Introduction
The historic November 2026 trilateral summit in Shenzhen bringing together Xi Jinping, Donald Trump, and Vladimir Putin on the sidelines of APEC has prompted Chinese strategic scholars to propose a Shenzhen International System. Framed as a modern counterpart to Westphalia or Yalta, Beijing seeks to institutionalize braking mechanisms to manage great-power rivalry without dismantling competition.
- Historical Analogy: Scholar Wang Wen likens Shenzhen to Westphalia and Yalta, claiming sovereignty, not spheres of influence. Example: Yalta comparison.
- Optics Over Substance: None of the three can achieve its objectives, so a substantive geopolitical reset is unlikely. Example: Photo-op summit.
- Co-management Claim: Seeking recognition as co-manager of global order reveals G-3 tendencies despite Beijing’s denials. Example: Co-manager prestige.
- Hedging Middle Powers: ASEAN’s Manila diplomacy shows states writing their own rules through multi-alignment.
- Economic Chokeholds: China’s supply-chain leverage and America’s protectionism sustain structured rivalry, not partnership. Example: Rare-earth leverage.
Strategic Braking Mechanisms by Managing Rivalry Without Ending It
- Institutionalizing Crisis-Management: Following the February 2026 expiration of the New START treaty, trilateral nuclear risk-reduction dialogues and AI-in-nuclear-command guardrails offer vital stabilization against inadvertent escalation. Example: Post-START nuclear guardrails.
- Regional Conflict Management: Dialogue on North Korea, Iran and Ukraine could provide diplomatic openings, although China’s reluctance to accept constraints on its expanding nuclear arsenal limits meaningful arms control. Example: Arms-control deficit.
- Risk of a Great-Power Condominium (New Yalta Syndrome): Excluding Britain and France, alongside non-permanent UNSC members, weakens collective decision-making and reinforces selective great-power privilege. Example: P5 marginalisation.
- Erosion of Sovereign Equality: Bargaining over Ukraine or Taiwan without affected countries contradicts Article 2(1) of the UN Charter, which establishes sovereign equality of states. Example: Sovereignty deficit.
- Geopolitical Realignment: China’s invocation of the 1945 anti-fascist alliance seeks to project itself as Washington’s partner in Asian security while potentially weakening the US-Japan alliance. Example: Alliance politics.
- Erosion of Multilateral & Legal Institutions: Joint declarations challenging the International Criminal Court (ICC) and selectively sidelining UNSC members (Britain, France, and non-permanent states) weaken rules-based multilateralism. Example: Rome Statute erosion.
- Asymmetric Strategic Gains for Beijing & Moscow: Hosting the summit legitimizes China as a co-manager of global order while ending Russia’s diplomatic isolation without substantive concessions on Ukraine. Example: Diplomatic legitimacy windfall.
India’s imperatives
- Preventing a Sino-American Bipolar or G-3 Hegemony: Any arrangement where Beijing co-directs Asian security threatens India’s continental-maritime balance and regional sovereignty. Example: Asian condominium risk.
- Leveraging Multi-Alignment Across Overlapping Forums: India’s simultaneous membership in the Quad, BRICS+, SCO, and G20 ensures New Delhi retains independent diplomatic leverage across both Western and Eurasian blocs. Example: Cross-bloc diplomatic leverage.
- Championing Inclusive Multilateral Reform: Countering exclusive big-power directorates requires accelerating UNSC permanent seat expansion and Bretton Woods governance reforms. Example: UNSC permanent expansion.
Way Forward
- Deepen Middle-Power Coalitions in the Indo-Pacific: Strengthen strategic convergence with Japan, Australia, ASEAN, and European powers (France, Germany) to ensure regional security architectures remain multipolar rather than G-3 dictated. Example: Indo-Pacific middle-power synergy.
- Anchor Global South Solidarity via Voice of Global South & BRICS: Use BRICS+ and G20 platforms to resist transactional great-power trade-offs that compromise developing nations’ developmental and security interests. Example: Global South consensus.
- Advocate Inclusive Arms Control & AI Governance Norms: Push for transparent, multilateral verification frameworks on emerging military technologies and nuclear risk reduction at the UN Conference on Disarmament. Example: Multilateral AI guardrails.
- Accelerate Domestic Comprehensive National Power (CNP): Fast-track indigenous defense manufacturing, critical mineral resilience, and semiconductor self-reliance to insulate India from external geopolitical shifts. Example: Indigenous defense self-reliance.
Conclusion
While crisis-management braking mechanisms among nuclear powers are welcome for global stability, a durable 21st-century international order cannot be designed by three capitals alone. By championing reformed multilateralism, strategic autonomy, and Global South representation, India can ensure global governance evolves toward genuine multipolarity.

