October 2, 2024   Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
Subscribe to ForumIAS
Oct 02, 2024  Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
1
Create
Create
Share GyanWrite an Article and share your knowledge or something you have learned recently.
Ask QuestionStart a discussion, ask a question, or ask for an opinion
Sign in

[official][prelims 2023] How was prelims result? In or out?

Vote people, Vote!

And share!

DM,VERMA_KIRANDEVI_LALBAHADURand12 otherslike this
295.3k views

747 comments

does upsc remove ambiguous questions, did it do it before.
2.7k views

Srinjaysaid

seesatsaid

@Sangaideer squirrel, prison, migration pact imo....but who knows......


what should be the answer for GCM? A?

What's the doubt in GCM? Vision has cited the source and there is no mention of internal displacement so answer is (D). (Btw I myself marked A)

2.7k views
@Sangaideer msme question, in video discussion, they told answer might be B(2nd statement correct)


2.6k views
@Srinjay yes.


just open this official website & read 23 objectives: it clearly mentions local migrations........ don't know what is the issue...


plmokn25688524,TomiokaGiyu
3k views
Well, there is no mention of the term 'internal migration' in the whole list of 23 objectives so it's hard to justify and pass off 'internal migration' as 'local'. 
Averageaspirant,
2.6k views

seesatsaid

@Srinjay yes.


just open this official website & read 23 objectives: it clearly mentions local migrations........ don't know what is the issue...


Did you file representation. Don’t think this would be the answer. Marked A myself.

2.6k views
@Srinjay  It seemed so obvious that didn't file it......the person setting the paper would obviously had to read every page of this pact to make sure that local migration is NOT included.......while this official page of the same pact explicitly talks about it in objectives (the question also specifically talks about the objectives).............A counter question to those who say "D".........where is it written that internal migration is not included?..........


Existential Enigma,
2.8k views
@quasiwin the whole sentence reads objectives @ local, national, international & regional levels...............now pls tell what else does "local" mean here if not internal.................sharab peekr paper set kiya hai is baar......answer key bhi usi sharabi ne bnayi hongi tbhi D krega wo😂.....so..... possible.......


2.8k views
@seesat But it doesn't. Read the 23 objectives--no mention of internal displacement. You need to go by what the question is asking.


2.4k views

i don't remember which option i marked but remember it was wrong as per insights

Anyway, internal migration seems like a push

local prolly just means planning at local level  

understand the zeal to push your answer to be right though 

many I want to be right lol 

but we will never know

2.5k views

Bas yahi bolna chathaa hun ki mai wahi tha jo 2021 ke Pre mei Indus River System wale question par option D satluj bol raha tha...par baaki sab mujhe DM mei nayi nayi cheez bata rahe theay.


Natural justice is a british Concept while Fairness and DPOL is American. Also one thing i have learnt in this Upsc journey is that if you cant find your option directly linked to your question on Google, you cant say that its right.


if you simply google, you will find that Fairness word is associated too many times with Dopl. Show me a link where it is associated with Natural justice.

Yeah jin bhaisahab ney screenshot dala haina MANEKA gandhi wala, usme zara Fairness word bhi check karlein...kitni baar diya hua hai...

reddington,MichaelScarnand4 otherslike this
2.2k views

Ans key ke saath itna issue pehli baar ho raha hai ya har baar hi Aisa hota hai?? 

2.2k views
Yaar upsc ko bolo ki ab kaise bhi result nikal de jaldi se nahi toh mamla garam horaha ab community me 🤣
2.1k views
@plmokn25688524 @Lawstice tumhre law ka experience kya bolta hai? :p


2.1k views

plmokn25688524said

Bas yahi bolna chathaa hun ki mai wahi tha jo 2021 ke Pre mei Indus River System wale question par option D satluj bol raha tha...par baaki sab mujhe DM mei nayi nayi cheez bata rahe theay.


Natural justice is a british Concept while Fairness and DPOL is American. Also one thing i have learnt in this Upsc journey is that if you cant find your option directly linked to your question on Google, you cant say that its right.


if you simply google, you will find that Fairness word is associated too many times with Dopl. Show me a link where it is associated with Natural justice.

Yeah jin bhaisahab ney screenshot dala haina MANEKA gandhi wala, usme zara Fairness word bhi check karlein...kitni baar diya hua hai...

Have ticked Natural Justice 

counting it as wrong as per insights

but

Fairness is fine but it says fair application of law

I asked myself the same q in exam that what if the law is unfair?

wasn't that what the issue was in Menaka Gandhi case?

That the law has to be fair

And what is the vision ans key on this one?

plmokn25688524,
2.2k views

seesatsaid

@Sangaideer don't know what the final answers would be

but in the exam, I've done:

Prisons: statement 2 incorrect (expressly- I don't think)
Gandhak: Only 1 kiya hai (would be unfair if this option is marked wrong, they at the least should then go for multiple answers)

Village (again only 1 kiya hai.......maybe wrong......but socha ki PESA se village & not cluster should be lowest)

Due process: fair application kiya hai (Natural justice is just too wide a concept, imo.....it means a lot of other things which due process doesn't.......yes due process takes some features from natural justice but then fair application of law also does so from natural justice.......just interchange due process with fair application in the question......then also some would say the meaning of fair application is natural justice)

End me Shayad 4on apne hi galat ho.......will take 10.68 marks hit.............. would be unfair......but then, kya hi kr sktey hain.............apni hi galti hai jo border pe hain...........


I marked the same options.

2.4k views
maine apna sab kuch galat man liya hai, 42nd amendment tick kiya  ko galat, 1 correct in GCm galat, Msme all loans  galat, hfc mei all tick kiya usko bhi galat par fairness waley ko galat nahi manunga 😊
Saint_1,Magnetozand2 otherslike this
2k views
UPSC is relying  on Chirkut websites where anyone can write anything.
Magnetoz,
2k views
@TomiokaGiyu me too same to same except gandak one..I went with two pairs here


2k views

DrKingSchultz100said

plmokn25688524said

Bas yahi bolna chathaa hun ki mai wahi tha jo 2021 ke Pre mei Indus River System wale question par option D satluj bol raha tha...par baaki sab mujhe DM mei nayi nayi cheez bata rahe theay.


Natural justice is a british Concept while Fairness and DPOL is American. Also one thing i have learnt in this Upsc journey is that if you cant find your option directly linked to your question on Google, you cant say that its right.


if you simply google, you will find that Fairness word is associated too many times with Dopl. Show me a link where it is associated with Natural justice.

Yeah jin bhaisahab ney screenshot dala haina MANEKA gandhi wala, usme zara Fairness word bhi check karlein...kitni baar diya hua hai...

Have ticked Natural Justice 

counting it as wrong as per insights

but

Fairness is fine but it says fair application of law

I asked myself the same q in exam that what if the law is unfair?

wasn't that what the issue was in Menaka Gandhi case?

That the law has to be fair

And what is the vision ans key on this one?

I used the logic that - Natural justice principles has 2 components - fair trial and no one can be a judge in his own cause. If Due process means Natural justice principles then before Maneka Gandhi judgement, it is implied that these principles were not being followed in India. But we know that's not the case. So it can't be that. This is what I used in exam to arrive at the answer. Ab galat ho jaega to atleast I tried. 

reddington,
1.9k views
Write your comment…