulation. The labor market regulation data are not included in this year’s ranking on the ease of doing business.

 I am not making this up and neither is forum probably( can't say because I am not the representative), This is from the official report. You can search for the keywords 'labor market regulation'. 

https://www.doingbusiness.org/content/dam/doingBusiness/media/Annual-Reports/English/DB2019-report_web-version.pdf

Also, the explanation is from Ramesh Singh. 

https://books.google.co.in/books?id=bmovDwAAQBAJ&pg=PT376&lpg=PT376&dq=doing+business+report+labour+market+regulation+ramesh+singh&source=bl&ots=f545Ypgn4x&sig=ACfU3U1CRTFqYBhe6Bwb_GQywssuJPPeuQ&hl=en&sa=X&ved=2ahUKEwid7PTN29noAhVazjgGHTL7Cb0Q6AEwAHoECAsQKQ#v=onepage&q=doing%20business%20report%20labour%20market%20regulation%20ramesh%20singh&f=false

Attaching both the links because you probably won't google yourself!

I hope this clears your doubts!










2.8k views
Same doubt


Read the thread!@bernoullitrials has also explained it. Also, I have commented on certain posts. 

2.8k views

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

Crowding out effect - The crowding-out effect is an economic theory arguing that rising public sector spending drives down or even eliminates private sector spending.

You are confusing the way government functions from the way private sector functions. The government can borrow money for expenditure as well as investment, on the other hand the private sector can undertake borrowing only for further investment.

A private entity can not be sustainable if its income is not higher than its expenditure. Thus when the private sector borrows money, it uses that money to expand its production capacity to generate further income only.

However, since crowding out effect leads to an increase in interest rates, the private sector will find it more difficult to undertake further investment decisions. Thus they would not indulge in the expansion of their production capacity, thereby reducing the private sector's expenditure which would have taken place had the interest rates been lower.


2.9k views

ARS21said

STT isdirecttax?


Securities Transaction Tax (STT) is a type of financial transaction tax levied in India on transactions done on the domestic stock exchanges. The rates of STT are prescribed by the Central / Union Government through its Budget from time to time. In tax parlance, this is categorised as a direct tax.

2.9k views

SFG batch 2, test 42

Question number 24. Statement 1.

Bimbisara was not a disciple of Buddhism. "Bimbisara was contemporary to both Mahavira and gautam buddha. Both religions claim him as their supporters and devotee." 

Quoted from TN board book

How did you come to this conclusion from one single statement? This is history, you need to refer to other sources. One single Google search or if you had read other NCERTs then it would have been easier for you. 

King Bimbisara met the Buddha for the first time prior to the Buddha's enlightenment and later became an important disciple. Kings like Prasanajit of Kosala, Bimbisar, and Ajatshatru of Magadh accepted his Doctrines and became his disciples. 

2.9k views

Test 45, Q47

Could someone elaborate on the statement that 'the founders of Buddhism and Jainism came from Republican states.' ? 

The statement means that both Mahavira and Buddha belonged to the Mahajanpads/Jandapadas that were a republic. To break it down for you, Mahavira was from Vaishali ( Vajji/Vrajji Mahajanpada) and Buddha was born in a Shakya Kshatriya family in Lumbini near Kapilavastu. Shakyas of Kapilavastu was a tribal Republican territory. 

2.9k views

SFG BATCH 2  Test 42 Q 5

Statement 3:

3. Rigvedic Aryans had domesticated the horse whereas there is no evidence of Indus Valley people having been aware of this animal.

 As per TN board book, it is actually not mentioned that Indus valley people  are not aware of Horses.

(Pg No. 20)

As per wikipedia:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surkotada


Statement 3 must be wrong.Answer should be "A".






Its a previous year question. You should refer to the UPSC answer key and not wiki.

3.1k views

Test 42

Q 7- explanation of statement 1 Sthulbahu was the leader of svetambars and Bhadrabhu was leader of Digambars.

Q-24 -  Buddha does not recognize the existence of soul and god (NCERT RS Sharma). so how can Statement 2 be incorrect ?


For the 7th Question, you are correct. But in any case, the statement is incorrect. Maybe they mistyped it in the explanation. 

Q. 24) Buddha neither accepted nor rejected the existence of God. He was more concerned about

the individual and his actions. This is the statements from IGNOU book. 

3.1k views

yraj38said

SFG test-42

Q-3, rituals were there in Yajurveda and Sacrifices were there in Atharvaveda

Q-7, 2nd Jain Council 513 A.D. or 526 A.D. so it is 6th century not 5th.

Q-14, Patliputra is on the confluence of Gandak and Ganga

Q-16 Domestication of animals started in Neolithic. ( A few associations may be seen later mesolithic age).

Q.3) The Atharva Veda mentions about the practices and the details of the rituals of the Non- Aryan People and their related activities during the later Vedic period. 

Q.7) But I read the statement in the NCERT. ( I hope forum gives an explanation for this). Not sure about it myself. 

Q.14) It is situated on the confluence of three rivers, the Ganga, the Gandak, and the Son. So, this statement is correct. 

Q.16) Always remember this, Domestication of animals started in the Mesolithic period only. This is a very common fact. 

3.1k views

mhs11said

Test 43 Q13

2. The Mehrauli Iron inscription mentioned his extensive conquest

Doesnt Mehrauli inscription belong to Chandragupta II?

Yes you are right, it only mentions King Chandra and historians have identified him as Chandragupta II. 

