Turning Police Reform into Practice

sfg-2026
ForumIAS LATEST
      1. SFG 2027 Level-1 starts 21 Dec. 2026 at 7 AM | Entrance Test on 22 Nov. at 9:30 AM Click Here to know more →
      2. Interview Guidance initiative by ForumIAS – UPSC CSE 2026 Click Here to know more →
      3. FRC 2027: SFG Residential program | accepting application for Tranche-2 Click Here to know more →

UPSC Syllabus: Gs Paper 2- Constitution of India

Introduction

Police reform in India requires changes in laws, institutions and everyday police station practices. Citizens face delays in complaint registration, fear of harassment and poor communication regarding their complaints. Police personnel also work under heavy workloads and inadequate rest arrangements. The Indian Police Foundation (IPF) has initiated internal reforms to address these concerns through practical, low-cost measures across four key areas of policing.

Need for Police Reforms

  1. Shortage of Police Personnel: India’s police strength stood at 152.80 personnel per lakh population, against the sanctioned strength of 196.23 as of January 2022. This remains below the United Nations (UN) recommended standard of 222, increasing workloads and delaying investigations.
  2. Poor Working Conditions of Constabulary: The constabulary constitutes approximately 86% of state police forces, but faces limited promotion opportunities and inadequate housing facilities. Poor working conditions reduce motivation and affect the overall functioning of police stations.
  3. Political Interference and Limited Operational Freedom: The Second Administrative Reforms Commission (Second ARC, 2007) observed that political interference affects professional police decisions. It can encourage biased policing and weaken accountability, particularly in sensitive appointments such as that of the Director General of Police (DGP).
  4. Centre-State Tensions and IPS-Related Issues: The centrally conceived and managed Indian Police Service (IPS) system has faced criticism from states preferring their own recruits. Public preference for Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) investigations also reflects limited confidence in state police, creating Centre-State tensions.
  5. Lack of Diversity and Public Trust: The Status of Policing in India Report, 2022, highlighted inadequate representation across caste, class, religion and gender. Women constituted only 11.7% of police personnel in January 2022, while a 2018 Centre for the Study of Developing Societies (CSDS) survey found fewer than 25% trusted the police.
  6. Colonial Laws and Police Misconduct: The Police Act, 1861 reflects a colonial approach focused on controlling people rather than serving citizens. Corruption, harassment and custodial violence weaken public confidence, while effective mechanisms for addressing complaints against erring personnel remain inadequate.
  7. Inadequate Infrastructure and Investigation Capacity: Police forces face shortages of weapons, surveillance vehicles and communication facilities, alongside poor utilisation of modernisation funds. The 22nd Law Commission noted that the conviction rate for Indian Penal Code (IPC) offences was below 50%, while the Asian Centre for Human Rights (ACHR) reported 144 custodial deaths during 2017–2018.

Four Key Areas of Internal Reforms

A. Improving Complaint Registration and Police Response

  1. Simplifying Complaint Registration: Visitor Management Systems (VMS) can maintain digital visitor records, while help desks can reduce unnecessary delays. QR codes at police stations can make complaint registration and access to services easier.
  2. Strengthening e-FIR Implementation: The Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS) introduced the concept of electronic First Information Reports (e-FIRs), implemented in Delhi. However, converting e-complaints into regular FIRs after obtaining complainants’ signatures remains a challenge.
  3. Addressing Property-Related Complaints: Recording e-complaints solely to facilitate insurance claims is insufficient for addressing property-related offences. Such complaints require proper police attention and follow-up through regular investigation procedures.

B.Strengthening Crime Prevention, Community Outreach and Citizen Services

  1. Improving Women’s Safety: Introduce night safety escort services for working women and make QR codes and panic buttons mandatory in taxis. These facilities should connect directly with district control rooms for quicker assistance.
  2. Expanding Technology-Based Surveillance: Increase Closed-Circuit Television (CCTV) coverage and connect cameras with district control centres. Body-worn cameras and dashboard cameras can also improve police accountability and incident recording.
  3. Promoting Community Participation: Introduce citizen sentinel schemes and strengthen engagement at beat and police station levels. Student internships with police can encourage public participation and improve cooperation with law enforcement.
  4. Supporting Vulnerable Groups: Provide skill training to school drop-outs and people affected by drug addiction. Such initiatives can strengthen community outreach and support crime prevention through local participation.

