Subscribe to ForumIAS

[official][prelims 2023] How was prelims result? In or out?

Vote people, Vote!

And share!

DM,VERMA_KIRANDEVI_LALBAHADURand12 otherslike this
295.3k views

747 comments

Is bar is the cut off going below 80 ? Anxiety peak me he. Not able to do anything. Any solid leads on the cut off?
plmokn25688524,TomiokaGiyu
3.2k views
@Sangaideer until your roll no or name is not the list just beilive you cleared it, vahi mindset se chal raha hu.


3.1k views
What are the authentic sources for constitutional amendment question (1st vs 42nd amendment) and the due process of law?
3.2k views
What are the authentic sources for constitutional amendment question (1st vs 42nd amendment) and the due process of law?


THE CONSTITUTION (FIRST AMENDMENT) ACT, 1951

Statement of Objects and Reasons appended to the Constitution (First Amendment) Bill, 1951 which was enacted as the Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951

STATEMENT OF OBJECTS AND REASONS

During the last fifteen months of the working of the Constitution, certain difficulties have been brought to light by judicial decisions and pronouncements specially in regard to the chapter on fundamental rights. The citizen's right to freedom of speech and expression guaranteed by article 19(1)(a) has been held by some courts to be so comprehensive as not to render a person culpable even if he advocates murder and other crimes of violence. In other countries with written constitutions, freedom of speech and of the press is not regarded as debarring the State from punishing or preventing abuse of this freedom. The citizen's right to practise any profession or to carry on any occupation, trade or business conferred by article 19(1)(g) is subject to reasonable restrictions which the laws of the State may impose "in the interests of general public". While the words cited are comprehensive enough to cover any scheme of nationalisation which the State may undertake, it is desirable to place the matter beyond doubt by a clarificatory addition to article 19(6). Another article in regard to which unanticipated difficulties have arisen is article 31. The validity of agrarian reform measures passed by the State Legislatures in the last three years has, in spite of the provisions of clauses (4) and (6) of article 31, formed the subject-matter of dilatory litigation, as a result of which the implementation of these important measures, affecting large numbers of people, has been held up.

https://www.india.gov.in/my-government/constitution-india/amendments/constitution-india-first-amendment-act-1951



TomiokaGiyu,
3.2k views
@AureliusM Vision and Forum can be relied upon so can't say bhai
all we can do is pray 


3.1k views

What about the question on due process?

Marked A

Counting it wrong as per insights

but still believe it should be a

3.1k views
Deleted
Bhai Forum and Vision can be relied upon. lets wish result goes in our way
3k views

Please give me your final answers for these questions


1. Prisons

2. Gandak and Kanwar

3. Village level councils

4. Rule of Law

Legible Neutrino,
2.8k views
@AureliusM insights has given two quant questions wrong for sure(ie 5 persons and tasks answer is 24 and 1186 remainder answer is 9)incase you attempted them you probably will have +6.xx marks to your score


2.8k views

Please give me your final answers for these questions


1. Prisons

2. Gandak and Kanwar

3. Village level councils

4. Rule of Law

Gandak should be B for sure, rest I am not sure;

Prison, have marked A; Village level marked A; Rule of law - C

2.7k views
@DrKingSchultz100 Bhai, it should be A. Also, as per classnotes of Vajiram, SC in Maneka Gandhi case held that, it will apply the Principle of Natural Justice and if law is arbitrary and oppressive, it will declare the law as invalid. It said that Article 21 inherently includes the principle of natural justice and thus it succeeded in reading due process of law under Article 21.


2.6k views
@DrKingSchultz100 Bhai, it should be A. Also, as per classnotes of Vajiram, SC in Maneka Gandhi case held that, it will apply the Principle of Natural Justice and if law is arbitrary and oppressive, it will declare the law as invalid. It said that Article 21 inherently includes the principle of natural justice and thus it succeeded in reading due process of law under Article 21.


ANSWERED it on the same logic of MENAKA GANDHI

Fair applications sound too limiting

2.7k views
@Sangaideer don't know what the final answers would be

but in the exam, I've done:

Prisons: statement 2 incorrect (expressly- I don't think)
Gandhak: Only 1 kiya hai (would be unfair if this option is marked wrong, they at the least should then go for multiple answers)

Village (again only 1 kiya hai.......maybe wrong......but socha ki PESA se village & not cluster should be lowest)

Due process: fair application kiya hai (Natural justice is just too wide a concept, imo.....it means a lot of other things which due process doesn't.......yes due process takes some features from natural justice but then fair application of law also does so from natural justice.......just interchange due process with fair application in the question......then also some would say the meaning of fair application is natural justice)

End me Shayad 4on apne hi galat ho.......will take 10.68 marks hit.............. would be unfair......but then, kya hi kr sktey hain.............apni hi galti hai jo border pe hain...........


plmokn25688524,ThePrinceand1 otherslike this
2.8k views
@Sangaideer prision i marked c..don't know kya hoga..

Kanwar lake..two pairs kiya hai..two pairs answer hoga imo.

Village level skip Kiya

Due process..I marked c.


plmokn25688524,
2.3k views

2022 ki official key nahi aayi na?

I dont know why but i feel upsc ab answer key Dene wala system bhi hata dena chahta hai

2.2k views
Except the kanwar jheel, do you guys find any answer given in vision's key to be wrong?
2.1k views
@Sangaideer squirrel, prison, migration pact imo....but who knows......


2.4k views
+1, I think due process means fair application of law. 
plmokn25688524,
2k views

seesatsaid

@Sangaideer squirrel, prison, migration pact imo....but who knows......


what should be the answer for GCM? A?

2.1k views
Write your comment…