May 6, 2024   Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
Subscribe to ForumIAS
May 06, 2024  Academy | Blog  | Community  | Our Philosophy
1
Create
Create
Share GyanWrite an Article and share your knowledge or something you have learned recently.
Ask QuestionStart a discussion, ask a question, or ask for an opinion
Sign in

[Community Initiative] Thread for Posting Performance Sheet. (Reviving For SFG 2022)

Post your performance sheet of SFG  in this thread,It is to  track our own mistakes and also to compare our mistakes with others.

Rationale behind continuing with same thread

  • it becomes a good repository for longtime.
  • Creating new threads making confusion in forum.
  • Back then during discuss platform oldies used single thread so we will do it in old way.
  • The previous work motivates some to participate.







Ps:

  • Pls don't use this thread for discussing anything.
  • Only use it,for uploading ur performance sheet(dont just upload score,pls do upload ur mistakes n if possible add a "y")(u can take reference from others previous work).

Google sheet to compare scores & gauge ones performance:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1gywpblGftHHCODDHVEjgmda5maCDTkPjXAJMC8qbwOQ/edit?usp=drivesdk

X
630Am 12Jan SFG 2022

SFG 2022 Non Ranking Based Performance Comparison Sheet,Overall Average,TEST 1,TEST 2,TEST 3,TEST 4,TEST 5,TEST 6,TEST 7,TEST 8,TEST 9,TEST 10,TEST 11,TEST 12,TEST 13,TEST 14,TEST 15,TEST 16,TEST 17 Head Count,Test Count,26,26,26,1,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0,0 Cutoff,71.0025,68.0025,66.9975 Test ...



Please don't alter the google sheet, just enter your score. 

OTHER USEFUL LINKS:

1)Sfg Related Discussion Thread:

https://forumias.com/post/detail/SFG-RLG-All-Tests-Discussions-in-one-place-1575640662

X
Official: SFG / RLG All Tests Discussions in one place

Hello All,The Group usage here is a little cumbersome, so I am creating this thread to make sure that all questions with doubts stay in one place. Can someone push all the doubts and queries here? I will make this an announcement?-Faceless, Anonymous "root"



2)Any UPSC Related Doubts:

https://forumias.com/post/detail/Doubt-Clearance-Thread-UPSC-2020-1579348713

X
Doubt Clearance Thread: UPSC 2020

"When in doubt, observe and ask questions. When certain, observe at length and ask many more questions."Created this thread as a one stop solution for all members so that all the doubts wherein any conceptual clarification is required can be solved here. 



3) Previous Year UPSC Prelims Questions Thread:

https://forumias.com/post/detail/Previous-Year-Questions-60-Days-Mission-1585383124

X
Previous Year Questions: 60 Days Mission

One cannot place less emphasis on the fact as to how important it is to solve questions asked by UPSC Previously. In fact, UPSC tends to repeat from its own stock, verbatim. This thread, shall be solely dedicated for posting questions asked in CSP & CAPF. I shall be posting questions here on a daily basis. Urge you all to answer these in all seriousness. Shoot doubts if you have any, wrt solving any question. Remember the idea is to solve them, again. Reading questions and solutions is NOT sufficient. Cheers!@Neyawn @root








jack_Sparrow,curious_kidand41 otherslike this
268.6k views

721 comments

correct=37
wrong=13
Score:   65.33
4 Very foolish mistakes 
3.6k views


Falcon,AJ_
5.1k views
How much time it generally take to complete sfg syllabus once? 
3.3k views
correct=39
wrong=11
Score:   70.67
3.3k views

Total: 68

37c 9w 4u


DNA/RNA

ZOO

MOTION OF THANKS

NO CONFIDENCE MOTION

VACATING SEATS WHEN ELECTED TO MULTIPLE OFFICES & THEIR TIME LIMITS

2ND, 3RD SCHEDULES

CARE PROJECT

FISCAL COUNCILS

GANGETIC DOLPHIN: EN

Good work@Patrick_jane 


Patrick_jane,
3.4k views

Attempted 47

Correct/Incorrect- 41/6


11. DNA- RNA (always mark DNA/RNA questions incorrectly)

15. Money Bill- Contingency Fund of India, no APPROPRIATION is required.[SHOULD BE CORRECT]

19. Money bill related (marked incorrect first, changed the answer, the page didn't save)

21. Fiscal Council (Not Attempted)[HAD NO IDEA ABOUT THIS]

25. Parliamentary control[WEIRD QUESTION]

31. CARE Project (Not attempted)

36. Anti-defection Speaker etc (Not attempted)[SHOULD HAVE ATTEMPTED]

41. Zoo Authority (incorrectly, Faint recollection that Sect Moefcc is the Chairman)

42. Privilege and Governor- Silly mistake


Overall paper was quite tricky. Could have ended much worse.

