Subscribe to ForumIAS

Mains 2022 - All Papers PDF + R**** Rona + Paper Discussion

Guys, Essay Paper is over. How was it?

DM,Oshoand33 otherslike this
936.7k views

2.3k comments

@MC Cullum Haha Sahi baat....still this score indicates that examiner must have been really pissed off !!


GaryVee,MC Cullum
3.6k views
@nalin_pandey78066 Kuch to baat rahi hogi 
I don't think ki just different interpretation ki baat hai because 58 means ki both essays are compromised. 


2.8k views

Why do people say writing is not important 

and that only content matters. If I get a copy with poor handwriting, why will I give it marks 

Surgicalstrike,Notorias
2.9k views
@nalin_pandey78066 Kuch to baat rahi hogi 
I don't think ki just different interpretation ki baat hai because 58 means ki both essays are compromised. 


58/250.... I am even not able to think ki.. kya raha hoga reason.. admi ek me galti karega , but dono milake 58...


He got more than 100 in previous attempts. Mock me kitna milta tha? Koi idea.

2.8k views

Mental health has been a serious issue among aspirants and is much less talked about than it actually should be. I felt like sharing a video that may help us deal with the same & form a clear eyed realistic perspective towards this exam (especially the new entrants) 


P. S - Today is World Mental Health Day (I am not as random as UPSC prelims :P) 


Aspirant123,brownianMotionand1 otherslike this
2.9k views
Mujhe ab tak lagta tha ki 90 100 essay me har kisi ka aajata..
2.8k views

Some years back I saw a video on yt

The topper said that in essay he wrote in a format of conversation between people and got really less marks 


2.7k views
@MC Cullum I have seen some disastrous essays. Kya interpretation hai wo samajh hi nahi aa Raha poora essay padhne ke baad and still they got 90+

I really dont know ki examiner ne kya soch liya

I heard few cases jahan candidate ne essay ka topic hi nahi mention kiya which confused examiner.

Apart from that its hard to digest 58

MC Cullum,
2.5k views
@Capedcrusader1 Yes i also came across that. Might be said by Ira singhal. 

One reason may be, he joined test series and written all prepared data and ideas to fit passage demand without coherence and continuity.

On twitter, one ex- examiner said, people are so obsess with quotes and Gandhi examples, historical examples and schemes. They unnecessarily try to fit them in essay and make no sense..


But still 58.. bahut kam diya 


GaryVee,MC Cullumand1 otherslike this
2.8k views
@Capedcrusader1 Yes i also came across that. Might be said by Ira singhal. 

One reason may be, he joined test series and written all prepared data and ideas to fit passage demand without coherence and continuity.

On twitter, one ex- examiner said, people are so obsess with quotes and Gandhi examples, historical examples and schemes. They unnecessarily try to fit them in essay and make no sense..


But still 58.. bahut kam diya 


Ira singhal nai 

he’s sir. 58 is way too less. Ek essay likhna bhul gaye honge 

captainhaddock,
2.7k views


MC Cullum,nebula
2.5k views
in 2021 i wrote my first essay on " The process of self-discovery has now been technologically outsourced." in sec A. The essay was in line with the explanations that floated in market by coaching institutes. 
My second essay was about "
 Hand that rocks the cradle rules the world." where I wrote 10 pages in which I dedicated 1.5 page just to explain my interpretation of the essay. And I didn't even considered the dimension of "role of a mother" in my entire essay( at that time I was wondering that, its not just the role of a mother to rock the cradle, and I might look like a person who is patriarchal ....weird but such thoughts do come when essay papers have all the topics that are just way too unconventional.)
I discussed my second essay with my senior after mains. He said that if there is a quote which is said for a specific purpose and you try to drift away from it, no matter what you write and how brilliantly you try to explain your interpretation, you will be heavily penalised.
My essay score in 2021 was 58
116 in 2019, 120 in 2020
Given that , 2021 was the first time I joined a test series for essay writing, wrote more than 20 essays beforehand, worked on my content, had a group of friends to discuss and improvise my structure...in short I really work hard on my essay in 2021..but still it was 58
So all I can say is that, until and unless you are extremely lucky, and examiner is a person with an open mind, expect poor marks for an essay that's drifts apart from actual interpretation of the quote known to the examiner.
Above that, I much I know, before checking our booklets, examiners are briefed about every topic, marking scheme etc. etc...so they already have a structure in mind and evaluate our essays based on that. SOme might take the pain to understand your view point, but that's rare...so all the best.
And about every section being checked by a different examiner, I never paid attention to the last page in my previous attempt but  a friend of mine said that after every question number, there is a column for marks and signature of the examiner, which proves that different examiners check our copies. Though this time I checked the same but there was no separate column for signature...but I assume it is being checked by different people.

Been in such situation in history optional paper2. In 2020 got 128 marks which was decent score.

But in 2021 attempt got some 52/58 marks.(paper went well with good histiography)Still can't  figure out what happened wrong. As an aspirant I  can only treat as an aberration and continue  hard work.

GaryVee,MC Cullumand1 otherslike this
3.3k views
@Kenshein Thats good spirit but so much variation confuses us.


2.5k views
@iceblock I went for forest are best case study....through all the aspects, economically ,culturally, ecologically and other aspects, I just showed that forest...the ecosystem works better in every aspect and how we can learn from the forest. Though, forest may look chaotic and disorderly, but jungle is not jungle raj, if we delve deeper..............


abhi toh line much aur hi ban gaya but issi lines par likha tha... 


iceblock,
2.4k views
one topper was saying in an interview that in gs1 he wrote 3 answers wrongly under 3 different questions so he had to strike it off..he felt like crying and all ... then in marksheet he got actually one of the highest in gs 1...so expect the unexpected...neither 58 can be explained nor sometimes marks shooting up beyond expectations...very unpredictable
GaryVee,Mahi2306and1 otherslike this
2.4k views

🤣🤣


EiChan,GaryVeeand6 otherslike this
2.3k views
@Kenshein  🙁

Even I feel disturbed to hear they could give such low marks in History Optional paper 2 which is not a subjective paper like essay ,


Hopefully it was not a question choice combination related error, one of the online peers made that mistake


hopefully everything turns out well this time 🤞

2.3k views
@nalin_pandey78066 essay me double digit score bhi aate hai kya?


2.3k views
@MC Cullum bhai ek maza batata hu.. but Dil se bahut bura laga..

Mera essays 2.5 hrs me hi khatam ho gaye. Mere right side me baccha tha... Usne 4 essays likhe the.. two 200- 250 words k rough sheet me.😂

1 full essay in section one.. jab 3rd hour ka Bell Baja, examiner lene laga paper.. he even not completed his 2nd essay...


Mai dekha kam se kam hyd center pe nahi tobhi  30 40 percent baccho ne 2nd essay nahi kiye complete or abrupt conclude kiya hai...


Par 200 250 words ka idea chart kon banata hai btw


Aspirant123,
2.6k views
@Kenshein in 2019 I just read spectrum for modern history(was just out from the college and had no time for other books)
my score was 118. Then I thought that next time with touch of historiography and bit of answer writing I might score well. Above that in 2020 questions from modern were straight forward..but final score was 82.



GaryVee,Street_lamp
2.2k views
Write your comment…