Subscribe to ForumIAS

Official: SFG / RLG All Tests Discussions in one place

Hello All,

The Group usage here is a little cumbersome, so I am creating this thread to make sure that all questions with doubts stay in one place. Can someone push all the doubts and queries here? I will make this an announcement?


-Faceless, Anonymous "root"

jack_Sparrow,curious_kidand56 otherslike this
529.2k views

1.4k comments

@Karmayogi thanks !


3.9k views
@Karam Finance Commision send its recommendations to the President and not to State Govt.  


musa,
3.5k views

@Thinker @root 

1) Kindly look into Test 10 , Ques 17 - statement 2 says Project Sashakt aims to resolve NPAs via "market-led" approach, it should rather be "bank led" (pls refer the screenshot) and hence the correct answer should option C - 1 and 3 are correct ( Answer key says option D-  1,2,3 correct) 



2) Also, Ques 19 statement 1 says Balsam are native to "Eastern Himalayas" which i think is a wrong statement ( refer the screenshots). So the answer should be option C - Both statements are not correct (as per answer key  option B - only 2nd statement is incorrect)


P.S

a) Since, as per the clarification MPLAD is a Central Sector Scheme, no given option is applicable, therefore the question should be cancelled.

b) If my argument regarding the above 2 question is correct (ques 17 &19) ,i request the answer keys should be revised and also the ranklist accordingly. 

3.9k views

Aks07said

@Thinker @root 

1) Kindly look into Test 10 , Ques 17 - statement 2 says Project Sashakt aims to resolve NPAs via "market-led" approach, it should rather be "bank led" (pls refer the screenshot) and hence the correct answer should option C - 1 and 3 are correct ( Answer key says option D-  1,2,3 correct) 



2) Also, Ques 19 statement 1 says Balsam are native to "Eastern Himalayas" which i think is a wrong statement ( refer the screenshots). So the answer should be option C - Both statements are not correct (as per answer key  option B - only 2nd statement is incorrect)


P.S

a) Since, as per the clarification MPLAD is a Central Sector Scheme, no given option is applicable, therefore the question should be cancelled.

b) If my argument regarding the above 2 question is correct (ques 17 &19) ,i request the answer keys should be revised and also the ranklist accordingly. 

Q17) Project Sashakt aims to resolve the problems of NPA via a market-led approach. You can find different info in different papers. But it is common logic that both creditors and debtors are involved in resolving the NPA problem and not only banks. For eg. bank-led approach for inter-creditor agreement & ARC (a private entity) for assets worth more than 500. Hence the option stands true. Even the market-led approach is being suggested by Sunil Mehta Committee on whose recommendation the Project Sashakt was envisaged.

Q 19) Balsam are endemic to the Himalayas and native of both eastern and western Himalayas. I am attaching a link that specifically states that new varieties of Balsam are found across the eastern Himalayas (https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/other-states/eastern-himalayas-a-treasure-trove-of-balsams-yields-20-new-species/article27951138.ece). Had we asked BALSAM ARE NATIVE TOONLYEASTERN HIMALAYAS then the option would have been wrong. But since Balsam are found across the Himalayas, they are native to both east and west Himalayas.

Q38) Detailed explanation in this regard has already put in CLARIFICATION which we released yesterday. 


4k views

Karamsaid

Test 11 - Q28.

How is Option 3 incorrect?

It says "The Finance Commission recommends the state government to improve the finances of the Panchayat"

For example, it can suggest the state govt to empower local govt to impose advertisement tax and assign productive local assets to Panchayats.

For Q28) FC recommends to President and not to state govt. 

4k views

The appointment, posting and promotion of district judges in a state are made by the governor of the state in

consultation with the high court.


Who is responsible for the transfer of the district Judge ?

2.9k views

Test 9  Qn 34

According to this link: https://main.sci.gov.in/jurisdiction

The Supreme Court has also a very wide appellate jurisdiction over all Courts and Tribunals in India in as much as it may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any Court or Tribunal in the territory of India.

