India-Afghanistan Relationship - Significance & Challenges

The recent visit of the Afghan Taliban government’s Foreign Minister in India has been described as unprecedented & groundbreaking by several geopolitics experts. It is the Taliban’s highest-level visit to India since seizing power in 2021. In this regard, let us understand the significance & challenges in the India-Afghanistan relationship.

Table of Content

Introduction
What is the historical background of Indo-Afghan Relations?
Significance of India-Afghanistan Relationship
What are the areas of engagement between India- Afghanistan?
Challenges in India-Afghanistan Relations
What should be the way forward in India-Afghan Relationship?

Introduction:

India-Afghanistan relations have been shaped by geography, history, and strategic interests. Afghanistan has historically served as a bridge between South Asia and Central Asia, fostering trade, cultural exchanges, and political alliances. However, its geopolitical significance has also made it a hotspot for great power rivalries.
In recent years, India has emerged as a key partner in Afghanistan’s development and stabilization efforts. The return of the Taliban in 2021 marked a significant turning point, prompting India to recalibrate its policy to safeguard its strategic interests and historical ties.
Since Taliban’s takeover in 2021, India has maintained a limited diplomatic presence while focusing primarily on humanitarian and people-to-people assistance.

What is the historical background of Indo-Afghan Relations?

Ancient Links and Cultural Exchange	Indus Valley Civilization: Indo-Afghan relations trace back to the Indus Valley Civilization, with trade and cultural exchanges flourishing between the two regions. Silk Road Connection: Afghanistan’s position on the Silk Road facilitated trade and cultural exchanges between India and Central Asia. Shared Heritage: The Gandhara civilization, based in modern-day Afghanistan, influenced Indian art and culture, notably in Buddhist sculptures like the Bamiyan Buddhas. Religious and Epic References: Ancient Indian texts like the Mahabharata and Rigveda mention Afghanistan, underscoring longstanding ties. Emperor Ashoka’s efforts to spread Buddhism to Afghanistan further highlight historical connections.
Medieval Period and Islamic Empires	Durrani Empire: Under Ahmad Shah Durrani in the mid-18th century, Afghanistan became a regional power influencing Indo-Afghan ties. Mughal Empire: Afghan rulers like Babur, the founder of the Mughal Empire, shaped Indian history, bringing Indo-Persian art, architecture, and literature into India.
British Period (19th-20th Century)	Anglo-Afghan Wars: British India’s attempts to control Afghanistan as a buffer state against Russia strained regional dynamics. Partition of India: Post-1947, Afghanistan refused to recognize Pakistan’s creation, supporting Pashtun autonomy and influencing Indo-Afghan relations.
Post-Independence and Cold War Period	1947-1979: India maintained friendly ties with Afghanistan, formalized by the Indo-Afghan Friendship Treaty (1950). Soviet Invasion (1979-1989): India supported Soviet-backed Afghan governments, while Pakistan and the U.S. aided Mujahideen forces. Kandahar Hijacking Incident (1999): The hijacking of Indian Airlines Flight 814 highlighted security concerns with the Taliban regime.
Post-Taliban Era (2001-Present)	Strategic Partnership: India invested heavily in Afghanistan’s reconstruction, funding infrastructure projects like the Zaranj-Delaram Highway and Afghan Parliament Building. Challenges Post-2021: The Taliban’s return has strained relations, forcing India to evacuate its embassy and recalibrate its approach. New Beginning: India has reopened its embassy in Kabul and established direct contact with the Taliban government, while pursuing an “engagement without recognition” policy due to ongoing concerns about governance and rights.

Significance of India-Afghanistan Relationship:

For India:

Geostrategic Significance	Gateway to Central Asia: Afghanistan serves as a vital link for India’s access to energy-rich Central Asia, bypassing Pakistan. Countering Pakistan’s Influence: A stable Afghanistan reduces Pakistan’s strategic depth, supporting India’s geopolitical interests. Chabahar Port Connectivity: India’s investment in Iran’s Chabahar Port facilitates trade with Afghanistan, circumventing Pakistan.
Regional Security	Terrorism Concerns: Afghanistan’s stability directly impacts India’s security, especially concerning cross-border terrorism and groups like the Haqqani network. Taliban-Pakistan Nexus: A Taliban-dominated Afghanistan raises fears of increased Pakistani influence and destabilization in Kashmir.
Economic Significance	Trade and Transit: India-Afghanistan air freight corridors and the Chabahar Port boost bilateral trade. Natural Resources: Afghanistan’s rich reserves of minerals like lithium, copper, and rare earths present opportunities for India.

