Subscribe to ForumIAS

Official: SFG / RLG All Tests Discussions in one place

Hello All,

The Group usage here is a little cumbersome, so I am creating this thread to make sure that all questions with doubts stay in one place. Can someone push all the doubts and queries here? I will make this an announcement?


-Faceless, Anonymous "root"

jack_Sparrow,curious_kidand56 otherslike this
507.9k views

1.4k comments

@Thinker can u relook in to the quest 27 of test 2 key,division of powers is a feature of Federal system not Presidential System.


ssver2,Mzp6628and6 otherslike this
4.5k views
@Thinker : Test 2  
Q47. Statement 1 is correct.
"Person renounces his citizenship, minor child if the person also looses his citizenship".

Answer should be D (neither is incorrect)

Answer given in the key is b).

Kindly clarify.


aparna.sharma634600,
3.8k views
@Thinker : Test 2  
Q47. Statement 1 is correct.
"Person renounces his citizenship, minor child if the person also looses his citizenship".

Answer should be D (neither is incorrect)

Answer given in the key is b).

Kindly clarify.


1st statement is crct

2nd is wrong bcoz voluntarily renunciation of citizenship automatically terminates except during war.

So question is asking incrct so answer isB

ssver2,Mzp6628and2 otherslike this
1.9k views

query regarding question: 44

The birth should be registered at an Indian consulate within 1 year as a necessary condition for citizenship right. merely having either of parents as an Indian citizen at the time of his birth would not suffice.

@Thinker 

please do clarify.

ssver2,
2.9k views
@Patrick_jane @Thinker  for the option c to be correct it should be seperation of power rather than division of power. 


Yes but already separation of powers is given as one of the feature.


ssver2,Tetsuko
1.9k views

How is Kesavnanda case related to federal structure?

2.5k views


Test 2 Question number 2 in Statement 3 it is written "Andhra Pradesh was created before the States Reorganization Act was enacted.

But it wasAndhra statewhich was created NOT Andhra Pradesh. If anybody has knowledge on this can clarify.

Otherwise this question seems invalid as 1 only is not there in options.


ssver2,mickeyviruand1 otherslike this
1.6k views

sgf 2/2

48. D? // b/c art 75(5) //


22. B?

1.4k views

sgf 2/2

48. D? // b/c art 75(5) //


22. B?

In 1997 sc ruled that a Non MP person can be appointed as Minister but S/he has to become MP within 6 months,otherwise S/he ceased to be minister.

So 3 option is crct.

Its asking incrct so 1&2 are incorrect

22 is crct Liberty of Thought Expression Belief Faith Worship

It is askng incrct So B is crct.

ssver2,
1.9k views
@ativdan w.r.t 48: the person can be removed after 6 months but at least he was appointed in the first instance
w.r.t 22: it asks for which are NOT associated with liberty


ssver2,
1.6k views

Q8. Art 3 deals with the changes or formation of States that are already part of the union of India. 

This is given as crct by key. What will happen if a UT (not part of union) is upgraded to State. Is this not covered under Art. 3?

2.3k views
@noOneSee the explanation I added by 18th CAA.


noOne,
2.9k views

BATCH 2- TEST 2:

I found some mistakes in the key of test 2. Please weigh in.

       KEY     ANS

Q16.  C      D

Q27.  C      A

Q29.  D      C

SACHIN_SHARMA,DR UMESH SHARMA
2.8k views

 @root  @Thinker


Test 2 Q 29

Sir, in this question in the 4th statement may be due to misprint or otherwise name of case and elements of basic structure was interchanged. So it created ambiguity in deciding answer.

So, please clarify that whether answer should be ( D) or ( C ). 

2.9k views
@7shaila Q2 seems invalid.
Q16 asks incorrect and Political justice definition seems correct so answer may be option c
Q 27 separation of power is equated as division of power which may not be totally wrong hence the option c
Q29 federal structure is mentioned as federal character which seems equivalent hence option d


1.6k views

@Thinker can u relook in to the quest 27 of test 2 key,division of powers is a feature of Federal system not Presidential System.


It can be a part of Presidential system clearly

Tetsuko,
2.7k views
@Milankovitch 
Q48 Second statement is correct but in the question they asked to markincorrect statement.
Q 26 According to me, we have positive secularism so state can support all religion and according to Art 25 can regulate religious institutions. Abolition of Triple talaq, religious subsidies are some examples. Please correct me if I am wrong


2.8k views
@Lighthouse answer is b because there is an exception and that is during war time


Lighthouse,
2.9k views

SFG 2 TEST 1

answer to question 27 is wrong.

The head of special committee to examine the draft constitution was Alladi Krishnaswamy Ayyar not JL Nehru.


It is Jawaharlal Nehru which is also the name given in updated Laxmikanth editions 5th and 6th.

3k views

yraj38said

SFG-2 Test-1

Doubts regarding Answer Key.

Question no 14

Question no 27  

Question no 29

Please correct your answers.

Plz post your specific doubts, I will resolve it.

3k views
Write your comment…