[Answered] Critically analyze the implications of Donald Trump’s return to power on India-U.S. relations. What opportunities and challenges does this pose for South Asia? (250 words)
Quarterly-SFG-Jan-to-March
Red Book

Introduction: Contextual Introduction

Body: Highlight implications for India-US relations and opportunities and challenges for South Asia

Conclusion: Way forward

The re-election of Donald Trump as the President of the United States in 2025 is likely to have significant implications for India-U.S. relations and broader South Asian geopolitics.

Implications for India-U.S. Relations

  • Countering China: Trump’s confrontational approach towards China aligns with India’s regional goals, fostering deeper cooperation in the Indo-Pacific strategy.
  • Focus on Reciprocity and Burden Sharing: Trump’s emphasis on burden-sharing aligns with India’s aspiration to be a regional leader. Increased U.S. capacity-building and defense assistance to India will help enhance its strategic capabilities.
  • Pressure on Regional Alliances: India may face increased pressure to align unequivocally with U.S. goals in South Asia, potentially limiting its strategic autonomy vis-à-vis Russia and regional actors like Iran.
  • Reduced Friction on Values-Based Issues: Unlike the Biden administration, Trump is expected to deprioritize issues of democracy and human rights. This may alleviate U.S. scrutiny over India’s internal policies and pragmatic regional engagements, e.g., support for Bangladesh’s Sheikh Hasina government and Myanmar’s junta.

Opportunities and Challenges for South Asia

  • Economic Assistance: Trump’s focus on development assistance, infrastructure, and defense agreements (similar to his first term) could benefit countries like Sri Lanka, struggling to recover from economic crises. This would reduce their dependence on Chinese financing.
  • Reduced Pressure on Domestic Politics: South Asian countries with authoritarian tendencies, such as Myanmar’s junta and the Taliban in Afghanistan, may face less scrutiny under Trump, creating opportunities for economic and strategic re-engagement.
  • Balancing China and the U.S.: Trump’s confrontational stance towards China will pressure South Asian nations to choose sides. Countries like Bangladesh, Nepal, and Sri Lanka, which often leverage great power competition for economic and strategic benefits, may face reduced diplomatic flexibility.
  • Pressure on Smaller Nations: Trump’s emphasis on reciprocity may push smaller South Asian nations to offer more in trade, defense, or policy alignment, which could strain their economies and domestic politics.

Conclusion

For India, the challenge lies in balancing its strategic autonomy while playing a leadership role in the region. South Asia, therefore, must adapt to Trump’s leadership style while managing the broader geopolitical shifts in great power politics.

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community