- SFG 2027 Level-1 starts 21 Dec. 2026 at 7 AM | Entrance Test on 22 Nov. at 9:30 AM Click Here to know more →
- Interview Guidance initiative by ForumIAS – UPSC CSE 2026 Click Here to know more →
- FRC 2027: SFG Residential program | accepting application for Tranche-2 Click Here to know more →
UPSC Syllabus: Gs Paper 3- Employment
Introduction
The growing adoption of Artificial Intelligence (AI) and investments in AI infrastructure have increased concerns over job security. Layoffs affect workers across sectors, causing loss of regular income and employee benefits, including family health insurance. This raises important questions about severance pay, unemployment assistance and social security. India’s labour reforms seek to address these concerns, but significant gaps remain in worker protection.
Understanding Layoffs and Retrenchment in India
- Terminology in Different Countries: The term layoff is commonly used in Western countries, particularly the United States, to describe job loss. In India, retrenchment is commonly used for employer-initiated termination of employment.
- Legal Meaning of Layoff in India: Under Indian labour law, layoff refers to an employer’s temporary inability to provide work due to specified circumstances. It does not terminate the employment relationship between the employer and the worker.
- Difference Between Layoff and Retrenchment: Layoff involves temporary suspension of work without ending employment, whereas retrenchment involves termination of employment. Both situations have different legal implications for workers.
- Impact Across Employment Sectors: Layoffs affect workers in coal mining, technology companies and government services, irrespective of their economic activities. Workers face uncertainty about future employment, family responsibilities and loss of workplace access.
- Differences Between Blue-Collar and White-Collar Workers: White-collar workers are generally expected to depend on their professional skills, while low-skilled and semi-skilled workers may migrate between companies. However, specialised skills may also restrict employment opportunities for white-collar workers.
- Role of Employment Contracts: Employment protection in India also depends on whether workers are trainees, contract workers or permanent employees. The nature of the employment relationship influences their job security and available protections.
Legal Framework for Layoff Protection
- Four Labour Codes: The government consolidated 29 existing labour laws into four Labour Codes to simplify labour regulations. These are the Code on Wages, 2019; Industrial Relations Code, 2020; Code on Social Security, 2020; and Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code, 2020.
- Earlier Legal Framework – Industrial Disputes Act, 1947: The Industrial Disputes Act (ID Act) provided the earlier legal framework for layoffs and retrenchment. Section 2(kkk) defined layoff as an employer’s failure, refusal or inability to provide work to a worker.
- New Legal Framework – Industrial Relations Code, 2020: The Industrial Relations Code (IR Code) replaced the Industrial Disputes Act and consolidated provisions relating to industrial relations, layoffs and retrenchment. The four Labour Codes came into force on 21 November 2025.
- Conditions Constituting Layoff: The new framework retains the concept of temporary inability to provide employment without ending the employment relationship. Shortage of raw materials, power cuts, machinery breakdowns, natural calamities and accumulated stocks are recognised grounds.
- Compensation for Laid-Off Workers: Under Section 67, workers completing at least one year of continuous service receive 50% of basic wages and dearness allowance for each day of layoff. Compensation is limited to 45 days within 12 months, subject to prescribed conditions.
- Prior Government Permission: Under Section 78, establishments employing 300 or more workers require prior government permission before implementing layoffs. Exceptions include shortages of power and natural calamities, while smaller establishments must maintain muster rolls and pay applicable compensation.
- Recognition of Non-Traditional Workers: The Labour Codes recognise gig, platform and informal workers within the broader social security framework. State governments are also developing laws to protect these workers, while the e-Shram portal collects their registration data.
Major Concerns and Challenges in Layoff Protection
- Limited Sectoral Coverage: The discussion identifies coal mining, plantations and manufacturing as the sectors covered by the relevant layoff protections. Service-sector, Information Technology (IT) and informal workers remain outside these particular protections.
- Inadequacy of One-Time Severance Pay: Employers generally prefer paying compensation in one instalment and closing employment matters. However, workers also lose regular income and employee benefits, including family health insurance.
- Taxation of Severance Pay: The government treats severance pay as profit in lieu of salary, attracting taxation similar to salary income. Certain previously non-taxable components of severance agreements are also taxable under income from other sources.
- Absence of Unemployment Assistance: India lacks a comprehensive unemployment relief system to support workers after job losses. Traditionally, joint families provided financial support, but vulnerable workers need wider government assistance.
- Limited Reach of Employees’ State Insurance: The Employees’ State Insurance (ESI) scheme provides insurance coverage to workers and their families. However, ESI hospitals remain disproportionately fewer compared with the number of beneficiaries.
- Challenges in Gig and Platform Worker Protection: The absence of a traditional employer-employee relationship makes compensation for lost earning opportunities difficult. Inconsistent earnings also create challenges in designing suitable income protection arrangements.
- Weak Implementation of Labour Laws: Existing social security infrastructure faces administrative and governance challenges. Inadequate implementation reduces the effectiveness of available worker protection mechanisms.
Way Forward
- Introduce Unemployment Assistance: The government should establish an unemployment relief system using tax revenues to support vulnerable workers. This can provide financial security during unemployment and income loss.
- Adopt Suitable International Models: Germany provides earnings-linked unemployment insurance, calculating benefits as a percentage of previous earnings. The United States uses payroll taxes and employer experience ratings, while the United Kingdom and Singapore follow different approaches.
- Develop Insurance-Based Protection: Existing insurance facilities should be extended to workers facing unemployment and income losses. International practices should be adapted to Indian economic conditions and employment requirements.
- Introduce Shared Insurance Contributions: Gig workers could voluntarily contribute small premiums to insure against potential revenue losses. Aggregators and customers could also contribute towards these insurance funds to share financial responsibility.
- Expand Employer Responsibilities: Employers should provide counselling, legal assistance, retraining, testimonials and employment exchange registration support. These measures can help retrenched workers prepare for new employment rather than relying only on compensation.
- Strengthen Social Security Delivery: The government should bring vulnerable workers into the traditional social security network and improve coordination between citizens and government agencies. Wider ESI infrastructure and effective implementation are essential for reaching beneficiaries.
- Promote Skill Development: Labour market governance should give greater importance to the Ministry of Skill Development. Retraining and skill development can help displaced workers adapt to changing employment requirements and find new opportunities.
Conclusion
India needs to move beyond one-time severance payments towards comprehensive unemployment and social security protection. Extending insurance, providing unemployment assistance and strengthening skill development can support displaced workers. Effective implementation of labour laws and coordination among government agencies are equally important. The objective should be income security and protection across formal, informal and emerging employment sectors.
Question for practice:
Examine the legal protections available to workers facing layoffs in India and the challenges in ensuring comprehensive social security.
Source: The Hindu



