Indo-French harmony: on President Macron’s visit to India 

Indo-French harmony: on President Macron’s visit to India

Context

PM Modi and President Macron deepen ties to work around global uncertainties

French President’s visit

• Joint Vision Statement:  The Joint Vision Statement on the Indian Ocean Region is clearly aimed at countering China’s growing presence in the region.
• Climate Change cooperation: The International Solar Alliance, recommitment to starting the Jaitapur nuclear power plant, and joint ventures on climate change cooperation are reactions to the U.S. abdicating its role by announcing its pullout from the Paris accord.
• Reciprocal logistics support agreement: The “reciprocal logistics support” agreement, which Prime Minister Narendra Modi called a “golden step” in defence cooperation, is a signal to Russia and to the U.S.-led alliance that partnered in the “Quadrilateral”, that both New Delhi and Paris feel the need to diversify strategic postures beyond their current choices.

ISA challenging geopolitical power structure

• Finally, by bringing 61 countries into the ISA, India and France are proposing an alternative leadership model for the less developed world, challenging the geopolitical power structure configured around fossil-fuel energy resources.
• The daunting task ahead is made clear by Mr. Macron’s assertion that $1 trillion is needed to reach the ISA goals by 2030: India and France have so far committed $1.4 billion and $1.3 billion, respectively

Problems

India

• Solar power tariffs low in India: India’s solar power tariffs stand at about ₹2.40 a unit and there is little scope to make the domestic industry profitable, unless the cost of solar panels and other components are brought down drastically.
• More thermal power being produced: At the same time, more thermal power, for which tariffs are higher but which is less fickle than solar or wind power, is being produced than the demand.

France

• Jaitapur plant progress is slow: France’s nuclear power story is a success, but negotiations between EDF and NPCIL for the Jaitapur plant, billed as the world’s biggest, have made very slow progress. While the two countries have committed to start construction by end-2018, they have missed deadlines multiple times.
• Indian Ocean Region cooperation might be symbolic
• Bilateral cooperation in the Indian Ocean Region too is more symbolic than substantive today, and much will depend on how closely the Indian and French navies and intelligence work together in the future.

Engagement with China also

The presumed joint message to Beijing may also be blurred by Mr. Macron’s parallel commitment to help “lead” the Belt and Road Initiative with China.

Conclusion

As two democracies with a firm belief in a multipolar world order and in the future of Eurasia, India and France have numerous strategic convergences. But common ambitions to cooperate on the world stage, as projected by Mr. Macron and Mr. Modi, must be grounded in some hard realities as well