[Answered] Constitutional sacredness rests upon reverence for democratic institutions and national symbols.” Elucidate with reference to constitutional morality and institutional accountability in India.

Introduction

Dr. B.R. Ambedkar cautioned that constitutional morality must be cultivated. India’s constitutional sacredness therefore lies not merely in its written provisions, but in respecting institutions, democratic processes and national symbols. Constitutional reverence means upholding the Constitution’s values through institutional integrity, civic responsibility and accountability rather than selective political invocation.

Foundations of Constitutional Sacredness

  1. Constitutional Morality: Ambedkar, drawing upon historian George Grote, emphasised reverence for constitutional procedures alongside freedom to criticise public authorities. Example: Constitutional restraint.
  2. Preamble Values: Justice, liberty, equality and fraternity provide a common ethical foundation transcending political, religious and regional divisions. Example: National fraternity.
  3. Fundamental Duties: Article 51A(a) makes respecting constitutional ideals, institutions, the National Flag and National Anthem a civic obligation. Example: Civic responsibility.
  4. Legal Protection: The Prevention of Insults to National Honour Act, 1971 and Flag Code, 2002 protect the dignity of national symbols. (Symbolic integrity).

Democratic Institutions as Custodians of Constitutional Trust

  1. Parliamentary Accountability: Legislative debate, Question Hour and committee scrutiny ensure executive answerability. During Monsoon Session 2026, Lok Sabha functioned for only 15% of scheduled time, reflecting the cost of disruptions. Example: Deliberative deficit.
  2. Electoral Integrity: Article 324 entrusts the Election Commission with superintendence and control of elections; transparent appointments and evidence-based grievance redress strengthen its credibility. Example: Anoop Baranwal, 2023.
  3. Judicial Independence: Kesavananda Bharati (1973) established the Basic Structure doctrine, protecting constitutional identity against arbitrary amendments. Example: Constitutional supremacy.
  4. Federal Balance: S.R. Bommai (1994) restricted arbitrary use of Article 356, reinforcing federalism and constitutional government. Example: Federal restraint.
  5. Audit and Transparency: CAG oversight and the RTI Act, 2005 strengthen financial accountability and citizens right to scrutinise public administration. Example: Public answerability.

Constitutional Morality Balancing Dissent, Decorum and Accountability

  1. Ethical Public Office: Manoj Narula v. Union of India (2014) emphasised constitutional morality and propriety in the exercise of public power. Example: Public-office ethics.
  2. Rights over Majoritarianism: Navtej Singh Johar (2018) affirmed constitutional morality over prevailing social morality, protecting individual dignity and equality. Example: Transformative constitutionalism.
  3. Legitimate Dissent: Article 19(1)(a) protects criticism of government and institutions; Section 2 of the 1971 Act also expressly safeguards lawful criticism of the Constitution and Flag. Example:  Democratic dissent.
  4. Historical Warning: The Emergency (1975–77) demonstrated how weakened institutional checks can undermine fundamental rights and democratic accountability. Example:  Institutional failure.

Institutional Accountability Converting Constitutional Ideals into Practice

  1. Independent Appointments: Anoop Baranwal (2023) highlighted the importance of an independent, consultative mechanism for appointing Election Commissioners.
  2. Regulatory Accountability: Economic Survey 2025-26 identifies transparency, procedural fairness and checks on concentrated regulatory powers as essential to institutional credibility.
  3. Judicial Capacity: Union Budget 2026-27 provides ₹1,200 crore for e-Courts Phase III, supporting digital access, transparency and efficient justice delivery.
  4. Political Responsibility: Competing campaigns such as Samvidhan Samman and Samvidhan Raksha should not reduce constitutional fidelity to partisan slogans. Example: Non-partisan constitutionalism.

Way Forward

  1. Strengthen Parliamentary Functioning & Committee Scrutiny: Mandate minimum annual sitting days, enforce anti-disruption norms, and refer bills routinely to Department-Related Parliamentary Standing Committees. Example: Standing Committee scrutiny.
  2. Ensure Transparent Appointments to Constitutional Bodies: Institutionalize broad-based, consensus-driven selection mechanisms for autonomous bodies (such as the ECI and CAG) to insulate them from political contestation. Example: Transparent ECI appointments.
  3. Promote Civic & Constitutional Literacy: Integrate Preamble values, Fundamental Duties (Article 51A), and respect for national symbols into school and civil service training modules. Example: Samvidhan Divas literacy.
  4. Enforce Self-Regulation Across Political Stakeholders: Adopt an inter-party code of conduct prohibiting unwarranted attacks on constitutional authorities and safeguarding the sanctity of national symbols. Example: Inter-party institutional code.

Conclusion

A Constitution survives not merely by the parchment on which it is written, but by the institutional rectitude and civic reverence of those who operate it. Upholding democratic institutions, constitutional morality, and national symbols in both letter and spirit is essential to deepen India’s constitutional democracy.

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community