[Answered] Discuss the challenges faced by state governments in enforcing safety regulations in illegal coal mines. Analyze the economic and social factors contributing to the prevalence of illegal coal mining in India.
Red Book
Red Book

Introduction: Contextual Introduction

Body: What are the challenges faced by the government and factors contributing to illegal mining?

Conclusion: Way forward

The tragic death of three workers in an illegal coal mine in Gujarat’s Surendranagar district underscores several systemic issues related to illegal coal mining in India. This incident, along with others in Jharkhand and West Bengal, points to the dangerous conditions and inadequate safety measures prevalent in illegal coal mining operations.

Challenges

  • Lack of Safety Equipment and Protocols: Workers in illegal mines often lack basic safety equipment such as helmets, masks, and proper ventilation systems. The absence of such gear leads to severe respiratory risks, as evidenced by the deaths in the Surendranagar incident.
  • Lack of Training: Many individuals working in illegal mines are untrained and unaware of the risks involved. The lack of proper training and emergency response knowledge exacerbates the danger.
  • Geographical Barriers: The remote and difficult terrain of many illegal mining sites poses additional challenges for enforcement efforts.
  • Insufficient Manpower and Technology: State governments often lack the necessary manpower and technological resources to monitor and shut down illegal mining operations effectively.

Economic and Social Factors Contributing to Illegal Coal Mining

  • Poverty and Unemployment: In regions with high poverty rates and limited employment opportunities, illegal mining provides a livelihood for many, making it difficult to enforce regulations without addressing underlying socio-economic issues.
  • Energy Needs: Coal remains the most abundant fossil fuel in India, accounting for 55% of the country’s energy needs. The high power demand, driven by industrial and residential consumption, often outstrips the legal supply, creating a lucrative market for illegally mined coal.
  • Coal Mafias: In regions with weak law enforcement, “coal mafias” often emerge, controlling illegal mining operations and sometimes enjoying the tacit support of local officials or political leaders.
  • Political Support: In some areas, illegal mining operations receive tacit or explicit support from political leaders, complicating efforts to curb these activities. For instance, allegations have been made against BJP leaders in Assam and other northeastern states for supporting illegal rat-hole mining despite a ban by the National Green Tribunal (NGT).

Conclusion

Addressing illegal mining requires stronger governance, better enforcement, alternative livelihoods, and public awareness campaigns. Without coordinated state and central efforts, incidents like those in Surendranagar, Jharkhand, and West Bengal will continue to result in fatalities and unsafe working conditions.

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community