[Answered] Critically analyze the proposition that restricting urban planning to land-use planning hinders growth. Examine how a holistic approach is essential for achieving ‘Viksit Bharat’ by 2047.

Introduction

UN projects 50% of India will be urban by 2047, contributing nearly 75% of GDP. Restricting planning to land-use undermines economic dynamism, climate resilience, and livability—critical for achieving Viksit Bharat.

How land-use–centric planning restricts India’s growth

  1. No linkage with economic vision: Master Plans largely focus on zoning and permissible land use. Cities are treated as physical spaces, not as economic growth hubs. Example: Most Master Plans do not assess economic drivers or job-creation potential, violating the idea of strategic spatial planning advocated by UN-Habitat.
  2. Ignores rapid demographic and employment transitions: Urban population increases by 25–30 million yearly (MoHUA). Current planning extrapolates past growth trends rather than projecting jobs-driven migration.
  3. Neglect of natural resource and carrying-capacity constraints: Cities like Bengaluru and Chennai face severe groundwater depletion (NITI Aayog Composite Water Index Report). Land-use planning ignores resource budgeting, leading to water scarcity, flooding, and heat islands.
  4. Fragmented planning within municipal boundaries: Urban expansion occurs beyond municipal limits—metros now spill into peri-urban regions. Lack of metropolitan governance leads to duplication of infrastructure and unplanned growth (case: Gurugram).
  5. Environmental degradation and poor mobility outcomes: Transportation contributes 40% of particulate pollution in urban India (CSE). Master Plans miss Comprehensive Mobility Plans, climate resilience pathways, and environmental risk assessments.

Thus, a zoning mindset results in spatial growth without economic or ecological strategy.

Why a holistic planning approach is essential for Viksit Bharat (2047)

A modern planning paradigm must integrate the following pillars:

Element of Holistic PlanningStrategic Outcome
Economic planning + job mappingAligns cities with national GDP and employment goals.
Natural resource budgeting & climate action plansEnsures resilience and reduces vulnerability (SDG-11).
Comprehensive mobility planningReduces congestion, emissions; promotes TOD, NMT.
Regional planning beyond city limitsEnables industrial expansion into smaller towns; supports Make in India.
Data-driven governance (GIS, digital twins)Real-time service delivery, predictive management.

 Case studies demonstrating holistic success

  • Ahmedabad BRTS (Janmarg): Integrated mobility planning → increased modal shift to public transport, reducing congestion & pollution.
  • Indore Waste Management Model: Zero-landfill approach using PPP + behavioral nudges; ranked India’s cleanest city (Swachh Survekshan).
  • Singapore Urban Planning Model Resource budgeting + mixed-use planning + transit-oriented development (TOD) → top global liveability index.
  • Delhi NCR Regional Plan (NCRPB): Planning at regional scale enabled Noida–Gurugram industrial corridors.

These examples demonstrate that planning for economy + ecology + equity drives sustainable development.

 The Way Forward: Reforms Needed

  1. Shift from zoning-based land-usestrategic economic and ecological planning.
  2. Mandate City Economic Vision Papers before Master Plans (as recommended by NITI Aayog Urban Strategy 2047).
  3. Integrate urban mobility, climate action, natural resource budgeting into planning statutes.
  4. Build a new cadre of urban planners, climate economists, GIS experts—aligning education to future needs.
  5. Strengthen Metropolitan Planning Committees (Article 243ZE) for interdepartmental coordination.

Conclusion

Cities thrive when planning nurtures people and markets. A holistic urban strategy is indispensable for a Viksit Bharat.

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community