July 14, 2024   Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
Subscribe to ForumIAS
Jul 14, 2024  Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
1
Create
Create
Share GyanWrite an Article and share your knowledge or something you have learned recently.
Ask QuestionStart a discussion, ask a question, or ask for an opinion
Sign in

[Results] Prelims 2020 Over - Gearing for 2021

Scoring 104.

Keeping basic structure, representation of people's act, non financial debt, rakhmabai and kisan credit card as negative. Did not attempt desh waala question.

Bhai log what are my chances in Gen category?

4.3k views

shubham4_m7770said

Last year idhar bht mathapachhi kiya tha digital signature, clouds, LS Rules, PDT Achary, ramsar, etc etc..Iss baar toh man bhi nhi kr rha..bcoz upsc directy verdict deta hai answer key me..no if and buts...

I am scoring 103.33 from forum and ias baba, 105.92 from vision,drishti and shankar...hopeful of writing my first mains this time..

Last yr scored 96 in prelims..missed by 2 marks..lets hope for the best this time..

iss baar ka prelims toh luck factor pe bht jyada aa gya hai..2-3 tukke jyada/kam lage aur u r in/out..

@gauravbrly409 bhai kya haal hai..i hope u remember me..digital signature pe upsc sala 3 only hi diya ans:)..usi ki wajah se bahar ho gya sala mai last time..

Bro, I am also getting 104.5 . For Gen is that sufficient? Asking because I live in this backward state with no one preparing for upsc around me. So don't have a perspective. Will be happy if you could give some insights

4k views

Negansaid

gauravbrly409said

Negansaid

@PercivalYes, statement 1 is definitely right because
1) Thequestion of age i.e 25 Years is only applicable for membership of the State legislatureandnot for being a Minister in a state(if he is appointed as minister without being member of state legislature)
2) Till the time a person is duly elected to state legislature as its Member,he can continue as Minister at leastfor6 months.
The question of his qualification/ disqualification by virtue of his age(<25 years) will only arise when he will fill election/ nomination papers for the membership of state legislature


The article 85 , I think it nowhere states as -  So, If you simple rely on that  -  Statement is ditto copied and true.
Also, the qualifications of minsiters are nowhere stated. So, A 18 year old person can be minister for 6 months. But, he cant be member of LA .. as he does not fulfills 25 year age criteria.. he has to give up ministership than. 
Deduction >>An 18 year person with voting rights can be a minister for 6 months only because any person can be a minister for 6 months without being member of house. The 25 year age criterian comes only in picture when you want to be member of house .. so .. you 18 year old can happy go to be a minister but beyond that -  you have to member of house which you cant be .. so cant continue beyond 6 months in any case.


But, If read it along with RPA and all , Then.. It makes all wrong.



That is why, in the question there is nowhere, any mention of RPA-1951. It only mentions the Constitution.


To add, RPA both 1950 and 1951, do not mention qualification of minister. If we go by constitution alone, no mention either. 25 years age minimum is only through ls route, or it is a convention. One can never find a law which says 25 is minimum age.

3.6k views

Negansaid

Great_Indian_Custardsaid

shubham4_m7770said

Last year idhar bht mathapachhi kiya tha digital signature, clouds, LS Rules, PDT Achary, ramsar, etc etc..Iss baar toh man bhi nhi kr rha..bcoz upsc directy verdict deta hai answer key me..no if and buts...

I am scoring 103.33 from forum and ias baba, 105.92 from vision,drishti and shankar...hopeful of writing my first mains this time..

Last yr scored 96 in prelims..missed by 2 marks..lets hope for the best this time..

iss baar ka prelims toh luck factor pe bht jyada aa gya hai..2-3 tukke jyada/kam lage aur u r in/out..

@gauravbrly409 bhai kya haal hai..i hope u remember me..digital signature pe upsc sala 3 only hi diya ans:)..usi ki wajah se bahar ho gya sala mai last time..

Bro, I am also getting 104.5 . For Gen is that sufficient? Asking because I live in this backward state with no one preparing for upsc around me. So don't have a perspective. Will be happy if you could give some insights

Start preparing for mains.
Cutoff will be 91-95 this year.
UPSC has shown mirror to the ORN and MN factories of coaching wala's.


Thanks a lot brother.

3.5k views
@shubham4_m7770 thanks brother. Means a lot


3.5k views

Rookiesaid

@kartikeybhatt171778 yes, the sunderban website says 

Recently the core areas have been notified as the Critical Tiger Habitat having an inviolate area of 1699.62 sq. km.

While for nagarjun,
The core area of the tiger reserve is around 1,200 sq.km.
Bhai, aise hi naye naye answer palto, mains prep ki himmat milegi.


http://wiienvis.nic.in/Database/trd_8222.aspx


NSTR core area is 2500 sqkm

3.8k views

GreenArrowsaid

@shubham4_m7770 Wikipedia says different.
But I just have a question for you.
if core area itself is 3721 what is total area?

:)

Here please help yourself


http://wiienvis.nic.in/Database/trd_8222.aspx

3.7k views

Buddhijeevi Parsadsaid

Great_Indian_Custardsaid

Scoring 104.

Keeping basic structure, representation of people's act, non financial debt, rakhmabai and kisan credit card as negative. Did not attempt desh waala question.

Bhai log what are my chances in Gen category?

No chance this year. Hard luck 

Next year score atleast 125.

Bhai last attempt de raha hoon. Buddha ho gaya is exam main

3.6k views
@gauravbrly409 yaar this is what is troubling me too. I didn't give 2019 paper but solved it later at home. Got 120 plus. Now this year getting 104.5 . Not sure will I pass because there are people who are scoring 100 plus. I don't know if they are telling their minimum score or not. But few friends are getting 100 plus and 110 plus. Good for them but I hope this is not the general case.
5.4k views
@Tenacious meri jaan, RPA doesn't mention ministerial qualifications at all!


6.1k views

Out.

Was getting 104.5 minimum. Kept all controversial questions negative.

Checked CSAT just to make sure. Using Vision IAS key for CSAT I am getting 75.


Can anyone help me decide what is happening? Is the cutoff more than 105?


6k views
@Gaurav Yaar I have no idea what to do say. 


7.3k views

Okay guys I am on a rant here.

Sorry . I am OUT But how?

I basically checked again.

I am getting 104.5 using Vision in GS1

And getting 75 using Vision in GS2.

Ye kya ho raha hai?


Is the cutoff 110?

7.7k views
@Palakkhinvasaea All controversial questions as negative. I cannot, just cannot get even 0.5 marks kesser than what I have written.
104.5 is the cleanest possible score 


7.6k views
@Thor_vs_Hulk Bro, absolutely not. 104.5 is what is minimum I will get. No bubbling error, no roll number error nothing. I am scoring 104.5(after all controversial questions as negative) and 75(asper vision)


7.6k views
@kartikeybhatt171778 My hunch is the same.cutoff is way past 98. It is definitely more than 104.5. may be it is 106 or 107 so ething. I am so pkwsed because last year my score was 128.


7.6k views
@GanduBandhu bhai fir to Aisa hua hai ki vision ki csat key galat hai.


7.4k views
@Sailor This is what people do not get. Even in my case controversial questions are all negative. Getting 104.5 min and yet not pass


7.4k views
Write your comment…