Subscribe to ForumIAS

Civil Services Mains 2020 Results: In or Out ? Way ahead, gratitude and Pain

The Civils Mains result has been declared. This thread is for sharing your grief , joy , mixed feelings - absolutely anything and everything.



jack_Sparrow,musaand60 otherslike this
2.3m views

5.3k comments

@AzadHindFauz @whatonly @SergioRamos @Villanelle @peterparker @nerdfighter @sjerngal @DHARNA @Patootie  Please tell what sources did you follow for post independence history as syllabus is vague and question was asked only once in 2013.

I did these-

  • Politics in India since Independence
  • Kunal Aggarwal's short notes

@AzadHindFauz Did you refer to PSIR notes of Kunal Aggarwal too?

4.1k views
Deleted

@Neyawn any idea by when the forum test centre and libraries will probably reopen? any chances that the centre could reopen by 7th June?

4k views
@AzadHindFauz @whatonly @SergioRamos @Villanelle @peterparker @nerdfighter @sjerngal @DHARNA @Patootie  Please tell what sources did you follow for post independence history as syllabus is vague and question was asked only once in 2013.

I did these-

  • Politics in India since Independence
  • Kunal Aggarwal's short notes

@AzadHindFauz Did you refer to PSIR notes of Kunal Aggarwal too?

Yes, I did. 

4.7k views
How is 'Ethical Dilemmas of a Civil Servant' by Anil Swarup , for a light read?
3.7k views

Rewl1said

How is 'Ethical Dilemmas of a Civil Servant' by Anil Swarup , for a light read?

It’s a good read.

3.8k views
Any idea about the expected mains date? Haven't been following threads😅
3.5k views
@Chanakya kaptaan once mentioned about 10th Jan as likely date. Not sure though.


Chanakya,
3.3k views

@THE_MECHANIC I made notes from Story of Civilisation (2 books) by Arjun Dev (old NCERT) and also watched some youtube videos 

@Aquaman I used Nitin Sangwan's notes 

HeNeArKr,
5.4k views
Deleted
.
whatonly,
3.7k views

by the way peeps, for essay one of the best sources are these handouts. you can check it out. very crisp.

we can prepare our own notes in this format,


Essay-1-Poverty-Inequality-Basic-Income-Class-Handouts.pdf

EiChan,Sedateand4 otherslike this
3.4k views

Rewl1said

How is 'Ethical Dilemmas of a Civil Servant' by Anil Swarup , for a light read?

Have read it partly. Found it apt for a light read. 

3.8k views
@Chanakya Most likely from the following three : 31/12/2021 to 9/1/2022 OR 7/1/2022 to 16/1/2022 OR 14/1/2022 to 23/1/2022.
Worst Case Scenario : They could begin from as early as 17/12/2021 or 24/12/2021.


EiChan,Chanakyaand1 otherslike this
3.3k views
@Chanakya Most likely from the following three : 31/12/2021 to 9/1/2022 OR 7/1/2022 to 16/1/2022 OR 14/1/2022 to 23/1/2022.
Worst Case Scenario : They could begin from as early as 17/12/2021 or 24/12/2021.


Source? 

3k views
@Inselberg As far as i have observed, out of the four GS papers, they seem to inflate one of the papers marks every year(maybe awarding 70% at max for questions where as you said they tend to stick to the 50% yardstick) and deflate one of the other papers marks.
Like in 2017, GS3 had high scores while GS4 was marked very conservatively
While in 2019, GS4 seems to have been awarded high scores and GS3 conservatively

What do you think ? 

Was any such pattern visible in CSM 2018 marking

Would love some inputs on this 



Yes, deliberate distortion could be the case. 

But there is another perspective to it. 

GS-3 2019 questions were tough. The examiners only evaluated as per the answer key/guidelines (if they are given anything as such?) provided to them. Most students did not perform enough to attain marks in 40-50% bucket. But some did. There are students who got 100+. I know people who could not make it to the final list but got 110. So, can't say that marks in GS-3 was deflated deliberately for all.


GS-4 questions were quite straightforward in 2019. Most students wrote on the expected lines. The ones who added more value received marks in 50-60-70% bracket. 


The basic point is perhaps it is not the examiners who determine which paper will get more marks but the question paper itself. 


Anyway, it is only another hypothesis. Hence, unproven. Maybe with scores in 2020, we can become more confident about which of these thesis provides a better explanation.  

EiChan,TwoFaceand1 otherslike this
3.7k views
@calvinhobbes No Source Mate !
Just some logical deduction seeing previous years trends(especially 2020 Mains).


3.2k views
@Inselberg I agree on most things you have said
What you are deducing is just another aspect of the whole inflation/deflation process of the papers. And its true that a few candidates would overall write a much better paper to tough questions than what majority would do, hence a few very good scores bucking the trend of deflation would be seen in the paper specifically deflated every year.
Who knows, it might be GS1 in CSM 2021 that gets rewarded liberally 😄 and all the notions of low cost-benefit in relation to Post Independence History and World History that people here have been citing are thrown out of the window.


Inselberg,
6k views

by the way peeps, for essay one of the best sources are these handouts. you can check it out. very crisp.

we can prepare our own notes in this format,


Essay-1-Poverty-Inequality-Basic-Income-Class-Handouts.pdf

These are very helpful. Thank you :)

Where can I find rest of the handouts?

EiChan,Sedateand3 otherslike this
6k views
Do we have any active thread for peer review of essay/ethics case studies??? TIA
5.7k views
Write your comment…