Patrick_jane,
3.5k views


Patrick_jane,
3.5k views

Correct 43

Incorrect- 7

RNA and DNA are self-replicating in nature; coronavirus yaar :/ 

 Private Bill can be introduced by any Member of the Parliamentother than a minister.(negligence)

Deputy Chairman's removal (was under the impression that for all officers of parliament procedure is: majority of all the then members of RS/LS and agreed to by LS/RS)

Climate Adaptation and Resilience for South Asia (CARE) Project: World Bank 

Chairman can't vote in first instance

Patrick_jane,
3.1k views
SFG 2.0
#POLITY_3(3)
Attempt = 50
Correct = 34
Incorrect = 14
Skip = 2
Marks = 58.67
INCORRECT TOPICS
1. Parliament making law in state list | No power under financial emergency (q2)
2. Legislative Council is not subject to dissolution  (q8)
3. DRSC ensure more accountability of executive to parliament (q9)
4. Money bill 110(3) - speaker decision  is final + Money bill NOT CAA (q12)
5. Rajya Sabha has a federal significance, the Vidhan Parishads do not. | RS & Vidhan Parisad not model on House of lord (q14)
6.  Committee on Absence of member & Committee on Private Member's Bills = special committee of RS(q17)
7.   legislative assembly can override the legislative council by passing the bill for the second time .. so NOT equal to that of parliament. (q18)
8. Qualifications of elected & nominated members of  State Legislatures by the Parliament. (q33)
9. Budget Process (q35)
10. Central Zoo Authority - WPA 1972 (q41)
11.  RS election - Open Ballot + NO NOTA (q43)
12. Disqualification of seats (q44)
13.  Chairman of the Rajya Sabha cannot vote when a resolution of his removal is under consideration ( as S/he is not part of it)  q(45)
14. RS chairman q(48)
SKIP
1.  Budget Sequence (q34)
2. Privileges of the State legislature NOT available for Governor (q42)
Patrick_jane,
3.5k views


Falcon,
4.6k views

SFG 2.0, TEST 4 

Correct 46, Incorrect 4, Score - 89

Q4. Lokpal has an independent enquiry wing (I wasn't aware)

Q11. Bor tiger reserve ( Guessed it could be Assam)

Q31. Indian energy modelling forum (Wasn't aware)

Q36. President emoluments ( Q. was tricky, should've been more careful)


I wasn't sure about Q11, Q31. I think i need not attempt all 50, Should be happy attempting less. 

ssver2,Patrick_jane
2.9k views

70M

38C, 8W, 4U

1. Vice president

2. Lokpal ->Is that true? Does lokpal require CVC consultation to even start a preliminary inquiry against central gov employees as given in the answer explanation?

3. Energy modelling forums

4. Tiger reserves

5. Autonomous district councils. 

6. Allowances of president can "change'  - they can't be reduced but can be increased.

7. ADB

8. 42nd CAA - can promulgate NE for a part of the country

Patrick_jane,
3.1k views

SFG 2.0 tests 3 polity 

    Wrong = 17

    Right = 31

    Unattended = 2

    Marks = 50.99

     

    Wrong list - 

     

    1. Deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) and Ribonucleic acid (RNA):
    2. Money bill
    3. Money bill statement not correct
    4. State legislatures 
    5. Financial bill
    6. Fiscal council
    7. Method of parliamentary control
    8. Climate adaptation and resilience for South Asia.
    9. Salaries and qualifications for state legislatures 
    10. Budget sequences 
    11. Motion of thanks 
    12. Anti defection law
    13. Central zoo authorities 
    14. Rajya sabha election
    15. Elected to both House of Parliament 
    16. Panel for chairperson of Rajya Sabha
    17. Charged expenditure on consolidated fund of India for high court ece etc.


