- SFG 2027 Level-1 starts 21 Dec. 2026 at 7 AM | Entrance Test on 22 Nov. at 9:30 AM Click Here to know more →
- Interview Guidance initiative by ForumIAS – UPSC CSE 2026 Click Here to know more →
- FRC 2027: SFG Residential program | accepting application for Tranche-2 Click Here to know more →
Source: The post “Why counting farm fires is not enough to measure the scale of stubble burning” has been created based on “Why counting farm fires is not enough to measure the scale of stubble burning” published in “Indian Express” on 21st November 2026.
UPSC Syllabus: GS 2–Governance
Context: Stubble burning is a major contributor to air pollution across the Indo-Gangetic Plain, particularly during the post-monsoon period. The narrow 10–20-day window between paddy harvesting and wheat sowing (generally October to mid-November) encourages farmers to burn crop residue. According to the Indian Institute of Tropical Meteorology (IITM), stubble burning can contribute more than 30% of Delhi’s PM2.5 pollution during the peak season. Although satellites recorded 16,070 farm-fire incidents across northern India during the current kharif harvesting season (2026), the actual extent of burning could be higher.
Existing mechanism for monitoring farm fires
- India primarily relies on daily thermal-anomaly observations, which detect significant deviations in the average temperature of a particular area.
- These observations are captured by polar-orbiting satellites such as Aqua, Suomi-NPP and Terra, operated by US agencies including NASA and NOAA.
- The major sensors used are:
- VIIRS (Visible Infrared Imaging Radiometer Suite): Installed on Suomi-NPP, it provides a spatial resolution of 375 metres and passes over the region at approximately 1:30 PM.
- MODIS (Moderate Resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer): Installed on Aqua, it provides a comparatively coarser resolution of approximately 1 km. Changes in Aqua’s orbit since 2023 have shifted its overpass from 1:30 PM to approximately 4 PM, allowing it to capture some later fires.
- The fire-count data is used by IITM to estimate crop-residue burning emissions and prepare air-quality assessments and forecasts for Delhi-NCR. These estimates also influence decisions regarding the implementation of the Graded Response Action Plan (GRAP).
Limitations of satellite-based monitoring
- Fixed observation windows: Most satellite observations take place between 10:30 AM and 1:30 PM, resulting in the under-reporting of fires occurring during late afternoon and evening.
- Short duration of fires: Agricultural fires often last for less than 30 minutes and may occur entirely between two satellite overpasses.
- Small-scale and partial burning: Small fires and partial burning, particularly common in parts of Haryana, produce weaker thermal signals that satellites may fail to detect.
- Changing burning patterns: A November 2025 study by ISRO’s Space Applications Centre, Ahmedabad, documented a shift in peak farm-burning activity towards late afternoon and evening in Punjab and Haryana.
- Evidence of changing fire patterns: A study using South Korea’s GEO-KOMPSAT-2A satellite found a sharp increase in farm fires around and after 4 PM.
- The trend has gradually developed since 2022.
- It also found that aerosol pollution over the Indo-Gangetic Plain increased between 2022 and 2025, even as official satellite fire counts declined.
- Cloud cover: Clouds over northern states obstruct satellite observations and lead to fewer detected fires, as regularly highlighted in the Indian Agricultural Research Institute’s daily bulletins.
- Underestimation of incidents: A 2019 study by researchers mainly affiliated with Columbia University found that the MODIS active-fire product missed more than 90% of fires in northwest India.
About burnt-area (BA) mapping and its importance
- Measures actual affected area: Unlike active-fire monitoring, which identifies thermal anomalies at the time of satellite observation, burnt-area mapping identifies changes in the land surface left behind after a fire.
- Longer detection period: Stubble burning changes the way the ground reflects sunlight, particularly in near-infrared and shortwave-infrared wavelengths. These changes, known as burn signatures, remain detectable even after smoke plumes have subsided.
- Use of spectral indices: Two important indices are:
- Normalised Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI): Measures the greenness of vegetation.
- Normalised Burn Ratio (NBR): Compares near-infrared and shortwave-infrared reflectance. A decline in NBR can indicate vegetation damage and a burnt or exposed surface.
- Before-and-after comparison: Researchers compare satellite images taken before and after a suspected fire to identify changes in these indices and estimate the affected area.
- Improved spatial resolution: European Space Agency’s Sentinel-2 satellites provide imagery at resolutions of up to 10 metres in some spectral bands and revisit an area every five days. These satellites are being used for internal burnt-area mapping assessments in India.
Evidence that fire counts alone are inadequate
- The assessment by the International Forum for Environment, Sustainability and Technology (iFOREST) highlighted a mismatch between recorded fire incidents and burnt areas.
- In Haryana, farm-fire incidents declined substantially, but the estimated burnt area increased.
- In Punjab, fire incidents declined considerably, whereas the burnt area declined by a much smaller proportion.
- This demonstrates that a decline in recorded fire counts does not necessarily indicate a proportionate reduction in the actual extent of stubble burning.
Challenges in burnt-area mapping
- Difficulty in distinguishing burnt and harvested land: Harvesting itself changes the spectral signature of agricultural fields by exposing soil and crop residue, which can resemble burn signatures.
- Small and less intense fires: Crop-residue fires involve less biomass and are generally smaller and less intense than wildfires. Consequently, medium-resolution sensors such as MODIS and Sentinel-3 are less sensitive to agricultural fires.
- Short agricultural cycle: The narrow interval between harvesting and the next sowing season makes burnt-area assessment difficult.
- Changing burn signatures: Burn scars may change when fields are cleared, ploughed or prepared for the next crop.
- Weather-related limitations: Cloud cover and haze reduce the availability of usable satellite images.
- Accuracy concerns: Burnt-area maps need regular comparison with higher-resolution satellite imagery to verify their accuracy.
Way Forward
- Integrated monitoring: Active-fire detection and burnt-area mapping should be used together instead of relying exclusively on fire counts.
- Strengthening ground surveillance: District authorities should intensify field inspections, particularly after 3 PM, when conventional satellite observations are largely unavailable.
- District-level assessment: District Collectors should undertake ground assessments and strengthen enforcement against stubble burning.
- Improved satellite monitoring: Greater use of high-resolution satellite imagery and suitable sensors can improve the detection of small agricultural fires.
- Standardised methodology: India needs a standardised method for measuring the total area affected by stubble burning to ensure reliable assessment and comparison.
Conclusion: Accurate measurement of stubble burning requires a shift from merely counting active fires to assessing the actual area affected. A combination of satellite-based active-fire detection, burnt-area mapping and ground-level surveillance can provide a more comprehensive assessment. Reliable data will improve emission estimates, air-quality forecasting and the effectiveness of pollution-control measures such as GRAP.
Question: Counting active farm fires alone may not provide an accurate assessment of the extent of stubble burning in India. Examine the limitations of satellite-based monitoring and discuss how burnt-area mapping can improve the assessment of stubble burning.
Source: The Indian Express