Confirmed by this article:

https
://www.deccanherald.com/amp/content/465647/apex-court-says-army-tribunal.html

But, according to Laxmikanth:



3.9k views

This is with respect to Q.15

'Planning' in India is associated with Union ministry of rural and union ministry of urban development. 
MoUD is involved in 'Smart City' project which involves City Planning
Similar argument goes for MoRD it is also involved in Rural planning.
Also, transportation planning, environmental planning, rural development etc are all in their mandate.
Preparation of District Development Plan is executed by MoRD as well as MoHUA

3.5k views

Explanation for answers of test 11

Q.9 why first statement is incorrect?

Q.15 How planning is possible without knowing the experience of ministries with undergoing schemes?

Q.30 Explain Art. 243E(4)


3.4k views

sfg test 9

sir

why the answer of question no.21 is revised....actually earlier one was correct.?

3.7k views

key error

Q30 Sfg test 11ans for it has to be Bnot D
4k views

Q38 test 10 MPLADS

Drafting of point 1 is very incorrect. Hadn't mentioned word "Central/Union" before government.


If authority find drafting forcentral sector scheme= Centrally sponsored scheme fully funded by government.(this is the drafting as per Q paper) In any authentic source then kindly share it.


Government which government, Central gov, State gov?


Drafting is incorrect as per my knowledge.


If I am wrong kindly make me understand please.


Thank you.

4.5k views

Q 26 word "vulnerable"

Kindly, re evaluate answer Q or delete Q at all. It is for weaker section not vulnerable. And if you want to keep answer as it is kindly show  format of the act with word VULNERABLE from any official publication.


It's not about to do rebel but any worng information or incomplete information can alter students thought process and consequently he or she may create mistake in CSE PT or other examination taken by government.

4.5k views

SWAYATT

You can not make sentence given in Q21(SFG test 9) wrong as such you hadn't asked full form.

Sharing one snapshot from PIB.

Abhi170,
4.5k views

Dear forum SFG RLG MONITORING CUM ADVISERY AUTHORITY, Kindly, respond to students queries w r to questions regarding SWAYYAT-MSME and VULNERABLE-LSA ACT 1987. So that they will be prevented from doing mistake in further examination. Thank you.


4.5k views

DrSsaid

Dear forum SFG RLG MONITORING CUM ADVISERY AUTHORITY, Kindly, respond to students queries w r to questions regarding SWAYYAT-MSME and VULNERABLE-LSA ACT 1987. So that they will be prevented from doing mistake in further examination. Thank you.


Please check out the clarification we provided 2 days earlier on SFG Channel to clarify any doubts.

4.1k views

key error

Q30 Sfg test 11ans for it has to be Bnot D

It was a typing mistake and the revised answer key had already changed that.

4k views

sfg test 9

sir

why the answer of question no.21 is revised....actually earlier one was correct.?

Please follow the thread for in detail explanation.

4k views

Explanation for answers of test 11

Q.9 why first statement is incorrect?

Q.15 How planning is possible without knowing the experience of ministries with undergoing schemes?

Q.30 Explain Art. 243E(4)


Q9) The President of India may appoint a Commission to investigate the conditions of socially and educationally (and not economically)backward classes.

Q15) UPSC previous year question and answer is as per the official answer key. The Planning Commission has an advisory power only and are not involved in the planning process. A simple elimination would give you the answer.

Q30) The provision of Art 243E(4) is explained in simple format in statement 2 of this question.

4k views

Test 9  Qn 34

According to this link: https://main.sci.gov.in/jurisdiction

The Supreme Court has also a very wide appellate jurisdiction over all Courts and Tribunals in India in as much as it may, in its discretion, grant special leave to appeal under Article 136 of the Constitution from any judgment, decree, determination, sentence or order in any cause or matter passed or made by any Court or Tribunal in the territory of India.

Confirmed by this article:

https
://www.deccanherald.com/amp/content/465647/apex-court-says-army-tribunal.html

But, according to Laxmikanth:



Please follow the thread.

4k views
Write your comment…