India’s Data Protection Rules
Red Book
Red Book

Mains Guidance Program (MGP) for UPSC CSE 2026, Cohort-1 starts 11th February 2025. Registrations Open Click Here to know more and registration.

Source: This post on India’s Data Protection Rules has been created based on article “India’s data protection rules need some fine-tuning” published in The Hindu  on 13th January 2025. 

UPSC Syllabus topic- GS Paper 3- Technology

Context: The article discusses India’s recently released Draft Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Rules, 2025, which aim to operationalize the country’s digital personal data protection framework following the enactment of the DPDP Act, 2023. These rules mark a shift from previous drafts of data protection laws, taking a more principles-based and pragmatic approach that avoids the pitfalls of overly prescriptive regulations seen in jurisdictions like the European Union’s GDPR.

What are the Draft Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Rules?

  • Released by the Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY) on January 3, 2025.
  • Aim to operationalize the Digital Personal Data Protection (DPDP) Act, 2023, marking a significant step in safeguarding personal data in India.
  • Reflect a shift from the earlier, restrictive Personal Data Protection Bill, with a principles-based, pragmatic approach.

How does India’s approach differ from the European GDPR?

  • The EU’s General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR), once a gold standard, faces criticism for:
    • Overburdening businesses, especially smaller enterprises.
    • Failing to enhance public trust in the Internet.
  • India avoids the EU’s overly prescriptive model by focusing on flexibility and outcomes:
    • Simplifies notice and consent mechanisms to reduce “consent fatigue.”
    • Respects business autonomy by avoiding micro-regulation of user interfaces.
    • Provides industry-specific exemptions, reflecting a nuanced approach.

What are the highlights of the draft rules?

  1. Principles-Based Framework:
    • Emphasizes simplicity and clarity in notice and consent mechanisms.
    • Avoids burdensome details like indirect data acquisition notifications, as seen in the GDPR.
  2. Industry-Specific Exemptions:
    • Educational institutions, healthcare providers, and childcare centers are exempt from verifying parental consent for tracking and behavioral monitoring, provided they follow established guardrails.
  3. Focus on Practicality:
    • Prioritizes empowering users without overwhelming them or stifling business innovation.

What are the challenges in the draft rules?

  1. Data Localisation and Cross-Border Data Transfers:
    • Significant Data Fiduciaries (SDFs) may face localization mandates beyond the Act’s original intent.
    • Ambiguity around differentiated rules for SDFs and smaller entities creates risks of regulatory arbitrage.
  2. Ambiguities in User Requests:
    • Lacks provisions for verifying the legitimacy of user information requests.
    • Does not address excessive or unfounded requests or allow businesses to charge reasonable fees for such requests.
  3. Government Overreach:
    • Unclear if the government can demand access to sensitive business data.
    • No safeguards to protect such data from misuse or exposure as trade secrets.

How can the rules balance compliance and innovation?

  1. Learning from Sectoral Approaches:
    • The Reserve Bank of India’s 2018 payment data localization mandate effectively addressed security concerns without disrupting businesses.
    • A similar targeted approach could resolve cross-border data flow issues.
  2. Rethinking Consent-Based Privacy:
    • Reliance on notice-and-consent mechanisms is outdated, especially with the rise of IoT, AI, and 5G technologies.
    • India must develop privacy frameworks that account for dynamic and uncontrolled environments like malls or airports.
  3. Maintaining Flexibility:
    • Public consultations should refine the rules to preserve their flexibility and focus on industry-specific needs.

Why is compliance with data protection laws important?

  • Data breaches in India cost businesses an average of ₹19.5 crore ($2.35 million) in 2024, according to IBM.
  • Protecting personal data is crucial not only for regulatory compliance but also for preserving business reputation and continuity.

What should India focus on moving forward?

  • Prioritize procedural integrity to address ambiguities in user requests and government access to sensitive data.
  • Maintain a balanced framework that promotes innovation, protects individual rights, and ensures economic growth.
  • Move beyond consent-based mechanisms to establish robust, forward-looking privacy frameworks.

Discover more from Free UPSC IAS Preparation Syllabus and Materials For Aspirants

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community