Subscribe to ForumIAS

Official: SFG / RLG All Tests Discussions in one place

Hello All,

The Group usage here is a little cumbersome, so I am creating this thread to make sure that all questions with doubts stay in one place. Can someone push all the doubts and queries here? I will make this an announcement?


-Faceless, Anonymous "root"

jack_Sparrow,curious_kidand56 otherslike this
510.1k views

1.4k comments

@saxena_amit20100 You are right. Answer should be "D"


TheMiddlePath,
3.3k views

Test 16, Q38.

Statement 1-ALLDelhi Durbars were conducted atCoronation Park, Delhi

This has been marked incorrect according to the answer key.

I believe this statement is correct.

1. Proof for1877 coronationat Coronation Park.

https://blogs.loc.gov/international-collections/2017/11/the-delhi-durbar-and-the-proclamation-of-queen-victoria/

2. Plaque at Coronation Park specifically mentions1911 coronation.

3. https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/new-delhis-106th-anniversary-coronation-pillar-wears-defaced-look/articleshow/62041742.cms

https://web.archive.org/web/20090513183442/http://www.charlottecory.com/travel/delhi_durbar.htm

The1903 coronation.

TheMiddlePath,
3.3k views

Test 16

QNo 39

Ans should be "B"

It is Irish Nationalist not Italian

Happier,Amansinghal
3.3k views

Turns out you are right.

But it has been mentioned in many places that Home charges include the miitary aspect as well.
First is a screenshot from Jagran Josh and the second is the screenshot from RC Dutts book.
(PDF- https://socialsciences.mcmaster.ca/econ/ugcm/3ll3/dutt/EcHisIndia2.pdf )

So probably the answer key could be wrong.



Edit- On second thought, it says "all charges of british troops in India, and partial cost of TRANSPORTATION to and fro India"

It could be interpreted that cost ofwaging war  is not included per se. Confusing.

root,TheMiddlePath
3.3k views

Today's test Que no 15 Home charges answer given here is D , this question was asked pre 2011 , and official UPSC key says B.Que no 59.copy-of-cut-off-20113.jpggs_paper_i.pdfgs_paper_i.pdf

Happier,
3.5k views
@TH14 question says "waging war outside INDIA. "
Whereas snap shot of R. C. Dutta book reads " cost of military and other stores suppliedTo INDIA "


3.3k views
@TH14 Allahabad Durbar. 1858.


Question is asking about only the Delhi Durbar

TheMiddlePath,
3.3k views
@TH14 question says "waging war outside INDIA. "
Whereas snap shot of R. C. Dutta book reads " cost of military and other stores suppliedTo INDIA "


Read the jagranjosh link. It elaborates on home charges. same can be found in Dutt's book verbatim.


There is some confusion though.

3.3k views
@TH14 you are right. Misread it.


3k views

Question number 38 first statement is right

TheMiddlePath,
3.2k views

@root 

Sir, whom to tag during History phase expecting clarifications?

Continue tagging thinker????

TH14,
3.7k views



Source- Shodhganga 


Download the pdf and type "revolutionary" for further clarification.


3.2k views

How point 3 in Qué 17(Regarding wavell plan) test 17 is not correct? Please guide me. 

TheMiddlePath,
3.2k views
@DrS ya it's wrong and that's why answer is Option "C" as per the Key


3.2k views

@Thinker 

Q 27,

The statement 1 is Navjivan was the first Gujarati Newspaper to be published by Mahatma Gandhi.

     

But Bombay Samachar was the first Gujarati newspaper instead of Navjivan in 1822.

Pls clarify..

3.4k views

Dear Forum IAS,

All the tests of Polity went well. Sir@Thinker  clarified all our doubts on this platform. But from the day History subject Tests are started there is no Teacher is here to clear our doubts. 

One must also understand that not everyone is getting discussion of tests. There are at least 300 students who are left out of discussion. So, kindly provide some teacher who can clear our doubts on this platform. Even if it cleared doubt of at least single aspirant, then also there is success of this platform. 

@root @Neyawn 

Thank you.

Mzp6628,Cincinnati
3.3k views
@SACHIN_SHARMA In 1st statement is specific to Gandhi. 2nd one is general statement. 


3.2k views

Q 27 Navjeevan was 1st GUJARATI paper by Mr Gandhi. 

Why you corrected it? If UPSC will behave in same manner what will aspirants do???

https://www.google.com/amp/s/m.timesofindia.com/city/ahmedabad/mahatmas-newspaper-turns-100/amp_articleshow/71030096.cms

TH14,
3.2k views
@mr_riteshyadav633  Sir I am asking How NOT CORRECT?
THANK YOU 


3.2k views

Please, clarify why authority changed ans of Q27 test 17 ?

Thank you .

3.2k views
Write your comment…