For Afghanistan:

Major Development Partner: India has invested over $3 billion in 500+ infrastructure and community projects, including dams, roads, hospitals, and schools, offering education, health, and livelihood benefits to Afghans.
Humanitarian Assistance: India provides regular emergency aid—food, medicines, disaster relief—and is respected for help during crises, including earthquakes and pandemic response.
Trade Potential: India is a major export destination for Afghanistan, and supports trade links through air corridors and Chabahar Port.
Scholarships: Thousands of Afghan students pursue higher education in India with scholarship support, strengthening people-to-people links.

What are the areas of engagement between India- Afghanistan?

Developmental Assistance	Infrastructure Projects: Zaranj-Delaram Highway: Connects Afghanistan to the Iranian border. Salma Dam (Afghan-India Friendship Dam): A major hydroelectric and irrigation project in Herat province. Afghan Parliament Building: A major symbol of democratic friendship, built and gifted by India in Kabul. Healthcare and Education: India has built hospitals and provided scholarships for Afghan students. Capacity Building: India provided training to thousands of Afghan students, civil servants, and military officers, helping to build the country’s institutional capacity.
Trade and Economic Relations	Air Freight Corridor: Facilitates direct trade bypassing Pakistan. Chabahar Port: Enhances Afghanistan’s connectivity to global markets.
Regional Security and Counter-terrorism	Capacity Building: India trains Afghan security forces to counter terrorism. Taliban Dynamics: India cautiously engages with the Taliban, focusing on its security concerns.
Humanitarian Assistance	Crisis Support: India has provided food grains and COVID-19 vaccines to Afghanistan. Community Projects: Over 200 programs, including schools and water supply systems, have been implemented.

Challenges in India-Afghanistan Relations:

Political Instability in Afghanistan:
- Taliban Takeover (2021): The lack of an inclusive government complicates bilateral ties.
- Uncertain Governance: India’s projects face risks under the Taliban regime.
Security and Pakistan Factor:
- Strategic Depth Doctrine: Pakistan’s influence over the Taliban undermines India’s interests.
- Cross-Border Terrorism: Taliban-Pakistan ties threaten Kashmir’s stability.
Geographic Connectivity Barrier:
- Geographic Disconnect: India lacks direct land access to Afghanistan.
- Limited Air Corridors: Air freight corridors are not a comprehensive solution.
Drug trafficking: Afghanistan is the world’s largest producer of opium, and the drug trade has contributed to instability and violence in the region, affecting both India and Afghanistan.

What should be the way forward in India-Afghan Relationship?

Sustain Diplomatic Engagement while Withholding Formal Recognition:
- Maintain a functional full embassy, regular high-level exchanges, and technical partnerships, without immediate formal recognition of the Taliban.
- Uphold conditional engagement, demanding assurances against the use of Afghan territory for terrorism targeting India, and keeping dialogue channels open for real-time intelligence sharing and security cooperation.
Expand Targeted Development and Humanitarian Diplomacy:
- Continue needs-based development projects (healthcare, water, rural infrastructure, education), responding to urgent Afghan requirements and building grassroots goodwill.
- Invest in humanitarian aid (food, medicine, earthquake support) and publicly visible projects to counter Chinese and Pakistani influence, reinforce soft power, and stabilize communities.
Strengthen Counter-terrorism Cooperation:
- Institutionalize intelligence exchange, joint investigations, and security sector capacity-building based on India’s 2011 Strategic Partnership Agreement with Afghanistan.
- Intensify cross-border anti-narcotics collaboration and border management to tackle trafficking and radicalization risks.
Secure Economic Connectivity & Cooperation:
- Expand alternative trade and transit corridors, notably via Chabahar Port, revitalize the Air Freight Corridor, and develop resource-sector partnerships with robust contractual safeguards.
- Explore investments in minerals, water resource management, and sectoral modernization to create mutual incentives for regional stability.
Balance Principles & Realpolitik:
- Engage with the regime on the basis of practical security and development needs, without losing sight of India’s advocacy for inclusive governance, minority protection, and women’s rights.
- Use multilateral forums to pressure for more inclusive policies and broader international engagement.

Conclusion: A patient, pragmatic, and principled approach—with robust humanitarian aid, targeted development diplomacy, and strategic cooperation—will safeguard Indian interests and support Afghanistan’s peace, progress, and stability in a volatile region.

UPSC GS-2: International Relations
Read More: The Hindu