So Mains 2021 has begun. Essay Paper is here
1. https://blog.forumias.com/upsc-ias-mains-2021-essay-question-paper/
2. GS Paper 1 : https://blog.forumias.com/download-upsc-ias-mains-2021-gs-1-question-paper
3. GS Paper 2 : https://blog.forumias.com/download-upsc-ias-mains-2021-gs-2-question-paper
/
How was your paper? How did you approach the paper?
@Duryodhan Bhai bas 3 chij bata do-1.Akbar ne khud se koi badi ladai ladi thi ki ya bas mantri bhejta raha zindagi bhar??2.Mughal rule me koi bhi Ancient India or contemporary Europe type world class university/research institution kyu nahi khule,janta ko backward rakhne ke liye kya?Mera koi view nahi, just curious koi scholar ne is baare me kuch likha kya?3.Bakhtiyar khalji burnt our heritage phir uske name pe station,town,college,ye aaj tak kisi ko nazar kaise nahi aaya?Eulogise kar rahe use kya hum because media celebrate kar rahi another celebrity naming his kid after Taimur lutera?Ya ye sab koi isotopes hai unke not actual persons??
Bhai class 12 new ncert part 2 me bechare leftist intellectuals bhi nahi chhupa pae mughal times me karname ghor poverty ghor inequality. Aj jo experts Inequality Index pe India ko question karte he unhe koi batae mughal times me bernier kehte he there is no middle state in india. mughals ko ye experts criticise to nahi kar payenge lekin kam se kam glorify karna band kre.
British raj ko criticise karke mughalo and delhi sultanate ke kale karnamo ko white wash kia ja raha he. Europe me jo renaissance and enlightenment movement aaya tab to yaha sultanate and mughal the, inhone raaj kia to kya kia hindustan ke liye? science technology develop ki ya bas jaziya wasoolte rahe.
Aaj west developed isliye he kyuki waha science and technology jaldi start hui. India peeche reh gaya thanks to Mughal india kyuki agar tum 200(1526-1726...)saal raaj karoge to accountability tumse hi extract krenge na.
Jajantaram Mamantaram
Bhaktiyar khilji ke baare me padha, he burnt down Nalanda in 1200 ce, obviously reason was to scare the population into submission and destroy the intellectual resistance.
If kisi ne JL mehta padhi hogi to u will know he talks about holocaust during establishment of Islamic rule.
Around the same time Mongol invasions shuru hue the, central Asia me where the tradition was to kill everyone who resisted. Khwarizm empire ko destroy karne ke strategy zabardast thi. They destroyed every city in Persia at that time and killed large population.
Now the point where Bhaktiyar khilji is relevant here is Siege of Baghdad 1259, if u read it you will know that it is end of Islamic golden age, Islamic literature ka hub Baghdad me tha, Mongols burnt down the library which continued for many days( just like Nalanda), this apart from killing of entire Baghdad population,killing of Caliph by trampling horses over him.
This when Mongols wre yet to accept Islamic faith btw.
The point iam trying to make is, RW Wale usually try to draw conclusions based on some historical facts for which they try and draw a historical responsibility of present day Muslim population in the subcontinent.
We all draw conclusions according to what suits our logic, above mentioned sari batein facts hai
To agar:
1. Ye kaha jaye ki battle tactics like killing entire towns and cities were common in that time, can it be said to be correct? Is this perspective modern one or medieval one?
2. Do Persian and central Asian population still abhor their Mongol history?
Main kisi ki side nahi le raha hu, bas ye bata raha hu history ko apne tarike se interpret karke samjhane Wale bohot authors milenge, lekin as said ki apne ko bhi ye dekhna hai ki which one seems more credible.
Teacher chahe jo bhi bataye, lekin marks lane ke liye kya likhna hai ye bhi hume hi sochna padega.
So in baghdad is there any prominent place named after Genghis khan like bakhitiyarpur station in Bihar?
Pata lagega to bata dunga Bhai.. waise ye sure hai ki india ne Iraq me jo railway line banayi thi 70s me wo saari USA ne uda di thi.
Vijaynagar bhi isi period main tha yaar , unhone bhi kuch nahin kiya yaar ; Similarly odisha ke rulers bhi the ; unhone bhi nahin kiya !!!
Rahi baat inke aane se pehle bhi koi aisi koi science and tech ka zabardast innovation nahin chal rha tha ,purane texts par commentary kar rhe the
Bhaktiyar khilji ke baare me padha, he burnt down Nalanda in 1200 ce, obviously reason was to scare the population into submission and destroy the intellectual resistance.
If kisi ne JL mehta padhi hogi to u will know he talks about holocaust during establishment of Islamic rule.
Around the same time Mongol invasions shuru hue the, central Asia me where the tradition was to kill everyone who resisted. Khwarizm empire ko destroy karne ke strategy zabardast thi. They destroyed every city in Persia at that time and killed large population.
