- Interview Guidance initiative by ForumIAS – UPSC CSE 2026 Click Here to know more →
- FRC 2027: SFG Residential program | accepting application for Tranche-2 Click Here to know more →
- CSAT Classes for Prelims 2027 by Rishi Bhargav sir starts 16 Nov. at 5 PM Click Here to know more →
Source: The post “A poverty line that falls short” has been created based on “A poverty line that falls short” published in “The Hindu” on 15th November 2026.
UPSC Syllabus: GS 3 – Indian Economy
Context: Poverty in India has declined sharply over the past decade. However, there is no consensus among researchers and policymakers regarding the actual number of people living in poverty. Different estimates place India’s poverty rate between 5% and more than 26%, depending on the poverty line and methodology adopted.
Divergence in Poverty Estimates
- World Bank Estimates: According to the World Bank, 2.6% of Indians were poor in 2022-23 under the international poverty line of $3 per day (2021 PPP). However, raising the poverty line to $4.20 per day increases the estimated poverty rate to around 16.1%.
- SBI Research (2025): Using the Tendulkar poverty line of 2009, adjusted for inflation, SBI estimated poverty at 7.2% in rural India and 4.6% in urban India for 2022-23.
- Rangarajan and Dev (2014): Their inflation-adjusted estimates placed poverty at 10.8%.
- Sethu, Surya and Ruthu (2024): Their reconstructed Rangarajan methodology, based on the latest consumption survey, estimated poverty at 26.4%.
- Variation in poverty thresholds:
- SBI’s Tendulkar-based estimates use monthly consumption thresholds of approximately ₹1,632 per person in rural areas and ₹1,944 in urban areas.
- In contrast, Sethu et al. use higher thresholds of ₹2,515 in rural areas and ₹3,639 in urban areas.
- Therefore, higher poverty lines naturally result in higher poverty estimates.
Evolution of Poverty Measurement in India
- Alagh Task Force (1979): It introduced separate calorie-based norms for rural and urban populations, which became the basis for subsequent poverty estimates.
- Lakdawala Committee: It refined the approach by introducing state-specific poverty lines and price indices.
- Tendulkar Committee (2009): It moved away from the direct calorie-based method and adopted a wider consumption basket that included expenditure on health and education. It estimated poverty at 21.9% in 2011-12.
- Rangarajan Committee: It proposed higher poverty thresholds and estimated poverty at 29.5% for the same year.
Major Challenges in Poverty Estimation
- Differences in Methodology: Different committees and research institutions use different poverty lines, consumption baskets and inflation-adjustment methods, resulting in widely varying estimates.
- Lack of Comparable Data: The 2017-18 consumption survey was never published, and the next full survey was available only in 2022-23. This created a gap of more than a decade in comparable poverty data.
- Changing Poverty Benchmarks: The World Bank’s international poverty lines are based on Purchasing Power Parity (PPP), which helps compare countries but does not necessarily reflect the actual cost of meeting basic needs in India.
- Different Reconstruction Methods: Some researchers adjust older poverty lines for inflation, while others reconstruct poverty estimates using spending patterns from newer surveys.
- Inadequate Measurement of Deprivation: Consumption-based poverty estimates may overlook deprivation in essential services such as sanitation, drinking water, housing, health and education.
Importance of Multidimensional Poverty Measurement
- Broader Assessment: Multidimensional poverty captures deprivation in health, education and living standards rather than relying only on consumption expenditure.
- NITI Aayog Estimates: Multidimensional poverty declined from 24.85% in 2015-16 to 14.96% in 2019-21. Its estimate for 2022-23 was 11.28%, based on projections from earlier trends rather than a fresh survey.
- World Bank and OPHI Estimates: For 2019-21, the World Bank estimated multidimensional poverty at 15.5%, while the Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI) estimated it at 16.4%.
- Identification of Hidden Deprivation: According to the World Bank, around 80% of Indians lived below the $8.3-a-day upper-middle-income poverty line in 2023, even though per capita income was more than three times the extreme-poverty threshold.
- Persistent Inequality: Around 30% of Indians still lack access to basic sanitation, highlighting the limitations of relying only on extreme-poverty estimates.
Way Forward
- Establish a Credible Benchmark: India needs a reliable and widely accepted official poverty line to assess the actual extent of poverty.
- Use Updated Consumption Data: The fresh data from the 2022-23 Household Consumption Expenditure Survey (HCES) should be used to improve poverty estimation.
- Adopt a Comprehensive Approach: Poverty measurement should consider both consumption expenditure and multidimensional deprivation.
- Ensure Comparability: A consistent methodology and regular publication of consumption surveys are necessary to enable meaningful comparisons over time.
- Focus on Economic Insecurity: Poverty measurement should also identify people who may be above the extreme-poverty line but continue to face inadequate access to essential services and decent living conditions.
Conclusion: India has undoubtedly made real progress in reducing poverty. However, without a credible and universally accepted poverty benchmark, it is difficult to determine how much progress has been achieved and how much poverty remains. A reliable poverty line, supported by updated consumption data and multidimensional indicators, is essential for inclusive development and effective policymaking.
Question: Despite a significant decline in poverty in India, the estimation of poverty remains contested due to differences in methodologies and benchmarks. Discuss the challenges in measuring poverty in India and the need for a credible poverty line.
Source: The Hindu



