- SFG 2027 Level-1 starts 21 Dec. 2026 at 7 AM | Entrance Test on 22 Nov. at 9:30 AM Click Here to know more →
- Interview Guidance initiative by ForumIAS – UPSC CSE 2026 Click Here to know more →
- FRC 2027: SFG Residential program | accepting application for Tranche-2 Click Here to know more →
UPSC Syllabus: Gs Paper 2- International Relation
Introduction
The proposed Shenzhen International System, involving the United States, China and Russia, raises concerns about the future of global multilateralism. Their growing preference for great-power diplomacy could marginalise emerging nations and weaken inclusive decision-making. India cannot take its rise as a global power for granted and must build a collective fourth pole based on sovereignty, strategic autonomy and international cooperation.
Changing Global Order: Growing Dominance of Great-Power Politics
- Emergence of Personalised Diplomacy: The leaders of the United States, China and Russia favour direct engagement, personalised leadership and transactional bargaining over established diplomatic processes.
- China’s Expanding Global Influence: Under Xi Jinping, China has expanded its global role through BRICS, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) and the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).
- Russia’s Opposition to the US-led Order: Russia has challenged the existing international order through military and diplomatic means, including Crimea’s annexation in 2014 and its invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
- America’s Shift Towards Unilateralism: Donald Trump’s America First policy, tariff wars and criticism of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) have weakened America’s traditional commitment to multilateral cooperation.
- Declining Institutional Cooperation: Direct negotiations among powerful leaders increasingly replace collective deliberation, common norms and inclusive decision-making through international institutions.
- Creation of a New Global Hierarchy: The exclusive participation of three major powers in important negotiations risks replacing the existing international hierarchy with another dominated by powerful states.
- Marginalisation of Affected Nations: Discussing Ukraine’s future without Ukraine and other European powers risks normalising decisions on international conflicts without consulting affected countries.
- Marginalisation of International Institutions: Exclusive negotiations among powerful leaders could weaken the role of international institutions in resolving conflicts and establishing global norms.
Implications of the Shenzhen System for India’s Strategic Interests
- Marginalisation in Global Decision-making: Exclusive coordination among three permanent United Nations Security Council (UNSC) members could reduce India’s influence over major international decisions and global governance.
- China’s Growing Strategic Advantage: China’s recognition as a co-manager of global affairs could strengthen its geopolitical influence, particularly in India’s neighbourhood and South Asia.
- Border Security Concerns: A possible United States-China understanding could reduce external pressure on Beijing and affect India’s strategic calculations along the Line of Actual Control (LAC).
- Changing Strategic Partnerships: Improved United States-China relations could affect India-US cooperation in the Indo-Pacific, while US-Russia rapprochement could change India’s defence and energy engagement with Moscow.
- Uncertainty over Regional Groupings: Changes in American strategic priorities towards China could influence the Quad’s relevance, functioning and future objectives.
- Challenges to India’s Global Representation: A stronger understanding among three permanent Security Council members could further complicate India’s efforts to secure permanent membership of the UNSC.
- Economic and Supply-chain Uncertainty: Changing US-China relations could reshape manufacturing networks and trade flows, affecting India’s opportunity to become an alternative global manufacturing hub.
- Technology and Energy Vulnerabilities: Cooperation among major powers on Artificial Intelligence (AI) and semiconductors could influence global standards, while changing US-Russia relations could affect oil prices and India’s energy security.
India’s Vision: Building a Collective Fourth Pole
- A Collective of Strategically Autonomous Nations: India should bring together countries from Japan, Taiwan, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Ukraine, Germany, the Philippines and Brazil that seek sovereignty, peace and independent decision-making.
- Common Commitment to Sovereignty: The proposed collective should oppose expansionism, protect national sovereignty and reject international decisions imposed without proper consultation.
- India’s Leadership Through Trust: India should build partnerships through mutual respect and shared interests rather than relying solely on its population, civilisational heritage or historical standing.
- Diplomacy of Conscience and Civilian Protection: India should oppose mass civilian casualties, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity. Its mediation efforts, including on Ukraine, should prioritise civilian protection amid conflicts that have claimed nearly half a million lives in five years.
Way Forward: Diplomatic and Strategic Measures
A. Strengthening Diplomacy and Multilateral Cooperation
- Preserve Strategic Autonomy: India should maintain independent foreign-policy decisions and follow an issue-based approach towards major powers without joining exclusive geopolitical blocs.
- Strengthen Multi-alignment: India should deepen partnerships with the United States, Russia, France, Japan, Australia and other countries while avoiding excessive dependence on any single power.
- Rebuild Multilateral Presence: India should strengthen its role in the United Nations and consider hosting important United Nations and associated multilateral agencies.
- Support Global South Representation: India should promote equitable representation of developing countries and strengthen cooperation through BRICS, G20 and the Voice of Global South Summit.
- Strengthen International Law: India should lead the proposed collective in signing and ratifying important international instruments, including the Convention Against Torture and the Refugee Convention.
B. Strengthening Economic and Technological Capabilities
- Strengthen Economic Foundations: India’s low per capita income and deepening inequality could delay its emergence as an economic power. Sustained economic development is necessary to support its global ambitions.
- Diversify Critical Supply Chains: India should reduce dependence on individual countries for critical minerals, semiconductors, electronics and pharmaceuticals while developing reliable manufacturing capabilities.
- Achieve Technological Sovereignty: India should invest in indigenous Artificial Intelligence, quantum computing, semiconductors, space and telecommunications to reduce technological dependence and protect strategic autonomy.
C. Strengthening Defence and Strategic Security
- Achieve Defence Self-reliance: India should accelerate domestic defence manufacturing and research to reduce dependence on foreign suppliers and strengthen its military capabilities.
- Enhance Maritime Security: India should strengthen naval capabilities, maritime domain awareness and coastal surveillance while expanding security cooperation with Quad partners.
- Strengthen Border Infrastructure: India should improve connectivity, surveillance, logistics and military preparedness along the Line of Actual Control and western borders to maintain credible deterrence.
- Promote Nuclear Strategic Stability: Like-minded nuclear powers should develop common rules governing strategic arsenal growth and explore the possibility of a joint nuclear umbrella.
Conclusion
India’s rise as a global power requires sustained economic development, military self-reliance and credible diplomacy. By bringing strategically autonomous nations together, India can build a collective fourth pole. This will help protect national sovereignty, strengthen inclusive multilateralism and give emerging nations a greater role in shaping the global order.
Question for practice:
Examine how India can build a collective fourth pole to protect its strategic interests and strengthen multilateralism in the emerging global order.
Source: The Hindu; Indian Express



