After Shenzhen How India Can Forge a Fourth Pole

sfg-2026
ForumIAS LATEST
      1. SFG 2027 Level-1 starts 21 Dec. 2026 at 7 AM | Entrance Test on 22 Nov. at 9:30 AM Click Here to know more →
      2. Interview Guidance initiative by ForumIAS – UPSC CSE 2026 Click Here to know more →
      3. FRC 2027: SFG Residential program | accepting application for Tranche-2 Click Here to know more →

UPSC Syllabus: Gs Paper 2- International Relation

Introduction

The proposed Shenzhen International System, involving the United States, China and Russia, raises concerns about the future of global multilateralism. Their growing preference for great-power diplomacy could marginalise emerging nations and weaken inclusive decision-making. India cannot take its rise as a global power for granted and must build a collective fourth pole based on sovereignty, strategic autonomy and international cooperation.

Changing Global Order: Growing Dominance of Great-Power Politics

  1. Emergence of Personalised Diplomacy: The leaders of the United States, China and Russia favour direct engagement, personalised leadership and transactional bargaining over established diplomatic processes.
  2. China’s Expanding Global Influence: Under Xi Jinping, China has expanded its global role through BRICS, the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership (RCEP) and the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI).
  3. Russia’s Opposition to the US-led Order: Russia has challenged the existing international order through military and diplomatic means, including Crimea’s annexation in 2014 and its invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
  4. America’s Shift Towards Unilateralism: Donald Trump’s America First policy, tariff wars and criticism of the World Trade Organisation (WTO) and North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) have weakened America’s traditional commitment to multilateral cooperation.
  5. Declining Institutional Cooperation: Direct negotiations among powerful leaders increasingly replace collective deliberation, common norms and inclusive decision-making through international institutions.
  6. Creation of a New Global Hierarchy: The exclusive participation of three major powers in important negotiations risks replacing the existing international hierarchy with another dominated by powerful states.
  7. Marginalisation of Affected Nations: Discussing Ukraine’s future without Ukraine and other European powers risks normalising decisions on international conflicts without consulting affected countries.
  8. Marginalisation of International Institutions: Exclusive negotiations among powerful leaders could weaken the role of international institutions in resolving conflicts and establishing global norms.

Implications of the Shenzhen System for India’s Strategic Interests

  1. Marginalisation in Global Decision-making: Exclusive coordination among three permanent United Nations Security Council (UNSC) members could reduce India’s influence over major international decisions and global governance.
  2. China’s Growing Strategic Advantage: China’s recognition as a co-manager of global affairs could strengthen its geopolitical influence, particularly in India’s neighbourhood and South Asia.
  3. Border Security Concerns: A possible United States-China understanding could reduce external pressure on Beijing and affect India’s strategic calculations along the Line of Actual Control (LAC).
  4. Changing Strategic Partnerships: Improved United States-China relations could affect India-US cooperation in the Indo-Pacific, while US-Russia rapprochement could change India’s defence and energy engagement with Moscow.
  5. Uncertainty over Regional Groupings: Changes in American strategic priorities towards China could influence the Quad’s relevance, functioning and future objectives.
  6. Challenges to India’s Global Representation: A stronger understanding among three permanent Security Council members could further complicate India’s efforts to secure permanent membership of the UNSC.
  7. Economic and Supply-chain Uncertainty: Changing US-China relations could reshape manufacturing networks and trade flows, affecting India’s opportunity to become an alternative global manufacturing hub.
  8. Technology and Energy Vulnerabilities: Cooperation among major powers on Artificial Intelligence (AI) and semiconductors could influence global standards, while changing US-Russia relations could affect oil prices and India’s energy security.

India’s Vision: Building a Collective Fourth Pole

  1. A Collective of Strategically Autonomous Nations: India should bring together countries from Japan, Taiwan, Morocco, Saudi Arabia, Ukraine, Germany, the Philippines and Brazil that seek sovereignty, peace and independent decision-making.
  2. Common Commitment to Sovereignty: The proposed collective should oppose expansionism, protect national sovereignty and reject international decisions imposed without proper consultation.
  3. India’s Leadership Through Trust: India should build partnerships through mutual respect and shared interests rather than relying solely on its population, civilisational heritage or historical standing.
  4. Diplomacy of Conscience and Civilian Protection: India should oppose mass civilian casualties, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity. Its mediation efforts, including on Ukraine, should prioritise civilian protection amid conflicts that have claimed nearly half a million lives in five years.

Way Forward: Diplomatic and Strategic Measures

A. Strengthening Diplomacy and Multilateral Cooperation

  1. Preserve Strategic Autonomy: India should maintain independent foreign-policy decisions and follow an issue-based approach towards major powers without joining exclusive geopolitical blocs.
  2. Strengthen Multi-alignment: India should deepen partnerships with the United States, Russia, France, Japan, Australia and other countries while avoiding excessive dependence on any single power.
  3. Rebuild Multilateral Presence: India should strengthen its role in the United Nations and consider hosting important United Nations and associated multilateral agencies.
  4. Support Global South Representation: India should promote equitable representation of developing countries and strengthen cooperation through BRICS, G20 and the Voice of Global South Summit.
  5. Strengthen International Law: India should lead the proposed collective in signing and ratifying important international instruments, including the Convention Against Torture and the Refugee Convention.

B. Strengthening Economic and Technological Capabilities

  1. Strengthen Economic Foundations: India’s low per capita income and deepening inequality could delay its emergence as an economic power. Sustained economic development is necessary to support its global ambitions.
  2. Diversify Critical Supply Chains: India should reduce dependence on individual countries for critical minerals, semiconductors, electronics and pharmaceuticals while developing reliable manufacturing capabilities.
  3. Achieve Technological Sovereignty: India should invest in indigenous Artificial Intelligence, quantum computing, semiconductors, space and telecommunications to reduce technological dependence and protect strategic autonomy.

C. Strengthening Defence and Strategic Security

  1. Achieve Defence Self-reliance: India should accelerate domestic defence manufacturing and research to reduce dependence on foreign suppliers and strengthen its military capabilities.
  2. Enhance Maritime Security: India should strengthen naval capabilities, maritime domain awareness and coastal surveillance while expanding security cooperation with Quad partners.
  3. Strengthen Border Infrastructure: India should improve connectivity, surveillance, logistics and military preparedness along the Line of Actual Control and western borders to maintain credible deterrence.
  4. Promote Nuclear Strategic Stability: Like-minded nuclear powers should develop common rules governing strategic arsenal growth and explore the possibility of a joint nuclear umbrella.

Conclusion

India’s rise as a global power requires sustained economic development, military self-reliance and credible diplomacy. By bringing strategically autonomous nations together, India can build a collective fourth pole. This will help protect national sovereignty, strengthen inclusive multilateralism and give emerging nations a greater role in shaping the global order.

Question for practice:

Examine how India can build a collective fourth pole to protect its strategic interests and strengthen multilateralism in the emerging global order.

Source: The Hindu; Indian Express

Print Friendly and PDF
Blog
Academy
Community