Now the point where Bhaktiyar khilji is relevant here is Siege of Baghdad 1259, if u read it you will know that it is end of Islamic golden age, Islamic literature ka hub Baghdad me tha, Mongols burnt down the library which continued for many days( just like Nalanda), this apart from killing of entire Baghdad population,killing of Caliph by trampling horses over him.
This when Mongols wre yet to accept Islamic faith btw.
The point iam trying to make is, RW Wale usually try to draw conclusions based on some historical facts for which they try and draw a historical responsibility of present day Muslim population in the subcontinent.
We all draw conclusions according to what suits our logic, above mentioned sari batein facts hai
To agar:
1. Ye kaha jaye ki battle tactics like killing entire towns and cities were common in that time, can it be said to be correct? Is this perspective modern one or medieval one?
2. Do Persian and central Asian population still abhor their Mongol history?
Main kisi ki side nahi le raha hu, bas ye bata raha hu history ko apne tarike se interpret karke samjhane Wale bohot authors milenge, lekin as said ki apne ko bhi ye dekhna hai ki which one seems more credible.
Teacher chahe jo bhi bataye, lekin marks lane ke liye kya likhna hai ye bhi hume hi sochna padega.
So in baghdad is there any prominent place named after Genghis khan like bakhitiyarpur station in Bihar?
Pata lagega to bata dunga Bhai.. waise ye sure hai ki india ne Iraq me jo railway line banayi thi 70s me wo saari USA ne uda di thi.
Like bola hai bhai. Nadi, nala, jila, gaon, kasba kuch bhi. Jaroori thode hai ki railway station hi uske naam pe ho.
@Duryodhan He is rejecting the "only" and not the argument itself.
Dekho ye Islamic invasions ke brutality ko baat kare to isko hide karne ka ye reason tha ki major division hua tha country ka 47 me, Papering over the facts was to hide wounds and prevent passions from regeneration.
This idea was accepted by people of that time and as we see we never had a government which supported this narrative. Anyways LW did the service to prevent the facts from coming out and it went out the way it did.
Now that we have a thriving eco system of other views, it will take time to build out a structure to help thrive "intelligentsia" but it will happen eventually, because this is what people are supporting too. Papering over the historical fact has been rejected comprehensively.
@Duryodhan He is rejecting the "only" and not the argument itself.
1st para pdhna. Usne btaya h Hinduism ko kitna 'threat'tha nd Islam kitna 'egalitarian' tha. Ma'am ka argument tha ki Islam aaya nd yha bhakti movement start ho gya Islam ko dekhke.
Ye view nhi maana jaata .
Infact ,sufi movement ko zyada impact kia tha nathpanthiyo ne bw 8-11 th century.
Vijaynagar bhi isi period main tha yaar , unhone bhi kuch nahin kiya yaar ; Similarly odisha ke rulers bhi the ; unhone bhi nahin kiya !!!
Rahi baat inke aane se pehle bhi koi aisi koi science and tech ka zabardast innovation nahin chal rha tha ,purane texts par commentary kar rhe the
you mean inke pehle matlab ancient india me science and tech ka koi zabardast innovation nahi chal raha tha.
Ese kaise history optional me score karoge bro
astronomy, medicine, mathematics me trigonometry, zero, algebra, geometry, language me ashtadhyai by panini, sushruta,charaka, bhaskaracharya,aryabhatta etc etc, mughalo ke defence me ancient Indian progress ko mat ignore kro bhai.
Vijayanagar ne bhi kuch nahi kia, odisha ne bhi theek he lekin ye chhote kingdom the delhi sultanate and mughal were central power in india. Mughalo ne kai bar inhe bhi invade kia akbar ne khandesh for example. Aur agar tum inse compare karte ho, to ek bat batao ncert me inhe proportionate coverage kyu nahi milta.
Tumne odisha ke rulers ki baat kahi, ncert me kitni jagah mention he odisha rulers ka? Unhone bhi to jagannath,lingaraj temple sun temple dia.
me bas itna hi kahunga, mughals ko achche ke liye glorify karte ho to unke Great Failures ke lie responsible bhi thehrao. Ankhe band karke mughalo ki bhakti theek nahi.
Jajantaram Mamantaram
@zombieland but zombies abhi bhi dead hainšRudra pe kuch tippani kijiye shriman savinay nivedan hai.
Army of dead dekha? Zombies bhi ab intelligent ho gye hain. Strategy, romance aur revenge teeno krte hainš¤£š¤£š¤£
Horror h kya? Kaisi h
Horror layak kuch zyada toh nahi hai isme. Zombie based movie hai jisme violence hai, action hai, gore hai, one time entertaining watch zaroor hai.
Agar Badia kuch khoon kharaaba vala zombie based dekhna hai toh I would recommend āAll of us are deadā jo ki Netflix par hai. 12 episodes ki series hai. Isse Badia zombies ke upar kuch nahi dekha abhi tak.








