Does the actual working of Indian federalism conform to the centralizing tendencies in Indian polity? Give reasons for your answer.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 federal in form, but Centre-tilted by design → actual working confirms the tiltRoute 2 Wheare’s “quasi-federal” → Partition / integration /…
The recent developments in Indian Politics has not eroded the true spirit of federalism in India. Critically examine this statement with the help of appropriate examples.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 Elazar’s “self-rule + shared rule” test → developments strain but do not erase spiritRoute 2 federalism as India’s multi-level device for…
Discuss the composition and functions of the Inter-State Council. To what extent has this body been successful in achieving its objectives?
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 ISC as the chief institution of cooperative federalism → Art 263, set up 1990 on Sarkaria recommendationRoute 2 shared-rule forum under…
The philosophy and administration of the distribution of powers between Centre and State is required to be re- assessed.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 distribution of powers = hallmark of Indian federalism → reconciles national unity with local autonomyRoute 2 Centre-tilt justified by Partition /…
Indian federation has moved from cooperative federation to competitive federation
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 claim only partly true → cooperation supplemented, not replacedRoute 2 Austin’s cooperative base intact → competition added as a new layerBody…
Implementation of GST and NEET is a major challenge to Indian Federalism.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 both reforms push national uniformity over State discretion → that is the federal challengeRoute 2 GST and NEET pull power upward…
Discuss asymmetrical federalism in India.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 asymmetry = different units, different powers/status under one Constitution → contrast with symmetry → not a flaw but a deviceRoute 2…
Despite constitutional mandate the Inter-State Council has not come of age. Discuss.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 Art. 263 mandate (inquire → discuss → recommend) → yet no maturation since its 1990 birth under SarkariaRoute 2 meant to…
Comment on the Mechanism for settling inter-state disputes in 150 words.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 divided powers/interests → disputes built into the system → Constitution offers judicial + extra-judicial mechanismsRoute 2 federalism breeds conflict by design…
Does the functioning of the federalism in India tend to make it appear as a unitary state in practice.
Flow snapshot — how the answer movesIntro routesRoute 1 federal in structure, strong Union bias → bias shows in functioning → Wheare “quasi-federal”Route 2 Wheare’s formulation: unitary state with subsidiary…
Free study material
PSIR Revision NotesFull syllabus, topic by topic PSIR PYQsTen years of PYQ answeredThe taught version
Reading builds content. Evaluated writing builds the score.
Foundation 2027Magnus & Crucible · from ₹42,000 Test Series 2027O-AWFG · Prime · ATS