3.1k views

yraj38said

yraj38said

SFG test-42

Q-3, rituals were there in Yajurveda and Sacrifices were there in Atharvaveda

Q-7, 2nd Jain Council 513 A.D. or 526 A.D. so it is 6th century not 5th.

Q-14, Patliputra is on the confluence of Gandak and Ganga

Q-16 Domestication of animals started in Neolithic. ( A few associations may be seen later mesolithic age).

Q.3) The Atharva Veda mentions about the practices and the details of the rituals of the Non- Aryan People and their related activities during the later Vedic period. 

Q.7) But I read the statement in the NCERT. ( I hope forum gives an explanation for this). Not sure about it myself. 

Q.14) It is situated on the confluence of three rivers, the Ganga, the Gandak, and the Son. So, this statement is correct. 

Q.16) Always remember this, Domestication of animals started in the Mesolithic period only. This is a very common fact. 

Please get your facts right. You have got misinformations. 

I have rechecked for the above facts from three soruces- R. S. Sharma,  Old Ncert(Makhan Lal)  and S. K. Pandey. 

All of them have unanimously metioned Neolithic period as domestication of animals. And please look for the time scales too.

Same is true for the other questions too.

only contentious fact  is the place  of confluence of Sone and Ganga. You may simply check it on google earth. Though Son River used flow south of Patna in the past but now river Punpun flows there in it's minor paleo-channels. 

I am quoting the NEW NCERT here,

Domestication was a gradual process that took place in many parts of the world.It began about 12,000 years ago.Virtually all the plant and animal products that we use as food today is a result of domestication. Some of the earliest plants to be domesticated were wheat and barley. The earliest domesticated animals include sheep and goats. The period when we find environmental changes, beginning about 12,000 years ago till about 10,000 years ago is called the Mesolithic (middle stone). 

http://ncert.nic.in/textbook/pdf/fess102.pdf



3.1k views

mhs11said

test 44 Q7

4. Baburnama was written in the Persian language.

The above statement is given as incorrect. But Babur wrote 'Tuzuk-e Babari'( in Chagtai Turkish) and Abul Fazl translated this into persian under the title 'Babarnama'. The statement should be right?

Yes, your explanation is correct. I hope they edit this soon. 

2.9k views

Sfg test 44

question number 19 and 49

1) question number 19 - Abul fazl was not poet but he was a court writer
2) question number 49-shershah introduce RUPAIYA as a silver coin and not DAM
I request you to take appropriate actions regarding these questions.
Thank you.

For Q.19)  Abul Fazl was the Wazir as well as Court Historian during the time of Akbar. He was also a poet though a distinguished one, like his brother Faizi who was the court poet of Akbar. His poetic skill can be seen in Akbarnama which consists of various couplets as well as poems. Since the question is asking for Persian poets during the Mughal time and not the court poets of the Mughal time the answer shall be D. 

Q.49) Yes you are correct.

2.9k views

SFG BATCH 2 TEST 45

Q 4:Statement 3 must be wrong. Answer should be"B"

3. Rama Raya founded the Aravidu dynasty.



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Q 46:

Consider the following statements regarding Mahmud of Ghazni:

1. He plundered the Somnath Temple in his first expedition to India.


Statement 1 must be wrong also, it is his last expedition to India. Answer should be"D"

It was his 16th expedition in which he plundered Somnath Temple (not the last). The last was against the jats.

2.9k views

Test 45 Question 46
Mahmud of Ghazni plundered Somnath temple in his first expedition to India. 
Please re-verify the correctness of this statement.

It was his 16th expedition. 

2.9k views

The first two statements are quite obvious. I guess they are from the ''About us'' section of the organizations. As far as the third statement is concerned, it is a topic in news since the last few months. I found a link of a recent article 

https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/companies/mca-panels-scope-on-cross-border-insolvency-gets-bigger/article31015843.ece


3.1k views

@Disciple 

SFG TEST 50 Q 49

Statement 3 (NCDRC)must be wrong.

3. It has the jurisdiction to entertain complaints where the value of the goods or services paid as consideration exceeds rupees ten crore.

It exceeds One Crore. Answer must be"A".



That was under the previous act. THE CONSUMER PROTECTION ACT, 2019 provides for the National Commission to entertain complaints exceeding ten crores. Please refer to the Act, it is important from the Current Affairs point of view. 

3.1k views

ssver2said

"Parliament may by law provide for the abolition of the Legislative Council of a Stateeven withoutthe consent of the State Legislative Assembly." 

How is this correct? 

Article 169: Parliament may by law provide for the abolition...,IF Legislative Assembly passes a resolution to that effect ...


Hi,

This was clarified in the class by Sir. According to Article 169, Parliament may by law provide for the abolition of the Legislative Council of a State having such a Council or for the creation of such a Council in a State having no such Council, if the Legislative Assembly of the State passes a resolution to that effect by a majority of the total membership of the Assembly and by a majority of not less than two-thirds of the members of the Assembly present and voting.

Parliament cannot do this on its own. 

3.5k views

Sheepsaid

Test 4, Question 2, SFG

The first statement says parliament can limit the operations of national emergency by 42nd amendment. But the amendment states that President can limit the operations of the national emergency to a specified part of India. Hence statement a) should be wrong.

Yes, It must be a typing error. The answer will be 'D' I think. They will correct it in some time. It is the President only who declares it.

4.8k views
Write your comment…