Subscribe to ForumIAS

Official: SFG / RLG All Tests Discussions in one place

Hello All,

The Group usage here is a little cumbersome, so I am creating this thread to make sure that all questions with doubts stay in one place. Can someone push all the doubts and queries here? I will make this an announcement?


-Faceless, Anonymous "root"

jack_Sparrow,curious_kidand56 otherslike this
526.6k views

1.4k comments

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

2.2k views

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

crowding out happens when private sector is driven out due to excess government participation in a sector. Excess borrowing by government leaves less capital for private sector leading to less expenditure.

3.2k views

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

crowding out happens when private sector is driven out due to excess government participation in a sector. Excess borrowing by government leaves less capital for private sector leading to less expenditure.

Am I Confusing the word Expenditure with investment or both are same?

bernoullitrials,
2.2k views

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

crowding out happens when private sector is driven out due to excess government participation in a sector. Excess borrowing by government leaves less capital for private sector leading to less expenditure.

Am I Confusing the word Expenditure with investment or both are same?

In the question I interpreted expenditure = investment spending. 

3.2k views

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

crowding out happens when private sector is driven out due to excess government participation in a sector. Excess borrowing by government leaves less capital for private sector leading to less expenditure.

Am I Confusing the word Expenditure with investment or both are same?

In the question I interpreted expenditure = investment spending. 

@Himasree Ok but I believe both are different. 

Investment is when you put your money in some product and expenditure is associated with the product when you already have it like petrol in a car.

Since Government pulls out money and less money is present so private companies won't do investment in new business because for that they need to borrow money which is now available at a higher lending rate due to crowding-out effect. Hence they decrease their investments.

Those who have to mandatorily do it because of some investments already done in the market will need to borrow it even though the lending rate is high which may increase their expenditure. Hence expenditure increases.

This is what I thought.


2.2k views

w.r.t Test 38 Q 4 When Crowding out effect kicks in there is less money in the economy and hence the money lending institutions increase the lending rate resulting in higher interest payment by the private sector due to which there expenditure increases and thus their investment decreases.

The correct answer is option c which means there expenditure decreases.

So how is there expenditure reducing?

Crowding out effect - The crowding-out effect is an economic theory arguing that rising public sector spending drives down or even eliminates private sector spending.

You are confusing the way government functions from the way private sector functions. The government can borrow money for expenditure as well as investment, on the other hand the private sector can undertake borrowing only for further investment.

A private entity can not be sustainable if its income is not higher than its expenditure. Thus when the private sector borrows money, it uses that money to expand its production capacity to generate further income only.

However, since crowding out effect leads to an increase in interest rates, the private sector will find it more difficult to undertake further investment decisions. Thus they would not indulge in the expansion of their production capacity, thereby reducing the private sector's expenditure which would have taken place had the interest rates been lower.


3.1k views

Q 33...managed exchange rate system..it is the central bank that intervenes to affect it and not the government of the economy..plz don’t say that central bank is also owned by the government. I know that but central bank has clearly assigned functions regarding managing the exchange rate system in managed rate system

PE14,
3.2k views

ARS21said

STT isdirecttax?


Securities Transaction Tax (STT) is a type of financial transaction tax levied in India on transactions done on the domestic stock exchanges. The rates of STT are prescribed by the Central / Union Government through its Budget from time to time. In tax parlance, this is categorised as a direct tax.

3.1k views

Hello!

Do you guys plan to write Ancient History SFG tests?


I hardly remember those tongue twisting names of people and places. Seems redundant.

3.5k views

Test 45, Q47

Could someone elaborate on the statement that 'the founders of Buddhism and Jainism came from Republican states.' ? 

3.4k views

SFG batch 2, test 42

Question number 24. Statement 1.

Bimbisara was not a disciple of Buddhism. "Bimbisara was contemporary to both Mahavira and gautam buddha. Both religions claim him as their supporters and devotee." 

Quoted from TN board book

mhs11,
3.6k views

SFG batch 2, test 42

Question number 24. Statement 1.

Bimbisara was not a disciple of Buddhism. "Bimbisara was contemporary to both Mahavira and gautam buddha. Both religions claim him as their supporters and devotee." 

Quoted from TN board book

Also, does follower of Buddhism imply they were Budhha's disciples? The statement should be incorrect.

3.2k views

Test 45, Q47

Could someone elaborate on the statement that 'the founders of Buddhism and Jainism came from Republican states.' ? 

Vardhamana Mahavira belonged to Vajji republic. Gautama Budhha belonged to Sakya clan which is part of Malla republic.

abhilasha1811,
3.2k views
@mhs11 Thank you 


3.4k views

SFG BATCH 2  Test 42 Q 5

Statement 3:

3. Rigvedic Aryans had domesticated the horse whereas there is no evidence of Indus Valley people having been aware of this animal.

 As per TN board book, it is actually not mentioned that Indus valley people  are not aware of Horses.

(Pg No. 20)

As per wikipedia:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surkotada


Statement 3 must be wrong.Answer should be "A".






3.1k views

SFG BATCH 2  Test 42 Q 5

Statement 3:

3. Rigvedic Aryans had domesticated the horse whereas there is no evidence of Indus Valley people having been aware of this animal.

 As per TN board book, it is actually not mentioned that Indus valley people  are not aware of Horses.

(Pg No. 20)

As per wikipedia:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Surkotada


Statement 3 must be wrong.Answer should be "A".






This is a PYQ. UPSC key says 1&3 are correct.

3.2k views

Test 42

Q 7- explanation of statement 1 Sthulbahu was the leader of svetambars and Bhadrabhu was leader of Digambars.

Q-24 -  Buddha does not recognize the existence of soul and god (NCERT RS Sharma). so how can Statement 2 be incorrect ?


3.5k views

SFG test-42

Q-3, rituals were there in Yajurveda and Sacrifices were there in Atharvaveda

Q-7, 2nd Jain Council 513 A.D. or 526 A.D. so it is 6th century not 5th.

Q-14, Patliputra is on the confluence of Gandak and Ganga

Q-16 Domestication of animals started in Neolithic. ( A few associations may be seen later mesolithic age).

mhs11,
3.6k views

SFG batch 2, test 42

Question number 24. Statement 1.

Bimbisara was not a disciple of Buddhism. "Bimbisara was contemporary to both Mahavira and gautam buddha. Both religions claim him as their supporters and devotee." 

Quoted from TN board book

How did you come to this conclusion from one single statement? This is history, you need to refer to other sources. One single Google search or if you had read other NCERTs then it would have been easier for you. 

King Bimbisara met the Buddha for the first time prior to the Buddha's enlightenment and later became an important disciple. Kings like Prasanajit of Kosala, Bimbisar, and Ajatshatru of Magadh accepted his Doctrines and became his disciples. 

3.1k views

Test 45, Q47

Could someone elaborate on the statement that 'the founders of Buddhism and Jainism came from Republican states.' ? 

The statement means that both Mahavira and Buddha belonged to the Mahajanpads/Jandapadas that were a republic. To break it down for you, Mahavira was from Vaishali ( Vajji/Vrajji Mahajanpada) and Buddha was born in a Shakya Kshatriya family in Lumbini near Kapilavastu. Shakyas of Kapilavastu was a tribal Republican territory. 

abhilasha1811,
3.1k views
Write your comment…