C. Preventing Police Misconduct and Harassment

  1. Strengthening Oversight of Arrests: Reasons for arrest should undergo scrutiny at the Deputy Superintendent of Police (DySP) level. This can strengthen supervision over arrest decisions and discourage unnecessary arrests.
  2. Protecting Rights of Arrested Persons: Allow arrested persons to make a phone call and inform them about their right to free legal aid. Investigating officers must also follow mandatory legal provisions governing arrests.
  3. Standardising Personal Searches: Establish uniform procedures for personal searches and use videography to prevent the loss of personal valuables. This can improve transparency and protect the property of arrested persons.
  4. Monitoring Police Lock-ups: Senior officers should monitor police lock-ups remotely through online systems. Regular supervision can help identify misconduct and improve compliance with safeguards for detained persons.

D. Improving Police Station Working Conditions

  1. Providing Basic Facilities and Rest: Police stations should have adequate rest rooms and ensure weekly days off for personnel. These facilities can improve working conditions and support better performance.
  2. Strengthening Investigation Resources: Provide sufficient transport facilities or vehicle allowances to investigating officers for quicker responses. Police stations should also receive adequate contingency funds for purchasing investigation materials.
  3. Providing Digital Investigation Tools: Every investigating officer should receive a tablet or equivalent device to use the e-Sakshya application. This can support digital evidence collection and investigation procedures.

4. Improving Recruitment and Skill Development: Establish recruitment boards and conduct periodic soft-skill training for police personnel. Police e-academies should support continuous learning, with training linked to career progression.

  1. Empowering Constabulary: Constables should receive opportunities to participate in investigation work rather than remaining restricted to routine duties. Greater involvement can improve their skills and strengthen police station functioning.

Institutional and Policy-Level Reforms: Recommendations of Committees and Expert Bodies

  1. Gore Committee (1971–1973): It recommended expanding police training beyond law and order and crime prevention. Training should develop greater sensitivity and understanding of human behaviour.
  2. National Police Commission (1977): It recommended insulating police from illegitimate political and bureaucratic interference. This would protect professional decision-making and improve police autonomy.
  3. Padmanabhaiah Committee (2000): It recommended standardising police recruitment and training procedures while improving constabulary recruitment criteria, salaries and allowances. It also emphasised improvements in police behaviour, investigation and prosecution.
  4. Malimath Committee (2003): It recommended comprehensive criminal procedure reforms and a separate national authority for crimes threatening national security. It also proposed a compensation fund for victims who turn hostile under pressure from offenders.
  5. Soli Sorabjee Committee (2005) and Second ARC (2007): The Soli Sorabjee Committee proposed a Model Police Act to replace the colonial Police Act, 1861. The Second ARC recommended separating crime investigation from law-and-order duties and establishing state police boards for personnel welfare and grievance redressal.
  6. Supreme Court Directives in Prakash Singh Case (2006): The Supreme Court issued seven directives covering State Security Commissions, DGP selection and tenure, minimum tenure for operational officers, separation of investigation from law and order, Police Establishment Boards, Police Complaints Authorities and a National Security Commission. These aim to improve police autonomy and accountability.
  7. Standing Committee on Home Affairs (2022): It recommended modernising police training through artificial intelligence, robotics, drones, forensic sciences and updated laws. It also proposed training on detainee rights, tribal customs, common training modules, university partnerships and online libraries for police academies.
  8. 8. NITI Aayog Recommendations: NITI Aayog suggested fiscal incentives for adopting the Model Police Act, 2015, and outsourcing non-core functions to reduce police workloads. It also recommended greater women’s representation and placing police and public order in the Concurrent List to address inter-state crime and terrorism through a unified framework.

Significance of Police Reforms

  1. Improving Public Trust: Faster complaint registration, accessible police services and effective grievance redressal can improve citizens’ confidence. Transparent procedures can also strengthen police-public relations.
  2. Strengthening Human Rights Protection: Proper arrest procedures, legal aid and independent monitoring can reduce custodial violence and deaths. These safeguards are particularly important for protecting disadvantaged and vulnerable sections.
  3. Improving Crime Investigation: Modern training, forensic facilities and digital investigation tools can improve evidence collection. These capabilities can help police tackle cyberespionage, deepfakes and online financial fraud.
  4. Promoting Inclusive and Gender-Sensitive Policing: Greater women’s representation and community-based safety services can make policing more responsive. These measures can improve police sensitivity towards women and vulnerable groups.
  5. Strengthening Internal Security: Modern technology, better coordination and specialised investigation skills can strengthen the police response to organised crime, terrorism, naxalism and separatism. Effective policing is essential for maintaining public order and national security.

Conclusion

Effective police reform requires translating policy recommendations into routine practices at police stations. The IPF change manual provides a phased approach, starting with Punjab, followed by Telangana and Tamil Nadu. Its wider adoption should depend on implementation outcomes and acceptance. This can help build police services that are accessible, accountable and responsive to citizens.

Question for practice:

Discuss the key challenges facing the Indian police system and examine the major reforms required to make policing more efficient, accountable and citizen-centric.

Source: The Hindu

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community