Patrick_jane,
3.2k views

test 4:

correct: 37

incorrect: 13

score: 65.33

q2. read parliament as president

4. Lokpal's (prelim) inquiry wing. (thought ki investigation toh CBI karti hai)

7. Constitution requires President to appoint leader of majority party in in LS as PM (b/c art 75(1)&(3))


11. Bor Tiger Reserve: Maha 

18. state party

(thought "only 6% votes to LS" is enough; logically, "+ 1 LS seat" makes sense, since it differentiates from "8% votes to LS/SLA" condition)

20. logic: CoM are collectively responsible, not Cabinet. Cabinet takes decisions and CoM endorse 'em ->speeds up govt activities

Q 32 didn't focus on "ask A minister" i.e. individual responsibility. knew about 164(1A), but thought maybe rules mein bhi add kar diya ho

33. read improper as proper

35. b/c NCRWC did recommend 

36. change ko decrease man liya

38. concepts clear nahi the as to president/governor's role wrt 5th/6th sch (area/application of acts)

40. didn't notice distinction b/w discharge & acting as

47. sarakaria's hung aseembly-order of preference



Patrick_jane,
2.8k views

test 5

correct: 43

incorrect: 7

81.33

comets & asteroids (logic: thoda pani toh hota hi hoga; asteroids erratically move karte honge; basics hi clear nahi hain)

Privy Council (b/c laxmikanth mentions 1947 Independence Act along with PC Act, mujhe laga 1947 mein hi abolish ho gaya tha) 

All India Judicial Services (b/c RS resolution but power toh Parliament ki hi hai :/ )

Seventy-third Amendment Act, 1992 inapplicable in Nagaland (lag raha tha)

Chattogram Port (logic: Bangladesh mein toh Chittagong port hai lol)

both Parliament/SL (governor reserves!) can change HC jurisdiction; posting and promotion of DJ by Gov (consults HC)


lok adalat: criminal cases (logic: wahan mediation hota hai, so won't cover criminal; only compoundable offences!)


could've got most of these correct if relied onrevision+memory & not logic


Patrick_jane,
2.8k views


ssver2,Falcon
4.4k views

SFG 2/Test 5

Attempted 49

Correct/Incorrect- 43/6


9. Art 323B Tribunal - Good question from Forum

12. Gram Sabha- Not all persons.

14. Fast Track Courts - No idea (Unattempted)

17. Property- Dumb mistake. Property legal right

19.Central Council of Local Government- shot in the dark

22. SC appellate- dumb mistake

42. Municipal Council - NOT CORRECT


Overall, most of it was guess work, which could've gone either way. This time it paid off. Not necessarily always.

ssver2,Patrick_janeand1 otherslike this
3.9k views

Test 5

correct:34

incorrect:16

Q48. Adhoc from hc

Q46.Indian and American SC

Q42.NOT CORRECT

Q41. Goldschmidtite

Q40.Jurisdiction of HC

Q39.Royal commission

Q37.DPC

Q36.Oath of president

Q35.Metropolitan planning committee

Q31.Chattogram-Bagladesh

Q30.73rd-not applicable to 5th schedule

Q27.AIJS

Q23.SFC by sla

Q19.Central council of local government

Q18.5 judge bench-Advisory

Q12.Functions of gram sabha not explicit 

Patrick_jane,Falcon
3.2k views

Test #5 Polity

35c 8w 7u

64.67

1. metropolitan/district planning committees

2. Oaths of cji/prez

3. panchayats & municipalities acts' applicability to 5th

4. notified area committee

5. Goldshmidtite

6. Kyaukphyu port of Mayanmar

7. Panama disease

8. Fast track courts vs Special Courts

9. National Biopharma Mission

10. Gram Nyayalas - criminal & civil appeals to sessions/district courts

11. Art 323B empowers central/state legislatures not govts.

12. Asteroids and comets


Phew! 

Patrick_jane,
2.9k views

Sfg2.0 polity 4 test

wrong = 12

unattempted = 3

cancelled = 4 (attempted all)

right = 31 

marks = 54 

wrong lists -

1. Pardon power of president 

2. reports laid down by president in the parliament as duty 

3. appointment of pm by president 

4. tiger  reserve 

5. holding office during pleaser of president 

6. state part recognition 

7. Asian development bank 

8. s.r. Bombai guidelines 

9. Com for state legislatures - 15 % rule 

10. emoluments allowance of president 

11. ordinance making power of president 

12. art 360 

13. CM - terms and salary 

Patrick_jane,
3k views
Write your comment…