Source: The post is based on the article “Mediating, Minus Sarkar” published in Times of India on 10th August 2023.
Syllabus: GS2- Dispute redressal mechanisms
News: The author discusses the new Mediation Bill passed in India, which formalizes and promotes mediation as a mainstream method for resolving disputes.
What are the main features of the Mediation Bill?
Recognition of Mediation: The bill recognizes mediation as a key method for resolving various disputes, from commercial to personal matters.
Definition: Mediation involves a neutral third person helping parties find an amicable settlement.
Types: Includes conciliation, community, and online mediation.
Mediation Agreement: Given the same status as a court judgment, harder to challenge than an arbitral award.
Online Mediation: Specific rules are provided for Online Mediation.
Mediation Council: Established with experienced members from mediation, law, government, and industry sectors.
Training & Service Providers: The bill acknowledges mediation institutes and service providers.
Community Mediation: Addressing local peace and harmony issues.
What are the benefits of the Mediation Bill?
Speedy Process: Mediation can be done within days to a few months, much faster than litigation.
Cost-Efficient: While now a profession, mediation remains less costly than court proceedings.
Active Participation: Disputants play a central role, unlike in adversarial processes.
Amicable Solutions: Focuses on practical agreements benefiting both parties rather than strictly legal verdicts.
Enforceability: Mediation agreements are easily enforced.
High Success Rate: Often sees success rates above 50%.
Support from Lawyers: Many lawyers appreciate mediation for its advantages and benefits to clients.
What are the limitations of the Mediation Bill?
Exclusions in Schedule: The bill has a lengthy list of cases not suitable for mediation. For instance, many disputes involving the government are excluded, indicating a preference for the state to continue litigations with citizens.
Ambiguous Provisions: Compoundable criminal offences are listed as non-mediatable, but another awkwardly drafted provision makes them mediatable.
Weak Language: Mandatory mediation before litigation is emphasized in soft terms, which might dilute its impact.
Section 49 Issue: There’s a significant loophole in Section 49, making it less stringent.
Absence of Practising Mediators: The Mediation Council lacks representatives from the current practicing mediators, which seems like an oversight.
Non-adherence to Singapore Convention: The bill doesn’t incorporate the Singapore Convention, which would have made enforcement of international commercial mediated settlements more accessible globally.
Over-Reliance on Mediators: The success of the bill heavily depends on the continuous efforts of mediators across the country.
Discover more from Free UPSC IAS Preparation Syllabus and Materials For Aspirants
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
